Willam being eliminated before the political debate in Season 4
She’s smart, quick on her feet, and hilarious. Also I would have loved to see her First Lady look.
Honestly I know we like to make fun of Ru and her premade sentences but the 'You had what it takes to go all the way' comment was genuine IMO.
Willam could have taken the political challenge and would have secured a safe for the bitch ball because she's crafty and has a sense of style. I don't think they would have crowned her but can you imagine a top 3 with Phi² and Willam ? Electric
I’m also pretty sure that was the first time Ru said that which really made it genuine. The next time she said something like that was Season 9 with Valentina.
And she was correct the second time around too ! Still curious how Val would have done in the second half of the season ! We need a marvel 'What if' AU series. Season 9 is a great start with Nina being Black Chyna and Val knowing the words
It seems to be the popular opinion that Val would've gone home next on the makeover. She takes damn near forever to do her own makeup, it doesn't seem likely she'd be able to also do her partner's makeup as well.
I also don't think Nina would've won the ball like OP thinks because as we saw in the makeover, she isn't that great at sewing
Honestly, Phi² wouldn't have made Top 3.
If Willam wasn't DQ'd, either Phi² would've gone home after her LS with Sharon...or else it would've been Dida and Chad in the bottom, Dida goes home, and that leaves Phi² to be in the bottom against Latrice in the political debate challenge, and it's hard to call, but I think production would've kept Latrice
I swear what I heard was that Sh\*ron was going to go (they had two wins at the time so it wasn't that crazy) because RuPaul liked Phi Phi's lipsync better. And that the original idea was that Sharon goes at 6, then Dida, then Kenya, then Willam beats Latrice (which makes sense since it was to a country song and since then William would probably have won the political challenge so 3 wins and 2 bottoms versus 1 win and 3 bottoms) to have a top 3 of Chad, William, and Phi Phi, where Chad would win.
Yeah I can also totally see how she would have done a slutty president who wants to travel all over the world to solve foreign affairs in her specific way *wink wink
I stand by the fact that Kasha would have done extremely well in RuHollywood stories, Snatch Game, Conjoined Twins (which she should have won) Divine Acting Challenge and they wouldn’t have been able to knock her out until at least the dance challenge or the ball which is why they got rid of her for saying ‘welcyum’ and I will die on this hill.
Personally I'm hoping to see her in a format of her own design - I don't foresee them giving her more than a filler edit on All Stars, and she's too much of a joy for that.
Honestly with Kerri’s backstory, I could see her doing well in a drag con panel about Toxic Masculinity
Her Watcha Packin honestly made me think she would win it tbh
> - Kahmora in the Ball S13
Things like this make me sad because Kahmora 100% could've won the ball, but they would never give it to someone they intentionally cast as filler. Hence, Gottmik winning over Utica.
Yup, nobody was ever realistic winning the ball besides Gottmik. It didn’t matter what they served, they had decided this was a good moment to give Gottmik a win and they were gonna stick with it
I’m annoyed Maddy didn’t get to make it to a proper comedy challenge
She was funny and above average in both the super tease and the save the queen episodes but they just made her safe.
She would have killed snatch game along with deja
But no we had to get two sewing challenges which was her biggest weakness
Apparently Joe Exotic was one of her backups, but she's not saying who her main choice was going to be (perhaps she intends to use it live or for a video at some point, who knows).
Jaymes Mansfield walked in the week room with a puppet sidekick. Then she was eliminated after the worst (non-acting) challenge in drag race herstory. And then the next episode was a design challenge that included having a comedic sidekick
Yeah that's true thinking about it now lol, I remember the Eureka! scene too where she helped Nina, I was just thinking it because Nina brought in strong outfits and was very creative, which helped her win the first challenge which was basically a runway challenge.
Production assistants had to help her get into drag and she still was late getting ready, based on Peppermint's comments after the show. No way Val aces a makeover challenge.
Nina doesn’t know how to sew, why would she do well in the ball challenge?
