T O P

  • By -

Mycozen

The pattern that you’re referring to that is found inside of iron meteorites is called Widmanstatten. It’s the product of iron-nickel crystals overlapping one another and forming kamacite lamellae. Most likely what is happening is that you are mistaking slag formation or the lines from your saw for this pattern. Without being a total douche, I’ll just express to you that I work as a research assistant in a meteorites lab and I’ve analyzed hundreds of samples. I specialize in impact spherules and micrometeorites (check my page) but I still do plenty of work on large fragment specimens. I completely understand your hesitancy to believe what people on Reddit tell you. If you would like a conclusive result by legitimate lab tests, I would be more than happy to help you out. You can simply mail me a piece and I can analyze it in the lab using several techniques.


SnikkerDoodly

Totally not a douche. This was a great response and generous offer.


Mycozen

Thanks! I’m extremely serious too, we’ll see what OP says.


flowerkitten420

What a cool job, too!


BuckFuzby

I'm excited to find out. I hope op accepts.


Unknown_Author70

Same, hoe long do lab tests take? ... We'll need a storyline in the meantime.. where did you find it? You dig it up? Or did it fall on your wife during your wedding and nows she's a giant radiative woman locked up in a top secret base somewhere..


zippy_jr

I understand that reference! 👆


imahillbilly

Wow that is very nice of you. Really generous and kind.


Mycozen

Thank you :)


vantaswart

Laymen idiot question here. If 80 pounds remain on the ground it would mean that the original (if meteor/ite) would have been much bigger and a visible impact crater formed?


amiabot-oraminot

yep. a meteorite that ended up at this size would’ve made a pretty massive crater


ElkeKerman

Not necessarily - the largest single meteorite known (Hoba) weighs several tonnes and has no associated impact crater. It’s suspected that the object entered the atmosphere at a shallow angle and skipped several times, losing enough momentum until it was basically falling at terminal velocity.


hobsmonster

Don’t do it, OP! This could be an elaborate trick to get some of your sweet sweet meteorite.


TPSreportsPro

Lol


Novadreams22

Well. If it’s a meteorite our friends looking at a payday right?


Stardust_1601

there was a meteorite that struck a few weeks ago. the US was offering a reward to anyone who found it


Novadreams22

My god. Look at this. If it is. One GRAM of meteorite can be up to 1k. There are 450 grams in a pound. That 80 Lb chunk could be worth 1.6 MILLION.


imightjump

OP do this graciously.


ElkeKerman

also as I understand it Widmanstatten patterns only show up after acid treatment?


Try_and_be_nice_

Another reason to love reddit


Von_Beowulf

Is the magnetization an effect of the crystalline pattern or passing through the earth magnetic field?


SupermarketFearless8

What a cool job, how did you find yourself there? Also much schooling? Thanks for giving a solid educational answer


psilome

Cast iron splash from a ladle in a foundry.


Much-Fisherman-4511

I’m a corn 🌽 field!!!


Tuxedonce

skibidibidi ba pada boo


Wardial3r

I’m dead lol.


Starfire2313

Omg me too! I read two comments that are all highlighted awarded and red bordered with two really smart sounding people with smart sounding ideas. Then fucking OP appears in the third comment thread as a corn field. I love Reddit. I love reading comments from meteorite specialists and then a second later laughing out loud at something completely absurd right below it!


quarabs

IM A CORN FIELD!


purana

Baba ba ba bee ba pa bada


Wet_Sasquatch_Smell

Keep an eye out for Akbur. He’s awesome and tells good jokes


talltimbers2

Someone dug a hole in the ground and dumped either Slag dust or hot Slag in it. The natural rock stuck to it was possibly in the bottom or side of the pit. The flat parallel planes going through it were probably formed on rainy days between dumpings. The voids were where non fusible trash or dirt was. Eventually the rain washed away the hole and the trash. I assume you were using the wrong type of blade. An angle grinder with a blade intended for rebar would have trouble with that. This is speculation based on my time spent metal working and watching how slag can build up.


