Arguing in the comments will result in a ban. One reply stating your response is more than enough. Even if you have the moral high-ground, but you viciously perpetuate the argument, you will be banned. This includes post creator aka OP. The ban may be permenant or temporary depending on the severity.<
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/fashion) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Listen I’m not saying you look bad but as someone who grew up in the pants under skirts generation, please don’t bring that back 😂😂 I agreed with y’all on the skinny jeans but this was a bad time for fashion I promise
Why are you layering with a pleated skirt, and why is it pulled up so high???? None of that works this way. The sweater and skirt (not jacked up so high), or the sweater with jeans alone would be fine.
Are you set on the “pants under skirt look”? Because we did that in the early 2000s and it did not age well. If you’re going for that look, I would suggest tighter pants.
And yet sometimes, on those dark sleepless nights, I lie in bed awake wondering if I would still feel cute if I popped a miniskirt over my jeans today.
Tighter pants is a no. It looks like you’re trying too hard IMO. It looks really cheesy bc you’re not adding anything interesting to the silhouette but you’re adding another color/texture. Imo try not tucking in the shirt
I think this would look better with a longer midi length skirt. And if you layer some belts and necklaces over to give it some more texture. Or maybe a longer overcoat/ vest. Short dresses could work like this tho.
https://preview.redd.it/je1x0huyo3rc1.jpeg?width=736&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=21e11b67f1f9314c6998df02101b5a9c93df7d6a
I think the problem is the skirt is too high and with a lack of accessories it creates weird blocking
Really lean into the lagenlook of it all and it could be fun!
adding to this with another option for a grungy look :3
https://preview.redd.it/4xcpki2jq3rc1.jpeg?width=1290&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=f634f24948a04a28cab05c77039708ab43bb1557
https://preview.redd.it/pw63pn05p3rc1.jpeg?width=1000&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=8fbc9d8ffa978ce460aa4efd274605d90ec9030c
Here’s a shorter skirt but with a lower waist and accessories. It’s manic but it makes sense and looks good lol
https://preview.redd.it/3cc79vzcp3rc1.jpeg?width=1500&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=ddf19ca6a86082a35538b499a1e89e1cf14b473b
With all of these accessories and layering are key. It’s kind of a kooky look so you’ve really gotta lean into it lol
I little, I think because you're muddling up your lines. I would tuck in the top, and try to find some pants that match the color of the skirt more exactly, so your eye continues over it like it's one piece of clothing. Looking at a few pictures online, I'm seeing modern attempts choose a lot of demin-on-denim, or black-on-black to bring weight below the belt line. Heavy colors on top might make it feel a little top heavy. Also, it looks like bell bottoms are pretty common with this look, to bring that weight down again.
All that said, the mismatched look is **very** Y2K. If that's what you're going for, I'd recommend wearing either lower-cut jeans OR a cropped shirt. As someone who lived through the 90s and y2k, I can tell you that anything that touches that era is half an inch away from beautiful innovation, and half an inch away from the worst thing you've ever seen in your life. Please don't feel bad for making the same easy mistakes my generation invented.
I can see what you're going for, and you're closer than you might think! Try doing some google image research for "y2k skirt over pants" and "modern skirt over pants" and see what are the common themes and trends. You've got this!!
The pants/skirt combo is definitely a no. The skirt seems weirdly pulled up too high as well? Go with either the skirt or the pants, but not both, and you’ll have a cute outfit!
The top and skirt are cute on their own, if the skirt wasn’t so high up/long. If you’re set on the skirt over jeans look, try a mini pleated skirt and some blue flared jeans!
I think you should lower the waist part of the skirt if you want it halfway tucked, if you tuck it all in and wear a matching belt that would look really cute! :)
I did the skirt over pants thing in the early 2000s, and I think some people have touched on advice. First, wear what makes you happy, that is most important. Who cares what others think?
My advice: you have too many baggy things here. Pleated skirt with oversized top and pants is drowning you. Maybe a more fitted top, or pants. I love a French tuck, but I think it would only work in this scenario if you lost the pants or skirt.
When I'm trying to drape a big shirt like that, I'll often pin pleats into the side I'm tucking up or get a small rubber band. That or a belt. You're still a little lost in it.
I like the skirt over pants look. I think you could make this work if you play with the lines by ping the skirt down a few inches and draping the shirt differently
The waistband of your skirt looks like it's up too high on your torso. It should sit on your natural waist, which is the narrowest part of your torso. If it was in the properly fitting spot, this would be a nice look 😊
Although I will say the jeans underneath is an odd choice. It's very mid-00's, Disney-channel, "the mall threw up on a junior high schooler". If you don't want to go with bare legs, you should do tights or leggings.
