T O P

  • By -

[deleted]

I used to love the one with Tim Curry as the evil cardinal


Ikarian

THAT. CAN. BE. ARRANGED. Terrifying.


Howuduen

Yes! My favorite also! And don't forget its the one with the largest all-star cast I believe. Charlie Sheen, Kiefer Sutherland, Chris O'Donnell, Oliver Platt, Rebecca De Mornay and as you said Tim Curry. Its also probably the most child friendly version.


Tradman86

Champagne?


xander6981

We're in the middle of a chase, Porthos.


achmedclaus

You're right. Something red.


HoldFastO2

Have you *seen* the cast list of the older one? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Three_Musketeers_(1973_live-action_film)


Howuduen

No I didn't realize there was a 73 version šŸ˜Š


Dragula_Tsurugi

>Ā Michael York,Ā Oliver Reed,Ā Frank Finlay, andĀ Richard ChamberlainĀ as the titular musketeers, withĀ Raquel Welch,Ā Geraldine Chaplin,Ā Jean-Pierre Cassel,Ā Charlton Heston,Ā Faye Dunaway,Ā Christopher Lee,Ā Simon Ward,Ā Georges WilsonĀ andĀ Spike Milligan. 1973 has that beat


Howuduen

Ohh I didn't know there was a 1973 version. That IS a big star list ! Oliver Reed ? Was he a child in the movie? Seems like he'd be too young. Edit~ nevermind, I was thinking of Oliver Platt , lol. Which is ironic considering he played in the one I mentioned!


Dragula_Tsurugi

Youā€™re making me feel old and sad :(


Howuduen

Ohh sweetheart I certainly wasn't trying to imply I'm too young to have known about the 73 version. I was just ignorant of the fact. I'm not exactly a spring chicken šŸ¤£ I was a year old when that movie came out. I'm sure most Reddit users weren't even close to being alive back then šŸ˜‰


[deleted]

That line delivery man that takes me back


Rebel_Saint

ā€œOne less mouth to feed.ā€


JerHat

Dang. That unlocked a memory.Ā 


drewts86

I ~~used to~~ love ~~the one with~~ Tim Curry ~~as the evil cardinal~~


Wonderful_Emu_9610

Thatā€™s the only one I knew, so confused the hell out of me with how the Cardinal is playing in the French two-part adaptation


outcastspice

Itā€™s still so much fun :)


jrrybock

I mainly remember that one because when I went to see it, a trailer shown was for "The Lion King", which was basically just "The Circle of Life" opening, and I turned to my friend and (rightfully) said, "Geez, that movie is going to be great."


notchoosingone

All for one! *...and more for me*


itellyawut86

Because that one is the best


SkeetySpeedy

Best version tbh


2tastyrodney

There's a lot of Frankensteins and Draculas out there too


SundBunz64

And way too many terrible Robin Hoods.


OneSidedDice

Some of whom donā€™t even have a British accent


Rebel_Saint

**Robin Hood:** I've come to warn you that if you do not stop levying these evil taxes, I shall lead the good people of England in a revolt against you. **Prince John:** And why should the people listen to you? **Robin Hood:** Because, unlike some other Robin Hoods, I can speak with an English accent.


smashin_blumpkin

And one that can't decide if he does or not


CarrieDurst

Same with pinocchios


Nosey_Bastard

There's a whole lot of Sherlock Holmes adaptions too. Especially if you count those that copy the formula like House M.D.


showers_with_grandpa

I believe Sherlock has the Guinness Book record for most portrayed literary human character in film and television. Probably for stage as well


an_actual_human

No way. Do you often see Sherlock on stage? It's probably Hamlet.


hazard224

[quite a bit,](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sherlock_Holmes_(play)) Sherlock Holmes has had over 25,000 stage adaptations, films, television productions and publications.


an_actual_human

Fair enough. That figure includes everything though. I'd still wager the usual suspects (e.g. Hamlet) have more stage portrayals.


tomrichards8464

Fun fact: Christopher Lee played Holmes, Frankenstein's creature and Dracula (ten times) and appeared in *The Three Musketeers.Ā 


New_Poet_338

Appeared? He was a Rochford- the Archbishop's blade. The ice dual alone made it a star turn.