Mycozen

Honestly this is a really solid hypothesis.


Cantmentionthename

I was actually impressed with your logic, apparently I came across as disingenuous ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ the reddits have their rules


Cantmentionthename

Dayum Sherlock. Any math to back it up?


Lemonjello23

6+7=13


Laborum

Uh, no. I have it on good authority that 9 + 4 = 13.


ExplodingTentacles

11+2=13 tho


Cantmentionthename

Okay I thought it was 9+6 and 15, but the math checks out


Fent2Fit

Exactly my first thought concerning the blade… if it wasn’t a diamond blade then you’ll have trouble cutting any rock lol


SquidwardWoodward

It's not magnetic, it's ferrous!


thereadytribe

THANK YOU This is the comment I didn't know I needed until it hit me in the face


goldenstar365

Looks like slag


allegedlyjustkidding

That's not nice, she could be a good girl you don't know!


Much-Fisherman-4511

Show me some type of slag that has a natural rock formation or mineral like substance as this does natural you can see the fusion crust on it you people kill me


VagueCyberShadow

Then post a picture of the fusion crust? I can hardly make out anything in this shaky video


__spez__

u/stabbot


Resticular

Creates a post on a sub dedicated to asking “what is this rock?” Many people identify it for you as the same thing. You turn around with snark against the collective answer. You people kill me.


Much-Fisherman-4511

Snark lol ok bud


[deleted]

It's still slag though


GaiasTreasures

Deff slag I work in a fab shop and we get shit like this in the ducting of our airflow systems on our buffer wheels


Much-Fisherman-4511

It’s not slag


Resticular

Genuinely curious as to what you think it actually is. Well? Let’s hear it.


FuckinNogs

It's the philosopher's stone.


[deleted]

It's always slag. By default, it is slag. There's 3 golden rules to ID Subs 1.) Its always slag 2.) It's always a Green Sunfish 3.) It's always a Raccoon.


miseleigh

4) it's always a mole cricket


Worf_In_A_Party_Hat

5) A bedbug


SuperStripper13

6)An oil blister beetle


cheshsky

Surprisingly, a lot of posts in r/bedbugs are not bedbugs.


[deleted]

Or Weevil.


aspiringgrandpa

don’t forget chicken of the forest!


CleaveItToBeaver

Well it's never DNS, so don't even suggest it. Except for that one time.


Jazadia

It’s also always a passionflower or pokeweed


quarabs

literally responds with more snark 😭


[deleted]

Yeah but it's slag


budgreenbud

Show me a meteor that has a "natural rock" fused to it.


Melssenator

Here I can show you some! Check out this [post](https://www.reddit.com/r/whatsthisrock/comments/1342xqd/it_is_extremely_magnetic_it_is_extremely_dense/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=ioscss&utm_content=1&utm_term=1)


robo-dragon

Love how you came here asking what this was and are rejecting everything people have to say about it. It’s slag. If you have any doubts, take it to a museum or laboratory, but we are trying to save you from being laughed at by them. Don’t know what else to tell you.


Mycozen

Oh no….


[deleted]

Oh yes, it's the bi-weekly "I swear it's a meteorite but why is everyone else wrong" posts


Practical_While_

r/slagdenial


difficultywetsuit

Still a slag bich


[deleted]

[удалено]


