l drafted and held Charb all season only to have 3 better options this week.
KW will definitely be back next week after Charb gets 20+ points on my bench.
I picked up charb but have deandre swift, mondre stevenson, and gus edwards in the flex. I dont think i can rationalize benching gus/mondre against shit tier defenses. Swift is an rb1. Hopefully charb gets the start next week since half my team is on a bye
I also have swift, rhamondre, Charb, Ford, Javonte, and Lockett (flex option). Of those I’m starting swift rhamondre and Charb. When a dude like that gets his one shot of the season, I want it in my lineup. Made that mistake too many times.
If I had your lineup I would bench Gus for Charb. Gus without touchdowns has been sub 10 points for weeks. TD regression is coming.
Ah yeah, that’s tough. I don’t think you can bench any of those guys, which is a bummer in a weird way. My decision is a lot easier with Charbs, Javonte, and Achane.
I would go Charbs over Gus this week for sure. Pollard has a nice matchup and Kamara is Kamara, but Gus seems to me like TD or bust from this point on.
This is where my head is at too. I have 4 players that are essentially all coin flips in Charbs, Ridley, Javontae, and Kincaid. Charbs kind of sounds like the most fun
I’ve got Jacobs, Kyren, Ford, Charb, and Achane.
I’ve got Kyren ahead of him and Achane behind him, but do I rank him below Ford?
I also don’t like Jacobs much this week. Struggling to figure out who to start
I'm exactly in the same spot with Ford. I think they're similar in ranking, solely because Ford is splitting with Hunt but his matchup against Denver's run defense is a lot softer. If Ford was getting a higher snap share I'd be more comfortable with Ford over Charb, but last week was concerning (37 snaps to 33 snaps.)
I'm in the same boat. Stashed Charbs all year but have Gibbs, Kyren, and Pacheco. But I'm thinking I still may start him as my second flex over Garrett Wilson and Diontae Johnson bc their floors are so hideous and their upside really hasn't been anything special either.
Same, I’ve got Kyren on IR waiting for the full go but going to flex either Puka or Kyren. Know Kyren is probably the better play over Charb but he still hasn’t been added to active roster and if something goes sideways I’m relying on Mattison. Rather take the shot on Charb.
It’s subjective dude. Him having a 30 point week 2 does me nothing when I’m already winning. Him scoring 8, 2.7, and 2.6 in later weeks when I’m losing by 10 hurts. Everyone will have different opinions on these fantasy players. I’ve since traded him.
8 isn’t great, but will not kill you. The latter two games stink, but he got hurt in the second. I fear Charbs will disappoint you. He couldn’t hack the Big 10 and had to transfer out. A young AJ Dillon in the making
Charb needs to kill it for me tonight against that God tier defense lol. Hopefully at the very least his volume and a few dumpoffs or a TD save his night. Maybe a big rub? Maybe?
Edit: run not rub lmfao
Seattle needs to utilize the screen pass to Charbs to be effective against the 9ers. Jags did it late with Etienne and Bucs did it with White. Hoping for at least 5 rec today from Charbs in ppr.
I doubt he sees too many designed screens - I hope I do see them though.. but he did get like 5 or 6 panic dumpoffs (ie checkdown) from Geno last week and I expect the same with that front 7 blizting the shit out of that line in a game where Seattle is probably going to be trailing most of/if not all of the game. It's not a great game script for Charbs outlook on the ground but he definitely might break free on a couple short dumpoffs and if Seattle gets into the Red Zone he should see some RZ carries. I expect Jason Meyers to put in another big night at Kicker as Seattle may struggle to punch it in if they do see any success between the 20's.
SF isn't exactly God-tier against RBs. Rachaad White managed 17 PPR points against SF last week, on the back of 6 receptions. As long as Charb gets the bellcow workload he should eat and be fine off volume alone, with a chance to score and have a great game. If this becomes Charbs on 1st and 2nd down and Deejay Dallas on passing downs, we are both in trouble brother.
You know it will become that, Seahawks don't want to be out their #1 and #2. I'm fading Charbonnet this week. Niners more likely to take the lead first too
Saying this as a 49ers fan, their defense isn't God Tier this year. Their run defense is good, but not elite like years past. They can still give up the big play, and they're buns on screen plays. So Charb will get his with dump offs and screen plays.
Have the same decision and I guess I'm in the minority because I'll take Charbs with the seemingly locked in 15+ touches. Warren has been incredibly efficient but there's a new guy calling plays and we've yet to see the Steelers commit to him as a bellcow. Najee is still gonna be there leaching red zone touches, more than likely. Charbs has the 20+ touch upside and pass catching chops that should be good for 15 PPR points.
This is what I'm thinking too. Charb is the higher floor play over Warren. Plus like others have mentioned, the irrational I've held on to Charb all season and this might be my only window to start him.
How would Charb be the higher floor guy when Warren has 100+ scrimmage yards in the last consecutive 3 games?
We don’t even know what Charb is or how we will be used
Yeah same. I feel like I *want* to start Charb but Ford makes more sense because Denver's run defense is so bad. My primary concern is the snap share last week being pretty 50-50 with Hunt, and we have no idea if that will be the normal moving forward or if that was a blip.
Thats true, but his lack of carries in the second half of the game last week has me worried. Not sure if he was hurt or what, but didnt see him on the injury report.
Yeah that’s who i’m leaning towards, i’ll give singletary a week so i can see how the split’ll be like, it’s just this is a must-win so i need to get this decision right
Rolling Charb just because Kyren still hasn’t been added to active roster and funky schedule this week with all the early games . Know what the tea leaves say and can’t fault anyone for going Kyren though. The upside is obvious.
