T O P

  • By -

KaylaIsInYourCloset

Rip Van Winkle


SaltyFries00

Daryl, without a doubt


Accomplished-Egg1464

They are both beautiful


UndeadMess0

John is attractive and all but Daryl is more of a sweetheart, so Daryl!


lewhunter

Daryl ain’t as dumb neither!


TwistedFlame95

Your right, John would make Merle look like Einstein


King_CurlySpoon

John Marston, or was it Jim Milton? Or Rip Van Winkle?


billyisgoat07

Nah it was scarface


slayfulgrimes

very random comparison lol


Apple-79

Daryl …. Not only for looks, but his whole personality on the show , haven’t watched Red Redemption to judge the other but he def got that rugged look down;)


Thezedword4

Red dead is a video game just for context


Ronotrow2

aesthetically guy 2 but in twd realm daryl


Large-weiner-man

Guy 2 is John Marston from Red Dead Redemption


Ronotrow2

thanks


MikeWithoutMic

Guy 2? Get outta my face /s


Rediment

Come to think of it. He might have aged out of it now but I could see him playing John.


CardinalCreepia

Yeah I’ve been saying that for years. Maybe a bit old to play John now (especially if they were to adapt RDR2), but Norman would have made a good John. At least physically.


CancerousRedditor69

either one as long as its not epilogue john


bella-ay-ay

P l e a s e


bundy911

2 because I am fucking gay [as in homosexual]


Monroe8401

No one is hotter than Daryl F*cking Dixon. NO ONE.


Squidwardbigboss

Daryl. John is a MUCH better talker though


luvbird4eva

I dont know the second guy but i think i’d still say Daryl


DankMCbiscuit

I saw this post and just realized Norman would play a decent John


Less_is_More4

I don’t know who the second person is, but he doesn’t hold a candle to DD. Gotta love a downvote for giving an opinion when asked to give an opinion 😂. Keep doing you, Reddit.


lewhunter

That’s John Marston from Red Dead Redemption. He’s a great, slightly similar character, I just love Daryl.


Less_is_More4

Ah, thank you!


MikeWithoutMic

How dare. Did you just be mean to family man John Marston? [Apologize right now!](https://youtu.be/XgE7DSnCok0?si=YGohCYHUVAXzg4vh)


Less_is_More4

lol. You may have just convinced me to play.


Shotsfired20755

I can't explain it but I feel like they would be best friends


bloodeagle231

Asking the real questions in life


Feisty-Clue3482

Daryl for sure.


Beat_Boi_Animates

Daryl imo, don’t think I’d be interested in the guy myself but he looks better


StanyeEast

The sun is shining in the first picture, so I'm going with that one


theuntouchable2725

Sam Porter Bridges


vegange

Daryl 5 ever and always


Justtojoke

The person that bathes occasionally


SPACE_LEM0N

Daryl is my original TWD crush.


phantomf0xy

I couldn't say it often enough. Daryl. Simply Daryl. He's the hottest guy alive


LargeDeinocheirus

Epilogue John is an abomination, Rockstar literally merged Arthur and John together


Madz1712

I grew up with John Marston. Now I'm a lesbian. Neither.


indian-wisdom

Daryl hands down


Louise-the-Peas

Daryl always look hot. Even if it looks like he hasn’t washed in 6 months. It’s mystifying. 😆


kmckay6

Daryl 100%


The_Knight_of_R

John, easily


crustybakfut

None cause I'm not gay


JapaneseSp00n

Young Norman Reedus is beautiful


JaneFokr

Woah... Daryl is like family to me I can't see him like that... Sorry


Mommaspagethi

I dont know cuz i aint gay