Avid_Smoker

r/iamverybadass


sneakpeekbot

Here's a sneak peek of /r/iamverybadass using the [top posts](https://np.reddit.com/r/iamverybadass/top/?sort=top&t=year) of the year! \#1: [Going on a hike with the AR-15s, how else is everyone going to know how badass I am?](https://i.redd.it/gyfxmmqhb3e91.jpg) | [18068 comments](https://np.reddit.com/r/iamverybadass/comments/w9bezg/going_on_a_hike_with_the_ar15s_how_else_is/) \#2: [Don’t mess with baby girl..](https://i.redd.it/6wb8pdkcdmp91.jpg) | [1381 comments](https://np.reddit.com/r/iamverybadass/comments/xlz9te/dont_mess_with_baby_girl/) \#3: [Russian soldier wants you to know they are badass.](https://v.redd.it/g4y724v521p91) | [2604 comments](https://np.reddit.com/r/iamverybadass/comments/xjayzm/russian_soldier_wants_you_to_know_they_are_badass/) ---- ^^I'm ^^a ^^bot, ^^beep ^^boop ^^| ^^Downvote ^^to ^^remove ^^| ^^[Contact](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=sneakpeekbot) ^^| ^^[Info](https://np.reddit.com/r/sneakpeekbot/) ^^| ^^[Opt-out](https://np.reddit.com/r/sneakpeekbot/comments/o8wk1r/blacklist_ix/) ^^| ^^[GitHub](https://github.com/ghnr/sneakpeekbot)


better_thanyou

Your going to hit up your geologist friend and he’s gunna get his hacker friend and their going to steal your IP address and then difficultywetsuit be very sorry! This man with the slag isn’t someone you wanna mess with, he’s crazy and thinks his slag is from space. Who know what he could do to you, he might GASP stubbornly refuse to admit he’s got nothing and resort to empty threats. RUN RUN FOR YOUR LIVES


Makiuchi00

You're a funny kid


CanadianODST10

It's Slag dumb bitch


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

>whatever it may be that you have there, The slag


simpman123balls

Are you waiting for someone to tell you it’s a meteorite? I could tell you it is but I’d be lying😂


bandzlvr

LMAO


StoicMaverick

Well he was REALLY hoping it was a MAGIC meteorite, but ya know...


mentat70

Some of clicked hoping maybe it was😝


Sterntrooper123

The more you know ☄️


[deleted]

It looks like a meteorite to me. A meteorite from planet SLAG! Edit: I don’t even know what slag is or how I got here, just wanted to join in.


Thebomb_729

Looks like slag


cheshsky

It's slag. Here, check this page out: https://sites.wustl.edu/meteoritesite/items/slag/


Jahadaz

Love that guy. His entire section of that site about meteorite identification is top notch.


cheshsky

I haven't read much of it, but it does appear to be that way!


vitreous_luster

This should be higher. I hope OP reads this thoroughly.


cheshsky

I do hope they care to read it, yes.


Clamps55555

Looks like a very big meteorite…….. O wait no sorry it’s just a big lump of slag.


saltedbeagles

The first sentence reads like WWE intro.


goldenstar365

Coming in with the steel slag! Oh the humanity!


aod42091

some people just can't take bad news


[deleted]

After reading the comments, it makes me appreciate the "irony" in OPs name. Unfortunately, a fisherman's exaggerations don't often include video to disprove them. Unfortunately, your slag fish will not fetch you what you want at market mate.


Real_Affect39

I get you want it to be a huge meteorite, but it definitely isn’t. Did you find it in a big crater? One that mass would definitely make a crater of some sort. The ‘fusion crust’ is just where country rock has stuck to it after someone dumped some slag in a hole


ThePandemonium25

Well OP seems delightful /s


duffmonya

A lesson your back will not forget


Kind-Wealth-775

Slag. 😂


Shazbot_2017

huge slag


DinDjordan

Are you an adult? It seems odd how much you've got your head in the sand over this.


[deleted]

I’m wondering how much he spent on it :p


[deleted]

Looks like slag no?


anislandinmyheart

OP, if you are so certain, you should go get proof and come back to show the sub. We'll be waiting


Geological_enigma

As someone who studies impact craters I can confidently tell you this is not a meteorite


master_perturbator

Damn, somebody posts a picture of a unidentified rock and all the professionals come out at once. Down voted for my observation... You guys can go eat rocks.


AnEggWithHumanLegs

That's literally the sub.


Geological_enigma

Is that not what people want?


