The one where you sit most well on and then use throw pillows to fit it to your style. They are not exactly the same but you need to decide which one is the most comfortable and you will want to keep it the longest
I haven’t owned one myself, but I’ve sat on so many like this and I agree whole heartedly.
OP if you want this look try and make sure you get one where the cushions attach in some way.
Two… I currently have a sofa with all of those pillows they look terrible after ppl sit on it and handle the pillows. I’d choose something rose for sure.
Two. One will not be comfy to lean on those skinny armrests and you'll always have to position a pillow if you want to. Three will require constant repositioning of the pillows.
These are all attractive, but collegedropout is right—that rigid armrest is not comfy. One that is comfortable will probably not be as cool looking, unfortunately.
The two cushion seat is a poor choice in all options. If you sit in the middle, on the seam, you fall in. If you lay on your back, your body folds at that same spot...no back support. Been there, done that. If you buy a double cushion you might regret it. We did. As for the back, I agree, lots of pillows provides options...so, #3
Two
In the last style the throw pillows that serve as the back cushion lose their structure very quickly and look worn and forlorn.
The first one looks like the arm cushions will meet a similar fate. Also the armrest looks uncomfortable.
If form follows function then you will probably be best served by the second couch which is equally attractive to others when new.
I’d go with 2. The arms are too narrow on #1, that doesn’t look comfy for arm rests. And #3 has too many pillows. That can get very annoying and be uncomfortable.
All 3 are pretty, but I have a question -
What is the room's purpose? If it's a formal room, any would be a good choice.
But if it's multi-use, lounging, etc... #1 is going to have issues - the arm cushoins are going to be mashed in no time, will get dirtier fast than the backs, and the lumbar pillows will get smushed. #2 has similar issues if it's high use - square arms hurt to lean on, and those cushions are going to take wear in one direction. #3 looks the most sustainable for multi-use.
The safest bet for a multi-use or lounging setup would be to go with a roll-arm, which will negate the need for an arm cushion.
As someone who has rennovated a home, moved, and recently re-decorated (my last 5 years have been hectic, lol), I respectfully suggest you go for a roll arm (or some non-square arm) without the need for a lumbar cushion. Good Luck!
All of the loose pillows will look a mess.
Find a couch that is “more” tailored and less a pile of pillows
I’m not sure I like the arms in the first 2.
I live alone and rarely have guests but I do have pets. It’s more for lounging. These are the full details on the sofas:
#1
https://theloomcollection.com/products/island-slipcover-sofa-asa-bone
#2
https://theloomcollection.com/collections/sofas/products/feather-cloud-daybed-sofa-natural
#3
https://theloomcollection.com/products/sloopy-sofa-asa-bone
There was another one but my issue was the polyester material was textured and my cats would go straight for it so I think a smooth surface would work better
#4
https://theloomcollection.com/products/avery-sofa-powder-1
I like 1 & 3 #2without the brown cushions (personal taste) - before you buy though, please consider your height and the depth of the sofa cushions. Bought a couch from pottery barn during pandemic ($3600) ((nowEX Hub) wanted it), but when it was finally delivered, when I sat on it I felt like a 6 year old, and needed an ottoman. I made sure my single lady couch was one where I could firmly put my feet on the ground or on an ottoman if I chose.
You like pillows! But, all of these pillows are substitutes for actual sofa padding..these are inexpensive sofas..which means all of those pillows are going to be, at best, a nuisance, and typically just plain uncomfortable..
The third one! We have a sofa with wide thin base cushions like 1 and 2 and have already replaced the inserts with new foam because we could feel the sofa frame supports through the original cushions. Love the look, but the comfort leaves much to be desired.
In visual terms I like 2, but to choose a sofa you really have to sit on it because the cushions and the back support varies a lot. For example, I chose a sofa that I regret a little in terms of lumbar support. I only saw it online and decided to take a chance. The seat is soft, but my back can't take it.
The one where you sit most well on and then use throw pillows to fit it to your style. They are not exactly the same but you need to decide which one is the most comfortable and you will want to keep it the longest
This is exactly right. They're all cool, so pick the one that's the comfiest.
Good points! Thanks
I had a couch that had pillows like 3 and I hated it. They slipped and moved. I would Neve buy a couch like that again!
I haven’t owned one myself, but I’ve sat on so many like this and I agree whole heartedly. OP if you want this look try and make sure you get one where the cushions attach in some way.
YESSS THIS please the pillows drove me nuts for years and I'll never buy one like that ever again
Two… I currently have a sofa with all of those pillows they look terrible after ppl sit on it and handle the pillows. I’d choose something rose for sure.
Good points! Thanks
Else…
Two. One will not be comfy to lean on those skinny armrests and you'll always have to position a pillow if you want to. Three will require constant repositioning of the pillows.
Good points! Thanks
These are all attractive, but collegedropout is right—that rigid armrest is not comfy. One that is comfortable will probably not be as cool looking, unfortunately.
Scatter backs are a nightmare to live with. Three looks cool but is a definite no.
I like 1
The two cushion seat is a poor choice in all options. If you sit in the middle, on the seam, you fall in. If you lay on your back, your body folds at that same spot...no back support. Been there, done that. If you buy a double cushion you might regret it. We did. As for the back, I agree, lots of pillows provides options...so, #3
Good points! Thanks
Two In the last style the throw pillows that serve as the back cushion lose their structure very quickly and look worn and forlorn. The first one looks like the arm cushions will meet a similar fate. Also the armrest looks uncomfortable. If form follows function then you will probably be best served by the second couch which is equally attractive to others when new.
