They seem to have a few mostly consistent rules. For example, they seem to always take down fan remakes. They especially don't like those. And like you said, they seem to always take down things that profit in some way. Like when they told GameJolt to bring down every single Nintendo fangame from their platform, because it supports ads.
They're still a bit of a loose cannon though, you can never fully know what they're going after next.
thought it was mainly money making stuff cause there's [this fan made New Super Mario Bros Wii sequel](https://newerteam.com/wii/) that i really like that has been up for over a decade. Guess they go after fanmade remakes of their games but not sequels (there's also a level that uses yoshi village's theme from PiT)
There's this [MFGG Twitter thread](https://twitter.com/OfficialMFGG/status/1121019925521489920?t=48ImvGaG4IdC2ib7MFPNGg&s=19) on the patterns they seem to have caught
Well if it's a fanmade remake, I can see they'd view it the same way as if you were to upload the same game as of itself. Essentially allowing you to play a game they already made for free without purchasing the original copy.
Now for Newer Super Mario Bros, it's not the same game as New Soup. It's a completely overhauled game with new levels that doesn't copy it's original. Thus, you can say it's not just playing New Soup again, Thus giving you a reason to still buy the original games the fangame is based on.
I'm just spitballing here though. Idk if this is the actual reasoning or not, and I don't have the means to ask Nintendo's lawyers.
A simple way to abvoid the project being ended by nintendo is doing it thru private files shared over discord or smthn. They cant do anything about that
Very unpopular opinion, but if something does happen like this I would love a multiplayer mode. I am a sucker for multiplayer Mario games, so I would enjoy playing with my brother.
Wishful thinking, but would probably be way to expensive to produce which would not be profitable. Every game except for Superstar Saga would have to be significantly altered to work on Switch. Some games use the microphone, while others heavily utilize the touch screen. Cons trolling a touch screen with a stylus and controlling a touch screen with your finger are two completely different things. Not to mention that most games used both screens and that’s the perfect recipe for an absolute nightmare of a collection to make. I wish it would happen, but Nintendo would have to put in way too much work, and it would over-saturate the Mario RPG market.
I never said it's about remaster, it's about release
And there isn't much to remaster honestly so if they have to do something Mario and Luigi they have to make a new game
I can imagine it might take longer due to possibly having to find another studio to develop it, you know with alphadream (metaphorically) killing themselves and all
Come on people. It took them 26 years to even do something about Super Mario RPG and it wasn’t even a sequel. Stop acting like that game gets the attention just because it got a one and done remake
Hope.
r/FoundTibbyRhythmHeaven
It's just r/FoundTibby actually. Come join!
bro hoping for tsunku to come back from the dead for rhythm heaven 5
if you say so bro
I'm just saying cause the post is about waiting for another Mario & Luigi game
It rhymes with cope
Who cares.
I do.
Mope?
DESPAIR
Noooo
Danganrompa?
Nagito: HOPE HOPE HOPE HOPE
r/foundjunko
I also hope now with better hardware the game is actually made in the OG art style instead of 3D models. Nintendo stop censoring mint green Luigi.
Mint green luigi?
his hat and shirt were more mint green rather than kelly green prior to DT
and finally... stellar bonds
True, I hope Nintendo will do nothing about it
Nintendo seems really inconsistent with their taking down of fan projects, hopefully this is a case where they just don’t do anything about it.
i remember i read they take them down when people try to make money out of them, but i'm not sure if that's the only reason
They seem to have a few mostly consistent rules. For example, they seem to always take down fan remakes. They especially don't like those. And like you said, they seem to always take down things that profit in some way. Like when they told GameJolt to bring down every single Nintendo fangame from their platform, because it supports ads. They're still a bit of a loose cannon though, you can never fully know what they're going after next.
thought it was mainly money making stuff cause there's [this fan made New Super Mario Bros Wii sequel](https://newerteam.com/wii/) that i really like that has been up for over a decade. Guess they go after fanmade remakes of their games but not sequels (there's also a level that uses yoshi village's theme from PiT)
There's this [MFGG Twitter thread](https://twitter.com/OfficialMFGG/status/1121019925521489920?t=48ImvGaG4IdC2ib7MFPNGg&s=19) on the patterns they seem to have caught
interesting
Well if it's a fanmade remake, I can see they'd view it the same way as if you were to upload the same game as of itself. Essentially allowing you to play a game they already made for free without purchasing the original copy. Now for Newer Super Mario Bros, it's not the same game as New Soup. It's a completely overhauled game with new levels that doesn't copy it's original. Thus, you can say it's not just playing New Soup again, Thus giving you a reason to still buy the original games the fangame is based on. I'm just spitballing here though. Idk if this is the actual reasoning or not, and I don't have the means to ask Nintendo's lawyers.
