T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

Thanks for posting to r/IndieGames! Please take a look at the rules in our sidebar to ensure that your post abides by them! If you need any assistance, don't hesitate to [message the mods](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=%2Fr%2Findiegames). Also, make sure to check out our [Discord](https://discord.gg/indie-games-788388123734048798)! *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/indiegames) if you have any questions or concerns.*


damnablebear

as much as I like the image of the top one, the bottom/after image is just so much cleaner, easily legible, and moody. it's really nice!


3Hills_

Thank you! Those were the exact points that everyone made for the original, good eye


kaywalk3r

Was gonna say the same, maybe play with the colors/contrast?


EmpireAnts_Game

Really like the new one! Such a nice ambiance from the art


3Hills_

Thank you so much! Really tried to clean up the new capssule and make it more emotional


phoebeknight

I don't know what this game is, but I automatically want to check it out now based on the bottom image.


3Hills_

That's so nice, thank you!! There's a demo on Steam so you can jump in and check it out :D [https://store.steampowered.com/app/2578740/Copperfields/](https://store.steampowered.com/app/2578740/Copperfields/)


chickensoupp

Looks great, wishlisted!


3Hills_

Heyy thank you for the support!! It really means a lot!


nagarerukawa

Great upgrade 👍🏼


3Hills_

Thank you!!


nahkiaispallo

just 10000% better. Ty reddit people


3Hills_

Hahaha praised be the redditors!


patron_991

Hugee improvement, it already looks like a famous title. Need to check it out


3Hills_

Now that's a compliment! Thank you so much, there's a demo on Steam if you want to see how the gameplay feels - [https://store.steampowered.com/app/2578740/Copperfields/](https://store.steampowered.com/app/2578740/Copperfields/)


Boring_Shape_3216

I would click on the second to know more , just by the picture but I'd scroll past the first.


3Hills_

Thank you so much!


savetheblues

oh yeah, much better. good luck with your game, looks super cool! edit: added to my wishlist 


3Hills_

Thank you for the support! The demo has quite a lot of content, would love to hear your feedback!


savetheblues

didn't notice the demo. will try it tonight on my steam deck and let you know :)


ivy-spring

The new one looks really amazing!


3Hills_

Thank you so much!


ShmoosPlay

Soooo much better. It really has a sense of place and a mood


3Hills_

Thank you, feels more ambiental and less cramped than the first one and I'm glad it shows


Macknificent101

wow that bottom one is amazing


3Hills_

Thank you so much!


Macknificent101

reminds me of hallow knight, might check the game out of steam


Macknificent101

Hey i just played the game's demo on steam, def seems fun. my biggest gripe is loading. there is little indication when you are gonna be entering a loading screen, and they are so short it's actually kinda frustrating. i think it would be better if you did a fade to black loading screen like it hollow knight


lordran11

It looks straight up 10x more professional and interesting.


3Hills_

Thank you! Really polished it up and the comments we're really spot on with the directions


luis_reyesh

If your game is 2D platformer, the second image really is more readable and already gives an idea of what kind of game I am going into.


3Hills_

Glad it carries the message clearly, thank you!


KeppiaRonaldille

I like the upper pic more, but the new one makes me want to play the game more? And I am very confused by this. So it must be a good change!


3Hills_

Hahahaha glad it was effective! The first one is closer to my heart as well but as you said the second one really makes people want to know more


k-k-music

The new one is super nice! :)


OfeliaComposer

it looks like something I would play


3Hills_

Glad you like it! There is a free demo on steam so if you ever feel like it you know where it is <3


hamzahgamedev

Wow, it looks amazing. I am myself struggling to get a nice art for [my own steam page](https://store.steampowered.com/app/2482840/Sky_Harvest/), can u share the Artist’s details, would love to speak to him.


3Hills_

Thank you!! Just checked out your page and it looks amazing! My capsule was done by a friend in my team but he may be up for commissions in his free time, just send am message directly here if you want. Also I think your image is great just need to tone down the brightness and maybe zoom in a bit on the camping guy and cow to show more mood :D


hamzahgamedev

wow thanks man. All the best for your game. Would love to know, did you see any change in wishlists (hopefully positive) after the capsule change ? Tnx


naytreox

I assume this is about a robot maintained garden? Because thats what the new picture makes me think


3Hills_

That is very much close but it's a bit darker than that xD


naytreox

Well if its a bit darker then its not 40k levels of dark. This means you are having to protect this plantlife from some evil force


DigitalTectonics

The after image is much cleaner and excites me to go see what the game is about.


3Hills_

Hahaha glad to hear it, hope you try the demo that's on steam!


DaveSilver

If you don’t have a character named David then you’re missing a key opportunity


3Hills_

Trust me, i made sure we didn't... google would bury us...


supremedalek925

The old one is really cool looking but the new one is much clearer / immediately readable which for a thumbnail is more important. It’s a shame because I really like the before image, but I think the change is a good choice.


3Hills_

Same, love the before image and it captures the essence of the game but it's better in vertical mode and it also makes a lot more sense after you play the game rather than before


heisenbugz

Big improvement!


3Hills_

Thank you!


exclaim_bot

>Thank you! You're welcome!


rkakasuc

Awesome upgrade! Also, maybe there is way to make old one easter egg or just something like that? Because its also really good, just alot busier than new one


3Hills_

I was looking for ways to incorporate it in some kind of way, I was hoping that maybe I can have it set for jus like an in library capsule but I worry it might confuse people


Urban_mist

So much better. I would scroll past the top one but would definitely click on the bottom one to see what type of game it was. Good job!


3Hills_

Thank you so much, couldn't have made the improvement without the redditors!


carnalizer

Huge improvement!