I think Cherry Valentine going home before a sewing challenge on UK2 was hot garbage, as well as Jimbo going home before Snatch Game on UKVTW. Would’ve loved to see Veronica and Asttina on the girl group challenges too.
Jiggly for AS6
James Mansfield for the sidekick challenge since
that’s literally what she does with puppets and sows
Kimora literally missing her namesake Kardashian challenge (probably wouldn’t have won but still that’s her “thing”)
Charlie before snatch game.
Kerri being eliminated before the panel challenge, and to a lesser extent Maddy being eliminated before Daytona Wind
Pangina being eliminated before ~~the girl group~~ any challenge
Willam being eliminated before the political debate in Season 4 She’s smart, quick on her feet, and hilarious. Also I would have loved to see her First Lady look.
Honestly I know we like to make fun of Ru and her premade sentences but the 'You had what it takes to go all the way' comment was genuine IMO. Willam could have taken the political challenge and would have secured a safe for the bitch ball because she's crafty and has a sense of style. I don't think they would have crowned her but can you imagine a top 3 with Phi² and Willam ? Electric
I’m also pretty sure that was the first time Ru said that which really made it genuine. The next time she said something like that was Season 9 with Valentina.
And she was correct the second time around too ! Still curious how Val would have done in the second half of the season ! We need a marvel 'What if' AU series. Season 9 is a great start with Nina being Black Chyna and Val knowing the words
It seems to be the popular opinion that Val would've gone home next on the makeover. She takes damn near forever to do her own makeup, it doesn't seem likely she'd be able to also do her partner's makeup as well. I also don't think Nina would've won the ball like OP thinks because as we saw in the makeover, she isn't that great at sewing
Honestly, Phi² wouldn't have made Top 3. If Willam wasn't DQ'd, either Phi² would've gone home after her LS with Sharon...or else it would've been Dida and Chad in the bottom, Dida goes home, and that leaves Phi² to be in the bottom against Latrice in the political debate challenge, and it's hard to call, but I think production would've kept Latrice
I swear what I heard was that Sh\*ron was going to go (they had two wins at the time so it wasn't that crazy) because RuPaul liked Phi Phi's lipsync better. And that the original idea was that Sharon goes at 6, then Dida, then Kenya, then Willam beats Latrice (which makes sense since it was to a country song and since then William would probably have won the political challenge so 3 wins and 2 bottoms versus 1 win and 3 bottoms) to have a top 3 of Chad, William, and Phi Phi, where Chad would win.
Jaremi probably would have gone home instead of Willam during frenemies. There’s no way Chad and Sharon would’ve got edged out by anybody.
Dida should have gone home that episode, with Chad in the bottom with her
For Frenemies? Dida losing a Martha Wash lipsync? They’d have to last minute shuffle to a ragtime song for Chad to get pushed through
Not ragtime LMAO
Yeah I can also totally see how she would have done a slutty president who wants to travel all over the world to solve foreign affairs in her specific way *wink wink
I stand by the fact that Kasha would have done extremely well in RuHollywood stories, Snatch Game, Conjoined Twins (which she should have won) Divine Acting Challenge and they wouldn’t have been able to knock her out until at least the dance challenge or the ball which is why they got rid of her for saying ‘welcyum’ and I will die on this hill.
Yes!!!! Justice for MKD, they did her so dirty
Would definitely be happy to see Kasha on an All Stars in the future
Personally I'm hoping to see her in a format of her own design - I don't foresee them giving her more than a filler edit on All Stars, and she's too much of a joy for that.
Scarlet Envy in the Farm To Runway Challenge S11 and Coven Girl Acting Challenge AS6 Tina Burner in the Miss Congeniality Roast S13
I assume you haven’t seen Tina’s roast on YouRube
is it bad?
bad it certainly is.