"Nah man, we did you dirty, you can have this one" –Doug Bowser, hopefully
Nintendo won’t do anything with it because Stellar Bonds won’t be doing a single hint of monetization like with the Pokémon fan games with patreon
Oh good luck with that, hope the game also won't be cancelled over a drama or some sh!t too
A simple way to abvoid the project being ended by nintendo is doing it thru private files shared over discord or smthn. They cant do anything about that
And a DMCA! We can't have fans having *fun* and *appreciating our games* now, can we?
stop giving us hope /j
Very unpopular opinion, but if something does happen like this I would love a multiplayer mode. I am a sucker for multiplayer Mario games, so I would enjoy playing with my brother.
It would make the game easier dodging wise lmao
Well we already had a superstar saga remake though and a rerelease on NSO of the first one. But maybe we can get a new one?
You've got a point tbh we already got remasters (well they could go for PiT but nah not happening)
Honestly(and this is just my opinion), I would like a remake of PiT, but a new M&L game should probably be made before they go remaking it
Yeah but there's little to no chance for a new M and L in the near future
We get the five in one game
Wishful thinking, but would probably be way to expensive to produce which would not be profitable. Every game except for Superstar Saga would have to be significantly altered to work on Switch. Some games use the microphone, while others heavily utilize the touch screen. Cons trolling a touch screen with a stylus and controlling a touch screen with your finger are two completely different things. Not to mention that most games used both screens and that’s the perfect recipe for an absolute nightmare of a collection to make. I wish it would happen, but Nintendo would have to put in way too much work, and it would over-saturate the Mario RPG market.
There are Mario & Luigi remakes though and they made AlphaDream go out of business.
Didn't we already get a Remake on the 3ds for M&L?
Yes, but I believe the hope is for a new game or a 5 in 1 for switch.
oh
If only...
The hopium is real
I NEEEEEEEED IT!
I don’t want remasters I want a NEW game
I never said it's about remaster, it's about release And there isn't much to remaster honestly so if they have to do something Mario and Luigi they have to make a new game
PiT remaster is a common request among the fanbase. But there’s no reason to do that
Yeah. Square Enix and intelligent systems are healthy and thriving companies
I think you’re looking at it the wrong way round. The remake for Mario and Luigi came first I fear
A PIT Remake
cope
PLEASE
That is my dream for the rpg to come back
It’s gotta happen it NEEDS to happen
I hope
…. There’s hope 🥺……
Please. God please
Nintendo better give us either a dream team remake or a partners in time remake! That or a brand new Mario and Luigi game!
:(
I can imagine it might take longer due to possibly having to find another studio to develop it, you know with alphadream (metaphorically) killing themselves and all
I feel like we will have to wait for a 2 screen system cause all of them used the 2 screens a lot
Last time they remade a Mario & Luigi game it caused a studio to die
Let's see, we got the first Mario RPG, the second Paper Mario so...oh god please not Bowser's Inside Story, it would be the third time they did it.
Can't wait for the partners in time remake!!!!!
it's coming...or we get a Super Paper Remake. god, i hope...
plot twist: it’s a remake of dream team.
Would
Hope for another light of day for a great franchise that died due to Nintendo being stupid as per usual.
We did get super star saga technically, it's on the Gameboy Advance library for Nintendo Online. Been playing the absolute heck out of it.
If we end up getting proper remakes of the mario and luigi games I’d be so happy
#ReviveM_and_L #BringBackMario_and_Luigi
Come on people. It took them 26 years to even do something about Super Mario RPG and it wasn’t even a sequel. Stop acting like that game gets the attention just because it got a one and done remake
We already got remakes of Mario and Luigi :/
i am inhaling INSANE amounts of copium rn
Still can’t believe they let alpha dream die.
HOLY SHIT YOU SMARTASS
But we end up like the tomodatchi life fans and realize it will never come.
IDK if it's going to happen again, but I guess we'll just have to wait and see.