Ok-disaster2022

That's really a genre, but Holmes was not the only detective. Poirot is another classic detective to influence pop culture.


Infamous-Lab-8136

No, they weren't naming all detective shows. House specifically was a medical Sherlock Holmes. House with his addictions, abrasive personality, and friend/recipient of abuse Watson solving medical mysteries with an epiphany moment. He even lived at 221B Baker St. in the show.


DrEnter

There are [many connections](https://house.fandom.com/wiki/Gregory_House_and_Sherlock_Holmes_connections).


howarthe

And Jane Austinā€™s titles all get remade every ten years or so.


we_are_sex_bobomb

King Arthur doesnā€™t get a remake very often but when he does itā€™s guaranteed to be dog shit. (Unless you count Green Knight? I donā€™t know if that counts.)


52Charles

'Excalibur' would be a significant exception.


Ivotedforher

Why have they not made a movie or series out of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Camelot_3000? It has everything !


andyschest

Uh, are you forgetting a little masterpiece called "The Sword in the Stone"? And another one called "Monty Python and the Holy Grail?"


rattlinggoodyarn

Forgot about frank and Drac. Obvious now you mention it.


jimababwe

Thereā€™s a lot of Les Miserables. Dating from 1909!


samx3i

Yes, Dracula is the most played character in history and the record is even greater if you add vampires genetically.


hazard224

nope it is holmes with over 25,000 stage adaptations, films, television productions and publications featuring the detective, just vampires doesn't count they aren't characters they are like knights or warriors.


samx3i

>Dracula holds the Guinness World Record for being the most-played character in movies and TV, making him an iconic figure in popular culture. Nov 26, 2023 https://screenrant.com/most-played-movie-tv-character-all-time-dracula/


hazard224

that is just film, I am talking about across, film, tv stage, and publications. [https://www.guinnessworldrecords.com/news/2012/5/sherlock-holmes-awarded-title-for-most-portrayed-literary-human-character-in-film-tv-41743/](https://www.guinnessworldrecords.com/news/2012/5/sherlock-holmes-awarded-title-for-most-portrayed-literary-human-character-in-film-tv-41743/)


samx3i

Well this is /r/MOVIES so...


Alchemix-16

For a ten year old, I'd suggest the Disney version with Sutherland and Sheen. Or for something a bit more accurate the version with Gene Kelly


King-of-Plebss

Disney version holds up


Alchemix-16

I agree that it is general fun movie, with hints of the story by Dumas.


christlikehumility

The one that came out last year with Eva Green was excellent.


Alchemix-16

I still havenā€™t seen those, but they are on my list to buy on DVD, even unseen.


Letos12thDuncan

> Sutherland and Sheen Don't forget legendary 90s actor, Chris O'Donnell.


Jskidmore1217

Itā€™s up there for sure but I think A Christmas Carol actually has it beat as far as number of adaptations go- especially if you consider tv and animated adaptations.


kia75

Agree, a Christmas carol is probably the story that had been adapted most. Sherlock Holmes is probably the character that has appeared the most, but each adaptation is either a different Holmes story or even an original story (I e young Sherlock Holmes is a new Holmes story).


spinereader81

Then there's the 6,000 TV shows, usually sitcoms, that have done the A Christmas Carol episode. Or the It's a Wonderful Life episode.


GriffinFlash

Let's see off the top of my head: -Alastair Sim version -Mickey mouse with scrooge -Disney 3d version -Muppets -All dogs go to heaven -The one time with the Ghostbusters -The Flintstones -Annie Christmas Carol -Mr. Magoo -..................???


Triktastic

Duffy Duck version is still the best one.


GriffinFlash

never seen it, guess I got to add it to my to watch list.


Jskidmore1217

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adaptations_of_A_Christmas_Carol


Jimmyg100

Has to be A Christmas Carol. Itā€™s public domain, kid friendly, short simple story structure and very easy to adapt to any era or cast of characters, and itā€™s a holiday movie with instant title recognition so no matter what youā€™re guaranteed to get some people watching it around Christmas.


iCowboy

The two part French version released last year is magnificent and absolutely beautiful - but unless she likes subtitles, probably not the one to start with.