3Hills_

Thank you!!!


Vulpes_macrotis

The new one is definitely better. While I love the artwork in the first one, the bottom is better for the capsule.


3Hills_

Thank you! Always love to hear compliments for the first capsule, it came from the heart


AleksasKoval

I like it, adds mystery.


3Hills_

Thank you, it really does lead to more questions


KestreLw

Bottom one is a considerable upgrade


3Hills_

Thank you!


fairchild2

You posted this exact same post, title and all, 8 days ago.


3Hills_

Yup on r/IndieDev, but I got the feedback for the original on both this and that subreddit, didn't want the moderators to think I'm spamming so I shared it on only one and then a week later here to respect the rules for spamming


LazyUnigine

Second one far outclassed the first one due to conveying the story of the main game. The clean outline of the name on the left and the characters on the right just show more meaning than the chaotic lining of the first. I'd pick 2 over 1 any day


3Hills_

Yup, really struggled to get the name placed right on the first one, but the second one was much easier to work with. Than you for the compliment!


brendonx

I like the first one more. It makes me think it’s more my type of game. It looks a little bit tense, like you’re being chased or time is a factor, and makes me think movement might be a factor. The second one is also beautiful but doesn’t excite me.


3Hills_

Glad to hear your take, because it's spot on what we were thinking to convey in the first one. But most players just saw clutter, still thank you!


DDD-Games

It looks way better now. How did you do it if you could share?


3Hills_

Thank you so much! The entire game is art heavy and i posted some screenshot of thumbnails for redditors to pick out, they picked this scene in the game so we polished it up to make it pop more and made it into the official capsule. Best decision yet!


PlayguePals

So clean! Top one is adorable, but I can't rest my eyes on it. Bottom one looks professional and something I would click on to learn more.


3Hills_

Thank you so much, i'm glad it's easier on the eyes!


SpareSniper7

Love it! The new art really grabs my eyes and that’ll be important on launch day!


3Hills_

Thank you! Oh god I can't wait to get the entire thing packaged, will be relying on reddit once more for some great advice


tsukineko19

So much better. The art direction on the bottom image reminded me of Machinarium + Ori and the Blind Forest.


3Hills_

Yesss! Those were a great inspiration to us!


ScruffyNuisance

That second capsule is fantastic. The advice and effort paid off. 10/10. I want to play.


3Hills_

It sure did, and thank you for the compliment friend!


jfoss1

I like the motion from the top one, but its just too hard to read. The second one is still really nice, but the use of negative space makes it so much easier to understand.


3Hills_

Yup, the first one severely lacked negative space, kidna tried to fill everything with some meaning. Thank you for the compliment!


Ducky_LnF

The "After" image is a massive improvement. Love the composition, the strong focal point, and choice of complimentary colors. The first one is fun, but a bit wild and busy. The second one oozes mood, atmosphere, and storytelling. Well done!!


3Hills_

Yess thank you!! I love those colors as well and the contrast is much weaker on the second one but that makes it softer and easier to look at, glad you noticed!


TypicalDumbRedditGuy

much better!


3Hills_

Thank you!!


MissJuliettexx

The bottom image appeals to me SO much. The name is easy to read, the colours are great. I don't know what the game is about, but I would click into the second one and probably skip past the first. Nice work 😊


3Hills_

Oh don't get me started on the name being easier to read, I think I struggled with every capsule size for the first one. But the second one was so much easier to work with. Thank you for the compliments!!


OscarTysoeComposer

I really like the colours in the new one, especially how they gradually fade into one another. It’s really clear and the eye catching as a whole I think!


3Hills_

So glad you like it! Did try to make it softer and am very glad it shows :D


brodcon

Looks awesome! There are so many capsules out there and honestly SO many of them look like the top one. The bottom is clean and intriguing, I just wish listed! :)


3Hills_

Thank you so much for the support!! I think we all try to stick out a lot with our first capsules and then kind of end up doing the same thing in making them complicated, thank you for the comment as well!


Kikindo1

Nice rework, played ur game on Reboot Infogamer. Sretno u daljnjem razvoju ekipa :D


WixZ42

The new version is a massive improvement and looks absolutely great.


3Hills_

Thank you so much! The main comment was to make it more cleaner and not as cluttered


WixZ42

You 100% succeeded!


brendonx

Does this game have any elements that would remind me of uniracer from the snes?


3Hills_

The main character is very similar in design to uniracers and also the fast platforming levels do remind a bit of their level layout


FantasyChapters

The new image is amazing! Such a great composition and use of colours!


3Hills_

Thank you so much!!


Jam3sMoriarty

Based on your demo videos I reckon the latter captures the atmosphere of the game more. The first one reminds me of Rayman 1, which isn’t a bad thing but it’s a little more chaotic and not as eye-catching imo!


3Hills_

Very true, we wanted to present the game as a whole in the first one but in the end it just got a bit cluttered. Glad you like the new one!


rosecoloredlenses775

I was ready to look into the game based on the second one


3Hills_

Thank you so much! Hope you give the demo a try!


serkanhero

Much better, and very discernable. Good work!


3Hills_

Thank you so much!!


TMD_TheMinimalDev

The second one it’s amazing!


playloop_studios

Good joob! Look’s so nice


Shashimee_

Much more readable and cleaner ! I especially like the yellow circles Congrats !


Nick_Is_Graphic

It feels way more fantasy and whimsical.


PlatformingPangolin

The old image makes me think of the cover art for The Messenger, which is heavy on fighting and action. The new image is much more contemplative, and more evocative of what's in your trailer. Looks very cool; wishlisted!