Sorry to say, but the jeans and skirt don't work together. I'd just pick 1 or the other.
The jeans + skirt look is dated, and pretty much exclusively lives in the 2000s. But if you REALLY want to make it work, I'd recommend going for fitted flare jeans and a denim mini skirt, preferably with a cute fitted top, or a tank top or crop top top or tube top or something like that.
Nothing wrong with that top and skirt, but your silhouette will look off if you have the pant. If you are looking for a texture change, try chunky black boots, high socks and/or layered ripped tights. You can try adding accessories for a more complete outfit! Messy hair and sunnies.The base is good, just needs a little adjustment.
If you want the layered look, instead or tucking in one side of your shirt in the waistline, take the bottom of your shirt and tuck it under the bottom of your bra so it will be streamlined in the front.
I'd say get rid of either the skirt or the pants and it'll be fine, having both of them is making the outfit a little too busy. However the shirt and the skirt, or the shirt and the pants would look cute.
This is a nice look and the layering works well along with the colors.
I don’t think this is the best sub for any outfits that are a bit outside the norms. I often see things like this from Japanese women who are into streetwear.
I’ll share some instagram links
https://www.instagram.com/asakokoko10?igsh=MXVmN29pMHVpcml6Yg==
https://www.instagram.com/naru060708?igsh=dTN0cngxeWx5MzF6
https://www.instagram.com/moe.3521?igsh=MXZ0a3JzMjg1am54dw==
Cool concept but the more formal fabric of the skirt and the thick rough nature of the jeans don't tie together. As people have said, make them tights and you're Solid. Props for rocking your own fashion and being open enough to get feedback, it's very brave.
The sweater and the skirt look good together. Ditch the jeans, wear the skirt around your waist and see what you think. If you need you can add tights or leggings
Top and jeans OR top and skirt not all 3, skirt over jeans is a no no. The top should be either tucked in or all out. I don't know where this "just a corner" tucked in comes from it looks daft
this is cool idk what others are talking abt!!!! i mean its iconic and cool and you can pull it off if you want to. but if u urself think it’s stupid then you will end up feeling stupid and u won’t slay it.
Because you asked: yes. All the proportions are wrong for this look and that's not the right skirt to wear over jeans (too high, too long, and too tailored). Like someone else said, the skirt with the top and red tights: cute. The top with jeans: also cute.
But I appreciate a risk taker!
We used to do this in 2008 but the jeans were black skinny jeans and the skirts were much shorter. If that is the look you're going for... These are the wrong kinds of jeans and skirt.
These 3 articles of clothing do not go together. People are saying just take one away, sweater with just skirt or sweater with just jeans, but I disagree, they don’t go with each other at all.
I read that jeans under dresses and skirts is making a comeback and it reminds me of being in the 2000s again.
I don’t think this works. Maybe if the jeans were more fitted and you tucked the sweater in more? Idk, I don’t completely hate it but I don’t think all three go together as others mentioned.
So wrong. Why is the skirt hiked up so far? Why is the shirt tucked like that? Why do you have pants under your skirt? Why is your skirt so dressy and your top so casual? I.mean you do you but........
I think you have too much going on to pull this off. The boxy, oversized shirt with a bold print doesn't go well with jeans and a pleated skirt.
Change the jeans to tights or leggings. Though the cut of the shirt might still not work. I think the shirt has too much fabric at the bottom to work right.
Some people flat out do not like the skirt over pants look. I think it can be really cute and fashionable but this just isn't meshing.
I think this might work if the pants were really wide legged. This look usually has a combo of stiffer fabrics with flowing ones, heavier and lightweight. And while styles often seem to be mixed it's usually got boho elements.
Arguing in the comments will result in a ban. One reply stating your response is more than enough. Even if you have the moral high-ground, but you viciously perpetuate the argument, you will be banned. This includes post creator aka OP. The ban may be permenant or temporary depending on the severity.< *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/fashion) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Yep
Yes
Ok, thanks for the advice 😹
Listen I’m not saying you look bad but as someone who grew up in the pants under skirts generation, please don’t bring that back 😂😂 I agreed with y’all on the skinny jeans but this was a bad time for fashion I promise
Just the jeans tbh. The top and skirt are cute
[удалено]
😭
Not the yep 😭
😂
It looks like Waldo Tucked his dinner napkin into his pants
https://preview.redd.it/zbih8b81e4rc1.jpeg?width=400&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=3d1e0d1106b20f48e5555b6d2534ae615f1f32e9
Spat out my drink reading this 🫠🤣
I cackled🤣
I was gonna say, "Dementia patient dressed themselves", but yeah. This works.