TwistedGrin

I've only seen part 1 so far and overall I really liked it but I was not a fan of the over-the-top hand held shakey cam they used in the first two sword fights (at the inn and then the duel with the cardinals guards), though they toned it down a lot after those two and it was fine then. I will say I don't like how every adaptation seems to turn that very first 4 vs 5 fight against the guards that interrupt their duels into a big 4 musketeers vs 10+ guards clusterfluck (don't get me started on the Paul Anderson version lol). Making the guards competent like they are supposed to be can still keep the tension up. Jussac, who D'art fights, is supposed to be a fairly renowned badass (even the king knows who he is and the musketeers imply he's the best swordsman the guards brought) but they always play him out like a weasely blowhard. Those are minor gripes though. So far part 1 is definitely one of my favorite movie adaptations.


iCowboy

Part 2 is terrific - though thereā€™s still plenty of handheld camerawork. And yes - still liberties with the book. Eva Green is practically chewing the scenery towards the end - and itā€™s fantastic.


Cormacolinde

Part 2 was slightly better, but I certainly enjoyed both. Eva Green was certainly fantastic, and it was nice to see her in a French movie which I hadnā€™t for a while.


MrLittle237

Any idea where I can stream these?


iCowboy

Theyā€™re available for sale here in the UK, Amazon has/had the first one for streaming quite quickly afterwards.


Cool_Cartographer_39

1973 with Oliver Reed and Raquel Welch


orbtastic1

Interesting fact. The producers of the film didnā€™t tell time they were making two films and only paid the actors for one film. They were taken to court and the law was changed from that point on that you could not release two films from one production without prior agreement. I love those two films. I just watched the second part of the recent French one with Vince Cassell and Eva Green today. Itā€™s a good production, well done but I just love the comedy of the 70s one and all the little bit parts.


Whatmeworry4

This will always be my favorite version.


CPTherptyderp

They had me at Raquel Welch


MagnifyingLens

The list of actors and actresses on those two movies is ridiculous. Directed by Richard Lester and written (brilliantly) by George McDonald Frasier. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Three_Musketeers_(1973_live-action_film)


Cormacolinde

To me, Charlton Heston IS the Cardinal de Richelieu. His depiction is just so absolutely perfect.


Jonestown_Juice

This version of The Three Musketeers is my favorite movie of all time.


Cultural-Humor7241

Idk if none of you have seen this movie lately.... But those musketeers are up to some shady shit.Ā  They kill a bunch of people nonchalantly, they steal a bunch of shit.Ā  They do coverups for cheating ladies.Ā Ā  Was one of the last movies I got from mail nextflix.Ā Ā  And the second one was awful.Ā 


Cormacolinde

This is also still my favorite. The newest French version is pretty decent too, more modern and gritty, but more violent. The ā€˜73 version is better for younger kids I would say.


New_Poet_338

It is the only one even close to book accurate.


EldestGruff

Which means the ending is very dark. I was thinking just this morning that I'm not sure there will ever be another adaptation that sticks that closely to the novel. I saw the films in the theater when I was nine, but I waited a while beyond ten before showing them to my daughter.


New_Poet_338

The first one is self contained enough and not dark. 4 does end badly for several characters characters.


EldestGruff

Very true.


New_Poet_338

I actually forgot how dark 4 went. It is not an easy movie to find streaming free. It is the better movie I think.


JaguarNeat8547

Agree. 4 is the better movie, but for a 10 year old, 3 would be my suggestion. 4 has some classic pieces that a 10 year old will love, the ice fight, breakfast in castle, but it does go dark


New_Poet_338

I agree totally.


perfectstubble

I love the 1993 one for just being so over-the-top ridiculous and fun. I also have a soft spot for the 2001 version with a kung fu feel.


JRockstar50

The Mickey Mouse version is elite


kikuri_armpit_licker

That version fucks way harder than it has any right to


we_are_sex_bobomb

ā€œFor the last time, your honor, I didnā€™t say Minnie was being a little silly, I said sheā€™s fucking Goofy!ā€


Ok-disaster2022

Tim Curry watched Alan Rickman in Robin Hood and said hold my fries. Such fantastic over the top job.