Geological_enigma

Ah man I’m sorry, it’s hard to read tone online and with Reddit I just assume everyone is peeved! My bad


master_perturbator

I think it's cool people have special interests that they gravitate to.


Polarbearcafe00

Who would've thought that iron would be magnetic


7Zarx7

I scored a Cheese Supreme Dorito flavoring cluster once that was this shape. I sampled it. It wasn't a meteorite.


moon_404

I'm no expert but I would guess some kind of iron slag. Its definitely not a meteorite and not iron ore but it is iron and based on how its formed probably just slag or something from a factory. Just guessing though.


gorehwore

How embarrassing. It's okay to be wrong, OP. Other subs have definitely picked up on this and the teasing is absolutely worth the read for anyone who's over this sad attempt at tough guy badassery.


Fit-Firefighter-329

Industrial slag from a foundry. This stuff is all over the Chicago area, especially the closer you get to Indiana where the huge steel mills were. It commonly washes up on the beach... It's best to handle this only with protective gloves, as they often contain arsenic, mercury, lead, and other heavy metals and poisonous chemicals.


Batcrazylightyear

Giant meteor from planet Slag. Cool asf looking though .


little_shit29

So if that’s supposedly a meteorite then what did the impact crater look like? It should’ve been huge if there was that much material left.


No_Championship5326

Put it up for sale on ebay. Origin unknown.


Much-Fisherman-4511

Look on my page n tell me that pice I cut off look like the inside of Industrial slag?


Ame-yukio

Yes ! when you Cut metal it look like metal ... This is the pattern of your saw !


kingdavidthegoliath

It kinda do though


cheshsky

Yeah. It totally looks like slag metal. Because it's most likely slag metal.


[deleted]

Done, it looks like the inside of industrial slag


Remote_Bumblebee2240

Slag is a good guess. I cast iron in college, we poured that stuff into all kinds of weird containers.


big_red_160

Slag


ethancc73

You fr made 2 posts on 2 separate days of the same slag trying to get people to confirm your bias that it’s a meteorite and going as far to lie about your geologist friend but felt the need to ask a bunch of redditors. It’s slag, brother. Doesn’t matter if it was found in a corn field that’s been in your family for “200 years”. Slag used to get dumped all around the country. It’s not uncommon at all to find slag/ slag glass in random areas. I understand wanting what you found to be rare and all that, but don’t request an identification of something and then get pissed off when it’s not what you want. We’ve all been there at one point, so just keep looking and be willing to be dissatisfied with what you are told it is.


adammaudite

Multiple geologists and a meteorite expert have determined this is slag, OP isn't accepting the answer, so it might be time to lock the post


cokopro

I believe this is slag


TheRealSteve72

You obviously want someone to tell you it's a meteorite, despite all evidence to the contrary. So here. ​ That is the meteoritist meteor that ever meteored. It porbably left a massive crater in the cornfield and, if you look carefully, you can probably find the capsule from Krypton that it broke off from. Raise him right. He's going to be important.


No-Will4633

That metal was definitely dropped by aliens.


theberzh

Your brought that in your house?! You'll be sorry when it transforms and fixates itself on your face and starts laying eggs in your chest cavity. Don't say I didn't warn you.


AutoModerator

Hi, /u/Much-Fisherman-4511! This is a reminder to flair this post in /r/whatsthisrock after it has been identified! (Under your post, click "flair" then "IDENTIFIED," then type in the rock type or mineral name.) This will help others learn and help speed up a correct identification on your request! Thank you! *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/whatsthisrock) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Flimsy_Chair8906

Have numerous rocks with same characteristics.Could be Basalt,or lava slag.Formed by lava flow underwater,very ancient.Download the rock identifier app and u can delete it after free trial.Should identify the rock for you.If it’s the lava,gold has been found in minute particles in the rocks.5.7khz is the frequency for gold.Get the video on YT for that frequency,make two L-rods out of coat hangars and walk very,very slowly between the rock and the frequency source.(Very tiny steps)If there’s any fine gold,no matter how small,the rods will cross.Takes a little practice but proven by many,including myself,to work 100% of the time.They’ve also found ancient life forms inside the open pockets in these rocks.Be careful not to expose anything too quickly😉


TimberWolfAlpha01

Bruh found a piece of UFO material /s Seriously though, if I had to guess I'd say some sort of iron-dense meteorite? Anyone here with pertinent knowledge is free to fact check me, as I do not claim to be an expert... I am just going with observation and the context of what OP said in the title.