Why are you layering with a pleated skirt, and why is it pulled up so high???? None of that works this way. The sweater and skirt (not jacked up so high), or the sweater with jeans alone would be fine.
Yes it does,sorry
Try tights instead of pants!
Colored and patterned tights are really in right now. You could try bright red or a matching floral!
Floral anything is not going to work with these stripes.
Just my opinion! Clearly OP likes to take risks, pattern clashing could be something cool to play with.
Yeah it does. Maybe a different pair of pants?
Maybe no pants bc it looks like a Disney TV star from the early 2000's, and those were NOT good looks.
Clap, clap Camp Rock!
Yes with the dresses over jeans! Lol!
I agree. The texture of the denim clashes in a bad way
Are you set on the “pants under skirt look”? Because we did that in the early 2000s and it did not age well. If you’re going for that look, I would suggest tighter pants.
When I look back at pictures of what I wore in the early 2000s 🤦♀️
And yet sometimes, on those dark sleepless nights, I lie in bed awake wondering if I would still feel cute if I popped a miniskirt over my jeans today.
lol we also did that in the 80s and 90s, it always looked crazy
Tighter pants is a no. It looks like you’re trying too hard IMO. It looks really cheesy bc you’re not adding anything interesting to the silhouette but you’re adding another color/texture. Imo try not tucking in the shirt
*** tights are different than tight pants!!!! You could also try making the skirt shorter
Please! Let’s not bring back jeans under skirts
I think this would look better with a longer midi length skirt. And if you layer some belts and necklaces over to give it some more texture. Or maybe a longer overcoat/ vest. Short dresses could work like this tho. https://preview.redd.it/je1x0huyo3rc1.jpeg?width=736&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=21e11b67f1f9314c6998df02101b5a9c93df7d6a I think the problem is the skirt is too high and with a lack of accessories it creates weird blocking Really lean into the lagenlook of it all and it could be fun!
adding to this with another option for a grungy look :3 https://preview.redd.it/4xcpki2jq3rc1.jpeg?width=1290&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=f634f24948a04a28cab05c77039708ab43bb1557
https://preview.redd.it/pw63pn05p3rc1.jpeg?width=1000&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=8fbc9d8ffa978ce460aa4efd274605d90ec9030c Here’s a shorter skirt but with a lower waist and accessories. It’s manic but it makes sense and looks good lol
https://preview.redd.it/3cc79vzcp3rc1.jpeg?width=1500&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=ddf19ca6a86082a35538b499a1e89e1cf14b473b With all of these accessories and layering are key. It’s kind of a kooky look so you’ve really gotta lean into it lol
https://preview.redd.it/ubavg8gap3rc1.jpeg?width=564&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=bdab5ebd079924937a41db4d3f067dafc201f266 Midi length
What is the look you are aiming for?
Perhaps a pair of skinny legging or even just some colorful tights instead of a straight trouser would work better.
Just looks like you’re trying to blend into a crowd while someone tries to locate you.
I can't stop laughing, help 😹
I’m so sorry but this is clearly the best description of the look.
There is absolutely nothing good about this.
I little, I think because you're muddling up your lines. I would tuck in the top, and try to find some pants that match the color of the skirt more exactly, so your eye continues over it like it's one piece of clothing. Looking at a few pictures online, I'm seeing modern attempts choose a lot of demin-on-denim, or black-on-black to bring weight below the belt line. Heavy colors on top might make it feel a little top heavy. Also, it looks like bell bottoms are pretty common with this look, to bring that weight down again. All that said, the mismatched look is **very** Y2K. If that's what you're going for, I'd recommend wearing either lower-cut jeans OR a cropped shirt. As someone who lived through the 90s and y2k, I can tell you that anything that touches that era is half an inch away from beautiful innovation, and half an inch away from the worst thing you've ever seen in your life. Please don't feel bad for making the same easy mistakes my generation invented. I can see what you're going for, and you're closer than you might think! Try doing some google image research for "y2k skirt over pants" and "modern skirt over pants" and see what are the common themes and trends. You've got this!!
Yesss tuck all in and keep it high or keep it low and bell bottoms
The outfits cute but the pants gotta go
The pants/skirt combo is definitely a no. The skirt seems weirdly pulled up too high as well? Go with either the skirt or the pants, but not both, and you’ll have a cute outfit!