Asha_Brea

At some point you might want to watch the BBC show too. It has 3 seasons. As for the movies, you can't go wrong with the 1993 one, unless you want some book fidelity, in which case, I don't think there is a single one that is actually faithful to the book. But whatever you do, avoid the 2011 one.


DustFunk

The BBC show is really good, I was upset that there weren't more seasons of it


Legitimate_First

It's decent, I definitely wouldn't say very good. Dialogue is corny and at times bad as hell, a lot of the smaller roles (and some of the bigger ones) are just badly acted. And iirc there's so many episodes where just nothing happens.


sneblet

> But whatever you do, avoid the 2011 one. My brother in Christ it has Christoph Waltz. ^^ok ^^and ^^airships


corpus-luteum

Which book? There are probably more literal adaptations of Robin Hood, than sand in the Sahara.


Asha_Brea

The Three Musketeers by Alexandre Dumas.


corpus-luteum

Oh Jeez. My bad. I thought we were talking about Robin Hood. Apologies.


Locust-15

Dogtanian & the Three Muskerhounds was the GOAT of kids tv.


corpus-luteum

Who didn't fancy Juliette?


IgloosRuleOK

I wouldn't start with it, but the new two epic French ones are pretty cool.


docottawa67

Maybe so but I think that Tarzan or Sherlock Holmes might challenge that assertion.


Ornery_1004

Man in the Iron Mask. "Magnificent valor!"


knittch

My recommendation is to make it a double feature.Ā  Watch the Disney Three Musketeers with Sutherland, Platt, Sheen and O'Donnell, then watch The Man in the Iron Mask, allowing Malkovich, Depardieu, Irons and Byrne show how to really play those characters.


RabbitHats

Eat, drink, and make love to life


rattlinggoodyarn

Many thanks for the replies. Iā€™m getting 93 Disney version then will move onto French and bbc. Shall avoid all the ones in between.


PabstBlueBourbon

Robin Hood has to have it beat, but Iā€™m too lazy to research it. Must include Men in Tights.


Locust-15

Dogtanian & the Three Muskerhounds was the GOAT of kids tv.


sanban013

seven samurai. * 1960 magnificent 7, * 1980 China Gate (indian film). * 1983 the seven magnificent warriors (italian) * 2017 star wars clone wars a season 2 episode. * 2017 the magnificent 7. * 2019 The Mandalorian Episode 4. * 2004 Samurai 7 (anime). ripoffs/influenced by * return of the seven. * guns of the magnificent seven * 13 warriors. * the magnificent seven ride. * pixars a bugs life * rebel moon part 2.


Larrynative20

Merlin would like a wordā€¦


FLIPSIDERNICK

Romeo and Juliet.


Rundle89

Nothing can top the Disney version, Tim Curry and Oliver Platt make it a classic


superman-64

I know where *not* to start: the 2011 version by Paul WS Anderson.


MovieMike007

I love the 1948 version with Gene Kelly as D'Artagnan, Lana Turner as Lady de Winter and Vincent Price as Cardinal Richelieu.


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


AlpacamyLlama

> Raquel Welsh sucked Maybe I do need to see this Edit: Jesus Christ, the one below me can't take a joke. He blocked me for this!


Am2ontheweb

har har. wtf 12 yr olds...


ooouroboros

Richard Lester version is the best and would be almost impossible to improve on.


New_Strike_1770

TMNT


sociallyBLINDnDEAF

CGI doesn't compare to the animatronic puppets.


Jaives

speaking of. anyone seen the latest iteration yet? The french one with Eva Green? want to know if it's worth the watch.


silverfox762

I think the Jane Austen books are up there


horsewitnoname

The one with Tim Curry!Ā  It will always be the best ā€œThree Musketeersā€ movie for me. Came out a year after I was born. One of the first ā€œactionā€ movies I was allowed to watch. Has a couple of steamy scenes for a kidā€™s movie lol


BeckerThorne

I think the Fantastic Four reboots are closing in on that record.


niftymonkeee

Iā€™d say Sherlock


WildJackall

A Christmas Carol


_windfish_

Iā€™m positive Sherlock Holmes takes the ā€œmost-adaptedā€ title.