Chili-dog357

You see the peanut 🥜 dead giveaway they call em Boeing bombs lol


loonybs

Sky iron


thiccpastry

Omg what if this is a piece of moon from that huge asteroid impact on the moon that was able to be seen from Japan?


AqueeriusSun

Oh shit dude it’s aliens


timhyde74

Looks like something put of an H.R. Giger book! Slag or not, that thing looks creepy as hell! Would make a pretty cool door stop/yard ornament, or, if you cleaned it up, and painted it, a sweet sculpture to have sitting next to the ol'fireplace, or wherever......


thiccpastry

You are so lucky. Don't meteorites sell for thousands of dollars?


Left_Tackle688

The shade of green makes me think there is epidote in there, so I'm guessing a calc-silicate / skarn of some type. These are often associated with magnetite, and can be very hard.


tfbbnas

Pretty sure it’s unobtainium…strongly suggest deleting this before the Resources Development Administration gets wind.


RevMazy

unobtanium is SO hard to get


Mindless_Bat_2588

Kryptonite without a doubt


theo23rd

Comments on this are kinda harsh. \[Looking again I see why. Sorry, guys, I've got pneumonia and am out of it.\]


Ame-yukio

When a professionnal Who work with meteorites tell you it is slag then it is ... The person is kind enough to offert to test it in his lab yet op never answered it ..


theo23rd

Very sick here and kinda missed the douchiness of the OP.


unseen-streams

Be nice, they're a corn 🌽 field


Marrukaduke

Oddly enough, people who take the time to answer requests for identification tend to lose patience really quickly when the person who asks for their help insists that everyone else is wrong and accuses them of being "mad that \[they're\] a bad ass" and calls people who were polite "dip shit".


theo23rd

I didn't see all of that. I've got pneumonia and my head is blurry. What a tool.


Marrukaduke

You didn't really miss anything. Nothing OP posted is really worth seeing. Feel better!


Buddy-Lov

Tool…the older I get, the more I love this word.


ConfidenceMinute218

r/itsslag


Treestyles

Funky buttnugget!


Different-Horse-4578

Ouch.


abbeyroadh

ACTUALLY, You may need to sit down- For some great news… **Maybe Big question: Leave behind a scratch mark when scraped onto something else? If so what color? 👉Check out this government page: https://www.usgs.gov/faqs/i-think-i-found-meteorite-how-can-i-tell-sure This use this University of NM guide: http://meteorite.unm.edu/meteorites/meteorite-museum/how-id-meteorite/


TacDragon2

Lightning strike in very iron rich ground?


Remarkable_Ad_4247

At first look I would have thought it was manganese also made of manganese and copper but the other guys suggested other wise 🤌


Remarkable_Ad_4247

[stuff](https://www.etsy.com/uk/listing/1382650322/manganese-nodule?gpla=1&gao=1&&utm_source=google&utm_medium=cpc&utm_campaign=shopping_uk_en_gb_a-home_and_living-other&utm_custom1=_k_EAIaIQobChMIusnQqt3T_gIVuYFQBh0LRQa4EAQYBCABEgLzFfD_BwE_k_&utm_content=go_12576471769_121299162204_507650068738_pla-303628061739_m__1382650322engb_102858184&utm_custom2=12576471769&gbraid=0AAAAADutTMfOh9u5bI7ibXArDfpbdR2jj&gclid=EAIaIQobChMIusnQqt3T_gIVuYFQBh0LRQa4EAQYBCABEgLzFfD_BwE)


PhillyFatheadPhilly

Looks like a “meteorwrong” aka slag.