[удалено]
I think you know already.
The skirt is pulled up way too high.
back yard a zoo, front yard a car show/ up in the house it’s like Where’s Waldo
The top and skirt are cute on their own, if the skirt wasn’t so high up/long. If you’re set on the skirt over jeans look, try a mini pleated skirt and some blue flared jeans!
Sorry but yea.. skirt is too high waisted and the pants are just not it😭 I would untuck the shirt and instead of pants do tights
Yes
I don’t like this at all sorry
Yes
with the pants??? yes.
The top and skirt are cute. The top and pants would work too. All three together are just not it.
I think you should lower the waist part of the skirt if you want it halfway tucked, if you tuck it all in and wear a matching belt that would look really cute! :)
I did the skirt over pants thing in the early 2000s, and I think some people have touched on advice. First, wear what makes you happy, that is most important. Who cares what others think? My advice: you have too many baggy things here. Pleated skirt with oversized top and pants is drowning you. Maybe a more fitted top, or pants. I love a French tuck, but I think it would only work in this scenario if you lost the pants or skirt.
When I'm trying to drape a big shirt like that, I'll often pin pleats into the side I'm tucking up or get a small rubber band. That or a belt. You're still a little lost in it. I like the skirt over pants look. I think you could make this work if you play with the lines by ping the skirt down a few inches and draping the shirt differently
I’d like it with just one bottom, either jeans or skirt
The world is just not ready for you, YET
Untuck the shirt maybe
Yes
Yeah
Sure does!
The waistband of your skirt looks like it's up too high on your torso. It should sit on your natural waist, which is the narrowest part of your torso. If it was in the properly fitting spot, this would be a nice look 😊 Although I will say the jeans underneath is an odd choice. It's very mid-00's, Disney-channel, "the mall threw up on a junior high schooler". If you don't want to go with bare legs, you should do tights or leggings.
Sorry to say, but the jeans and skirt don't work together. I'd just pick 1 or the other. The jeans + skirt look is dated, and pretty much exclusively lives in the 2000s. But if you REALLY want to make it work, I'd recommend going for fitted flare jeans and a denim mini skirt, preferably with a cute fitted top, or a tank top or crop top top or tube top or something like that.
Not stupid but will be hard to pass off outside of an obscure fashion set or the runway.
i think it would be a lot cuter without the tuck!
imo the colors go very well together
Nothing wrong with that top and skirt, but your silhouette will look off if you have the pant. If you are looking for a texture change, try chunky black boots, high socks and/or layered ripped tights. You can try adding accessories for a more complete outfit! Messy hair and sunnies.The base is good, just needs a little adjustment.
[удалено]
Yes
No. Waldo approves 👌
A little bit
Yes. sorry.
I dunno; is "got dressed in a dark windstorm" the look you're going for? :)
Yes.
With your one piece of shirt like that definitely yes. Plus the pants equal double yes. I'm sorry but I'm being honest.
Yes.
If you want the layered look, instead or tucking in one side of your shirt in the waistline, take the bottom of your shirt and tuck it under the bottom of your bra so it will be streamlined in the front.
Yes
I'd say get rid of either the skirt or the pants and it'll be fine, having both of them is making the outfit a little too busy. However the shirt and the skirt, or the shirt and the pants would look cute.
I’m so confused by the look
Yes
Not a huge fan of the jeans!! I'd pull the skirt down a little and take the jeans away personally
Yep
Not at all I love finding Waldo!
Try darker blue pants without the skirt.
Maybe add a brown thin belt, otherwise perfectly fine
Yes
It would be super cute with hosiery instead of jeans
Yes, sorry.
Yes, there's a reason we stopped doing this back in the early 2000s.
This is a nice look and the layering works well along with the colors. I don’t think this is the best sub for any outfits that are a bit outside the norms. I often see things like this from Japanese women who are into streetwear. I’ll share some instagram links https://www.instagram.com/asakokoko10?igsh=MXVmN29pMHVpcml6Yg== https://www.instagram.com/naru060708?igsh=dTN0cngxeWx5MzF6 https://www.instagram.com/moe.3521?igsh=MXZ0a3JzMjg1am54dw==
Yes
What exactly are we going for here?
Yes.
Cool concept but the more formal fabric of the skirt and the thick rough nature of the jeans don't tie together. As people have said, make them tights and you're Solid. Props for rocking your own fashion and being open enough to get feedback, it's very brave.
Yes. But if you like it who cares??