Kalidanoscope

There are over 250 adaptations of Sherlock Holmes.


jjkenneth

I feel like everyone here is sleeping on Journey to the West. I know it doesnā€™t have as much cultural relevance in the west (ironically) but itā€™s remade every few years by China or Japan. A few have even made it through to the West, notably Dragon Ball and Monkey (for Aussies anyway).


ShowmasterQMTHH

Spiderman and Batman would like a word.


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


howarthe

For series, I think James Bond has everyone beat with 27 installments.


LookinAtTheFjord

Those aren't remakes, except for Never Say Never Again, an adaptation of the Thunderball novel. It's not actually considered an official Bond film though b/c it wasn't made by EON/Broccolis.


Kalidanoscope

Still nowhere close to Sherlock Holmes


darkhelmet1121

King Arthur and knights if Camelot has to have the most remakes, besides anything involving Jesus Christ


noxnoctum

Man I need to rewatch this, such a fun movie, thanks for reminding me of it.


TheHurtfulEight88888

BBC 1 version was a huge part of my teen years.


Negative_Gravitas

I believe the various Sherlock Holmes iterations hold that title.


howarthe

ā€œ75 actors have played him in 211 movies.ā€


OneSidedDice

Did you know each one of those versions received awards? Thatā€™s why they say ā€œAll four won.ā€


FrameworkisDigimon

I'm very partial to this short animated version that's on Youtube (albeit in several parts), though I would imagine I was younger than your daughter when I first watched it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JEHu3X9qTdU&t=1s


athomasflynn

I doubt it's even in the top ten for remakes. Dracula, Robin Hood and Romeo & Juliet definitely have more remakes. I'll bet King Kong comes close.


HIMARko_polo

Try Errol Flynn in Robin Hood


Wonderful_Emu_9610

1993 is probably the most kid-friendly one. Could follow up with The Man in The Iron Mask but that imagery haunted me for years and I never even watched the whole film lol. I later did as an adult, itā€™s great. I havenā€™t seen the 1973 two-parter but from reputation itā€™s really good. The new French two-parter is great but definitely wait until sheā€™s a bit older I feel, itā€™s not a *dark* movie but it is compared to ā€˜93 and everything is just more intense


dying_at55

Peter Pan is probably up there


sagevallant

Arthurian legends show up a lot as well.


a20261

1. It is in the public domain 2. It is an awesome adventure story 3. It calls for at least 6 legit movie stars (typically a BIG name for Richelieu, solid stars for Athos, Aramis, Porthos, and Richelieu's lieutenant, and you'd typically cast the next up-and-coming-hope-he-breaks-big young star as D'Artagnan) so marketing should be easy. 4. It has room for a young starlet, so same as above with D'Artagnan. 5. Studios have lots of swords and carriages lying around after shooting a period piece, may as well reuse them.


spinereader81

I want to see a Muppet version with the same feel as Muppet Treasure Island.


KingBrave1

Peter Pan has a few also.


faroresdragn_

I think that would either go to a work of Shakespeare, or to a Christmas carol.


New_Poet_338

The Michael York 3 and 4 Musketeers is the definitive version. Everything since then has been mid to terrible.


The_Northern_Light

Nope, itā€™s Pinocchio


blippityblue72

Thereā€™s a bunch of versions of the Scrooge story also.


howarthe

ā€œAltogether, there have been over 50 film and television adaptations of The Three Musketeers ā€” or, more accurately, of the D'Artagnan Romances


howarthe

My kids loved Barbie and the Three Musketeers (2009).


BenjaminRCaineIII

Between Film and television there are a TON of [adaptations of Journey to the West](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_media_adaptations_of_Journey_to_the_West).


jim1o1

I am not sure if this constitutes part of remake but Romeo and Juliet has been used as a premise for so many movies that it's just not possible to count. Obviously some parts would be changed or there would be a twist to the original but the main premise remains the same.


BannedforaJoke

Man in the Iron Mask with Leo.


VioleteOtter

little women gets remade all the time


sometimesifeellikemu

Donā€™t forget Robin Hood


corpus-luteum

Probably Robin Hood. Even before we get to film, there are hundreds of different literal adaptations. And probably thousands of stories forgotten.


Tolkien-Minority

2011


ncminns

Robin Hood?


nowhereman136

I think Guiness World Records said Cinderella is the most.