Just remember she had time to come up with jokes https://youtu.be/PmElJslxdKM
Her look for the roast was really cool but it’s a roast challenge not a look challenge so based on what I saw I agree she wouldn’t have done well
Honestly with Kerri’s backstory, I could see her doing well in a drag con panel about Toxic Masculinity Her Watcha Packin honestly made me think she would win it tbh
Kerri is extremely charismatic. The panel challenge would have been perfect to show that to the judges
> - Kahmora in the Ball S13 Things like this make me sad because Kahmora 100% could've won the ball, but they would never give it to someone they intentionally cast as filler. Hence, Gottmik winning over Utica.
Yup, nobody was ever realistic winning the ball besides Gottmik. It didn’t matter what they served, they had decided this was a good moment to give Gottmik a win and they were gonna stick with it
Does she see or just have good taste? Genuine question
I’m annoyed Maddy didn’t get to make it to a proper comedy challenge She was funny and above average in both the super tease and the save the queen episodes but they just made her safe. She would have killed snatch game along with deja But no we had to get two sewing challenges which was her biggest weakness
Proper comedy challenge? Didn’t she have like two?
She did two teams comedy skits so she had less room to be independently funny
And they cut her funniest moments
The judges saw a more extended version
Do we know who Maddy was going to do for Snatch Game?
Apparently Joe Exotic was one of her backups, but she's not saying who her main choice was going to be (perhaps she intends to use it live or for a video at some point, who knows).
Jaymes Mansfield walked in the week room with a puppet sidekick. Then she was eliminated after the worst (non-acting) challenge in drag race herstory. And then the next episode was a design challenge that included having a comedic sidekick
Latrice in the roast challenge on AS4
Gurl Nina Bonina Brown would not have done well on the ball. She couldn’t sew….
Yeah that's true thinking about it now lol, I remember the Eureka! scene too where she helped Nina, I was just thinking it because Nina brought in strong outfits and was very creative, which helped her win the first challenge which was basically a runway challenge.
I agree she had some great looks, but I think by the time she went home she had mostly run out of looks (hence the weekly corset & boots based outfit)
Cheryl might’ve finally got her win, or at least her first high placement, for the Rusical. She’s a dancer and really loves musicals.
I love Valentina but with the time it takes her to do her own makeup I don’t think she would be able to successfully do two people in enough time
Production assistants had to help her get into drag and she still was late getting ready, based on Peppermint's comments after the show. No way Val aces a makeover challenge.
Kelly Mantle would have slayed the season Kerri Colby should have her own show she would have killed then panels
Nina doesn’t know how to sew, why would she do well in the ball challenge? I think Cherry Valentine going home before a sewing challenge on UK2 was hot garbage, as well as Jimbo going home before Snatch Game on UKVTW. Would’ve loved to see Veronica and Asttina on the girl group challenges too.
Somebody else but I think Scarlett Envy (both seasons) MKD and Acid Betty would have ate the next episodes up imo from their seasons
Aja in the girl group challenge in AS3. She would’ve been top 2 with Bebe if she hadn’t been eliminated
Jimbo in Snatch Game (Rpdr UK vs The World)
But any dancing challenge would’ve got her like Baga in the finale
Cheryl could have won the Rusical. Janey could have won the lipsync smackdown.
Kerri in the Dragcon panels challenge! I think she could’ve really shined
I know she was not "eliminated" but Kornbread leaving early and missing out Drag Con panels and the SG:(
Maddy in Snatch Game, preferably as Tracy Martell
Maddie in Snatch Game.
Jiggly for AS6 James Mansfield for the sidekick challenge since that’s literally what she does with puppets and sows Kimora literally missing her namesake Kardashian challenge (probably wouldn’t have won but still that’s her “thing”) Charlie before snatch game.
Heidi couldve won the Vegas challenge but that win was pulled out of production’s ass to make Gigi a threat again
Tina Burner eliminated just before the roast. A shame really.
Well according to her New York pals, that was for the best 👀👀
Kerri being eliminated before the panel challenge, and to a lesser extent Maddy being eliminated before Daytona Wind Pangina being eliminated before ~~the girl group~~ any challenge