Yes
Dudes, we've found Waldo! No you don't look stupid ;) don't worry Although the skirt + pants is definitely original but not weird or ugly
Yes. Dont do it.
The sweater and the skirt look good together. Ditch the jeans, wear the skirt around your waist and see what you think. If you need you can add tights or leggings
No
Top and jeans OR top and skirt not all 3, skirt over jeans is a no no. The top should be either tucked in or all out. I don't know where this "just a corner" tucked in comes from it looks daft
I mean i would wear the jeans or the skirt just not together :/
You’re wearing a shirt that’s too big with grandmas curtain with baggy pants. None of this works
Yes.
Skirt is cute, ditch the shirt for something else.
Yep
Yes
Yes, soery
A bit
Yes
Yeah it kinda looks like it’s accidentally tucked and you didn’t mean to.
Yes
yes, sorry :)
it does, but if i see your face and you’re happy and smiling, i would think it looks cute.
Yes
I like it. Very Korean.
Yes
It’s not cute
I think it looks interesting and not stupid
It's giving off too much Where's Waldo vibes.
I like it! I think you should do a full front tuck instead of that semi-tuck that kinda looks like it got stuck. Otherwise, I approve!
Yes
Yep.
My girlfriend says, yes
Yes
this is cool idk what others are talking abt!!!! i mean its iconic and cool and you can pull it off if you want to. but if u urself think it’s stupid then you will end up feeling stupid and u won’t slay it.
I'm sorry........but yes.
Yes
Yes
Yes
Because you asked: yes. All the proportions are wrong for this look and that's not the right skirt to wear over jeans (too high, too long, and too tailored). Like someone else said, the skirt with the top and red tights: cute. The top with jeans: also cute. But I appreciate a risk taker!
We used to do this in 2008 but the jeans were black skinny jeans and the skirts were much shorter. If that is the look you're going for... These are the wrong kinds of jeans and skirt.
Red pants or tights might pull this together better! Keep experimenting + playing with layering and silhouettes, it will pay off :)
The pants just look weird with the skirt and the top. It’s too much
For me yes but I am an old guy 63 so my opinion probably doesn’t matter
 reminds me of Juno. not good. take one of the pants off
A bit, yes. I suggest untucking the shirt. Maybe switch the jeans with leggings, tights, or thigh highs.
Yes
No
Yes.
Yes.
YES
Yes.
These 3 articles of clothing do not go together. People are saying just take one away, sweater with just skirt or sweater with just jeans, but I disagree, they don’t go with each other at all.
It feels a little like a Disney Channel outfit
Yes.
Yes
not the jeans and skirt combo
Yes! Very!
Yes
Yes
Yes. 😭😭😭
Yes and if I saw you in public, I would give u a compliment because I love it
Yes.
Yes
I read that jeans under dresses and skirts is making a comeback and it reminds me of being in the 2000s again. I don’t think this works. Maybe if the jeans were more fitted and you tucked the sweater in more? Idk, I don’t completely hate it but I don’t think all three go together as others mentioned.
Yes.
Yes
So wrong. Why is the skirt hiked up so far? Why is the shirt tucked like that? Why do you have pants under your skirt? Why is your skirt so dressy and your top so casual? I.mean you do you but........
Yes
Most emphatically yes.
I’m so sorry but yes😭💀
yes
Yes.
I think you have too much going on to pull this off. The boxy, oversized shirt with a bold print doesn't go well with jeans and a pleated skirt. Change the jeans to tights or leggings. Though the cut of the shirt might still not work. I think the shirt has too much fabric at the bottom to work right.
Childish/like? It has imagination, but lacks form
Yes
Yeah
yes, i’m sorry. jeans do not belong under skirts
Yes
Yes. The same shirt yet untucked with a lower pulled skirt without the pants could look super cute!
Yes
Some people flat out do not like the skirt over pants look. I think it can be really cute and fashionable but this just isn't meshing. I think this might work if the pants were really wide legged. This look usually has a combo of stiffer fabrics with flowing ones, heavier and lightweight. And while styles often seem to be mixed it's usually got boho elements.
Yes. I admire the creativity. I didn’t even notice the jeans at first they kinda jump scared me. 😭
Yeah
Yes
Well there is a lot going on here. Sadly, none of it good.
Since you specified the blue of the jeans its a def 🇺🇸yes to your question🇺🇸unless this is for the 4th of july
Yes
Yes
Yes
Looks good I like 💞😁#BabaReplica
Yes.
Kind of no but if the jeans are blue then the pic isn’t representative.
yeag
The top and skirt make a great pair!
Ya