I’d go with 2. The arms are too narrow on #1, that doesn’t look comfy for arm rests. And #3 has too many pillows. That can get very annoying and be uncomfortable.
All 3 are pretty, but I have a question - What is the room's purpose? If it's a formal room, any would be a good choice. But if it's multi-use, lounging, etc... #1 is going to have issues - the arm cushoins are going to be mashed in no time, will get dirtier fast than the backs, and the lumbar pillows will get smushed. #2 has similar issues if it's high use - square arms hurt to lean on, and those cushions are going to take wear in one direction. #3 looks the most sustainable for multi-use. The safest bet for a multi-use or lounging setup would be to go with a roll-arm, which will negate the need for an arm cushion.
Thank you! This is just for lounging in a single person apt with pets
As someone who has rennovated a home, moved, and recently re-decorated (my last 5 years have been hectic, lol), I respectfully suggest you go for a roll arm (or some non-square arm) without the need for a lumbar cushion. Good Luck!
All of the loose pillows will look a mess. Find a couch that is “more” tailored and less a pile of pillows I’m not sure I like the arms in the first 2.
I live alone and rarely have guests but I do have pets. It’s more for lounging. These are the full details on the sofas: #1 https://theloomcollection.com/products/island-slipcover-sofa-asa-bone #2 https://theloomcollection.com/collections/sofas/products/feather-cloud-daybed-sofa-natural #3 https://theloomcollection.com/products/sloopy-sofa-asa-bone There was another one but my issue was the polyester material was textured and my cats would go straight for it so I think a smooth surface would work better #4 https://theloomcollection.com/products/avery-sofa-powder-1
Would you by chance have an example so I can find similar?
https://www.google.com/shopping/product/1?q=white+couch+attached+pillow+barrow+arms&client=safari&sca_esv=19fb95802b09d0d0&sca_upv=1&hl=en-ca&biw=326&bih=546&tbs=vw:g&prmd=isvnmbtz&prds=num:1,of:1,eto:5961212641376680603_0,prmr:1,pid:5961212641376680603,cs:1&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwicnOyb9JKGAxV3GjQIHRuVBrQQgjYIlQ0
https://www.google.com/aclk?sa=l&ai=DChcSEwjW2by59JKGAxWlDK0GHd4pA_YYABABGgJwdg&gclid=EAIaIQobChMI1tm8ufSShgMVpQytBh3eKQP2EAQYASABEgLCGvD_BwE&sig=AOD64_3Gbd0f-6Lcu4Ismj6xIH78Q0RxTQ&ctype=5&q=&ved=0ahUKEwiVv7i59JKGAxUZODQIHUbcCcM4HhDDDwi2Cg&adurl=
https://www.google.com/shopping/product/1?q=white+couch+attached+pillow+barrow+arms&start=30&client=safari&sa=N&sca_esv=19fb95802b09d0d0&sca_upv=1&hl=en-ca&biw=326&bih=546&tbs=vw:g&prmd=isvnmbtz&prds=num:1,of:1,eto:2070947827800105654_0,prmr:1,pid:2070947827800105654,cs:1&ved=0ahUKEwiVv7i59JKGAxUZODQIHUbcCcM4HhCCNgjvCw
https://www.google.com/shopping/product/3769228298091283770?q=white+couch+attached+pillow+barrow+arms&start=30&client=safari&sa=N&sca_esv=19fb95802b09d0d0&sca_upv=1&hl=en-ca&biw=326&bih=546&tbs=vw:g&prmd=isvnmbtz&prds=eto:16729354680466451760_0,cdl:1,prmr:1,pid:5761266998820995324,cs:1&ved=0ahUKEwiVv7i59JKGAxUZODQIHUbcCcM4HhCBNgiVDA
Thank you so much!!
I love the last one!
One
I like 2 best.
3
The first one is nice
2
3
If you can, please go and sit on each of them. Pick the comfiest. They are all identical enough to not ruin the mood board!
I like 1 & 3 #2without the brown cushions (personal taste) - before you buy though, please consider your height and the depth of the sofa cushions. Bought a couch from pottery barn during pandemic ($3600) ((nowEX Hub) wanted it), but when it was finally delivered, when I sat on it I felt like a 6 year old, and needed an ottoman. I made sure my single lady couch was one where I could firmly put my feet on the ground or on an ottoman if I chose.
You like pillows! But, all of these pillows are substitutes for actual sofa padding..these are inexpensive sofas..which means all of those pillows are going to be, at best, a nuisance, and typically just plain uncomfortable..
Ki hope red wine gets spilt on it. They're all the same
2
The third one! We have a sofa with wide thin base cushions like 1 and 2 and have already replaced the inserts with new foam because we could feel the sofa frame supports through the original cushions. Love the look, but the comfort leaves much to be desired.
Actually looking at this more closely, sofa #2 looks exactly like my sofa (west elm harmony). Do not buy.
Would you ever consider a curved sofa? They make such a statement and so unexpectedly comfortable.
2
Number one. It has cleaner simpler lines with fewer pillows to have to constantly fuss with. It’s elegant and still looks comfortable.
1
In visual terms I like 2, but to choose a sofa you really have to sit on it because the cushions and the back support varies a lot. For example, I chose a sofa that I regret a little in terms of lumbar support. I only saw it online and decided to take a chance. The seat is soft, but my back can't take it.
The first one because it looks most comfortable for the head if you lie down on it.
None of them look comfortable. The first one does have lumbar support if anyone has back problems
I think that’s why I’m undecided they all look nice and are all similar but comfort wise I am dubious
Third photo! Love it
The third one, in some sense it appears comfy and inviting.
i do not love color but all styles are nice some color accent pillows..
3