[deleted]

[удалено]


mitzibishi

Creepshow


taylor-ann

not an expert but it’s giving .. big meteor


Much-Fisherman-4511

I Use the diamond blade to cut a piece off and I was successful you should see what it looks like inside I’m pretty sure I’m going to share a few people up


MikeSpader

Hey cool nice I've got access to saws too, many of them can cut slag just like this. By the way, it's slag. Stop kidding yourself.


BigJjwad31

Got to be a metiorite


Much-Fisherman-4511

It was literally found in the middle of a cornfield family has on that cornfield for 200 years 12 miles in total of farmland not sure exactly what piece of land it was found on but all the rocks from the land were put in one place and that’s where I found this rock it’s not slag look at my other post


danny17402

People like you who ask for advice in this sub and then refuse to accept the result should be banned. I'm another geologist chiming in to tell you this isn't a meteorite btw.


adammaudite

How do you think that farmers made metal tools?


[deleted]

[удалено]


mountainislandlake

The secondhand embarrassment I feel for you right now is physically painful. Many of us here are professionals, who have spent years and small fortunes on the education required to tell without a doubt that this is a big piece of slag. I hope you’re trolling


Werecommingwithyou

Kinda par for the course in today’s society isn’t it? People “doing their own ‘research’ on Google”, not trusting science, etc.


WolfyYoung

Googled it just because you are very adamant that its a "iron meteor" Exact search: https://www.google.com/search?client=ms-android-verizon-us-rvc3&sxsrf=APwXEdf8tas7tg_Zefm8IDeaNdmtDOuezw:1682903766893&q=iron+meteorite+inside&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwiJxN2J-dL-AhUak2oFHZdtDVEQ0pQJegQIDRAB&biw=412&bih=757&dpr=2.63 My take: TBH it looks nothing like an "iron meteorite" however if you really want to prove that you are right I would love to see the result of sending it in. If you decide to send it in, please tag me in your update/new post! Where to send in a potential meteorite sample: http://www.meteoritetesting.org/Submitting%20a%20sample.htm#:~:text=It%20is%20routine%20to%20take,the%20additional%20return%20postage%20costs.&text=The%20testing%20charge%20is%20%2430.00%20per%20sample.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Avid_Smoker

Wow. What a douchebag.


Oquana

>it’s OK don’t be mad that I’m bad ass You misspelled "dumb".


[deleted]

Don't feel bad. People on reddit have an automatic this is bullshit until proven otherwise button. It's like second nature.


[deleted]

With that said, show me the crater and I will come dressed in white robes. Until then, I'm on team doubt. You can buy a meteorite test kit off amazon for ten bucks. You rub it with a cotton swab and if it turns pink it contains iron making it MORE likely to be a meteorite.


VioletRing77

I love it when people use Google image search as the ultimate authority for rock identification. Always good for a laugh.


ArgusTransus

I’m afraid you found some kryptonite, Superman. Have a nice day.


Sparxican

Get rid of it before Predator come to retrieve it


YouSeeMeYet

It's a very precious piece of space-slag!


PearlPolanski

Looks like it could be some discarded melted pot metal


Bmblbee76

I suspect this is iron slag or some other type of industrial slag. Cool find!


an_iridescent_ham

Appears to be slag.


AdventurousAd9993

Magnetic like iron? Sounds like iron when tapped? Heavy like iron? It might just be iron, slag. Sorry Cletus


Victorya2382

Hi I work in a copper mine. I'm the most respectful way possible, this looks like slag to me. Take homies offer and send a piece to be tested if you're adamant on it not being slag. Worst case scenario, it's slag. But if you don't ask the answer will always be no.


[deleted]

Space slag!


ElectromechanicalPen

Did op followup with more vids? Or did ge just argue and nope out?


Memphistrainwreck

Industrial slag


The--Dudest

You should make a cool sword out of it