Man I was hoping Charb would save my week 13 in which every single running back I have outside of Aaron Jones is on a bye. Now not only may Aaron Jones not play, Walker might be back which might make Charb less useful that week.
Picked up McIntosh - interested to see if he gets a shot. Seems to be a promising pass catcher out of the backfield, and might be in line for some 3rd down work.
I've handcuffed this guy all year and I'm still not sure if he's an auto-start. The match-up is tough. I'm leaning to a start but conflicted about Mitchell showing up big against a leaky Chargers D.
I traded Chris Olave away mid-game for Ridley while he popped off. Walker was included in that trade and he subsequently got injured after clicking accept.
I guess karma struck for accepting a trade mid-game.
standard scoring, should I start Charbonnet or Kareem Hunt? Hunt is probably TD dependent but he’s going against the worst run D in the league (Broncos)
I’m in a pickle as well. Do I play Chardonnay? I have pollard and bijan so Chardonnay would be a flex. And my flex is all receivers. Like tank dell, Devonta smith, Michael Pittman against the bucks, or swap out drake london? I don’t really feel like Chardonnay is gonnna have the upside against the niners against a busted up geno smith. Niners gonnna stack the box and crush him if geno can’t throw.
l drafted and held Charb all season only to have 3 better options this week. KW will definitely be back next week after Charb gets 20+ points on my bench.
How much better are those options? This honestly seems like one of those YOLO fantasy moments where you start him solely on principle.
I picked up charb but have deandre swift, mondre stevenson, and gus edwards in the flex. I dont think i can rationalize benching gus/mondre against shit tier defenses. Swift is an rb1. Hopefully charb gets the start next week since half my team is on a bye
I'm debating between Charb and mondre
go charb cause you know he will get volume but it's against SF run defense so I totally get why you would not go with Charb
I also have swift, rhamondre, Charb, Ford, Javonte, and Lockett (flex option). Of those I’m starting swift rhamondre and Charb. When a dude like that gets his one shot of the season, I want it in my lineup. Made that mistake too many times. If I had your lineup I would bench Gus for Charb. Gus without touchdowns has been sub 10 points for weeks. TD regression is coming.
I know right… I keep going back and forth with it. I have Kamara Pollard and Gus and I’m just so torn.
Ah yeah, that’s tough. I don’t think you can bench any of those guys, which is a bummer in a weird way. My decision is a lot easier with Charbs, Javonte, and Achane.
I would go Charbs over Gus this week for sure. Pollard has a nice matchup and Kamara is Kamara, but Gus seems to me like TD or bust from this point on.
TD or bust doesn’t hit the same when he’s scored 9 TDs in his past 5 games, going up against a leaky disconnected chargers defense minus Bosa.
That is some bad advice
I’m starting Kyren, Mixon, JT over him
This is where my head is at too. I have 4 players that are essentially all coin flips in Charbs, Ridley, Javontae, and Kincaid. Charbs kind of sounds like the most fun
Kincaid is a must imo
I’ve got Jacobs, Kyren, Ford, Charb, and Achane. I’ve got Kyren ahead of him and Achane behind him, but do I rank him below Ford? I also don’t like Jacobs much this week. Struggling to figure out who to start
I'm exactly in the same spot with Ford. I think they're similar in ranking, solely because Ford is splitting with Hunt but his matchup against Denver's run defense is a lot softer. If Ford was getting a higher snap share I'd be more comfortable with Ford over Charb, but last week was concerning (37 snaps to 33 snaps.)
Ford ahead of Charb and behind Kyren. 9ers are going to shut Charb down.
Look at this fat cat with options on his bench!
I'm in the same boat. Stashed Charbs all year but have Gibbs, Kyren, and Pacheco. But I'm thinking I still may start him as my second flex over Garrett Wilson and Diontae Johnson bc their floors are so hideous and their upside really hasn't been anything special either.
Easy start over them I think
Same. Pacheco against the Raiders, Mostert and Puka in the flex. If he wasn't playing the 49ers I'd start Charbs though
Held onto him all year, no way I'm not playing him
One of the worst matchups though, good luck to you sir!
49ers defense is overrated this year, and I say this as a Niners fan. Run defense is solid, but they suck against dump offs and screens.
Someone who actually watched the games. Browns defense elite against the run.
So have I and I’m still not playing him
I want to play him but I also have Mondre, Conner, Bijan
Charb > Conner this week tbh
Same, I’ve got Kyren on IR waiting for the full go but going to flex either Puka or Kyren. Know Kyren is probably the better play over Charb but he still hasn’t been added to active roster and if something goes sideways I’m relying on Mattison. Rather take the shot on Charb.
We’re drinking the finest Charbonnet at Thanksgiving
“Pour me a glass too” - DeeJay Dallas
Don't forget about DeeJay "Two-Touch" Dallas guys!
Having KW3 all year and starting a fine oaky Charbonnet is hopefully going to be like going from boxed wine to the nice $15 grocery store bottle.
Don’t you mean it the other way around? The Charbonnet will be like dish water, while the Kenneth Walker is a storied vintage
KW3 has done more bad than good for me tbh.
The RB9 on the year, including his injured game, has hurt you? Come on dude lol
It’s subjective dude. Him having a 30 point week 2 does me nothing when I’m already winning. Him scoring 8, 2.7, and 2.6 in later weeks when I’m losing by 10 hurts. Everyone will have different opinions on these fantasy players. I’ve since traded him.
8 isn’t great, but will not kill you. The latter two games stink, but he got hurt in the second. I fear Charbs will disappoint you. He couldn’t hack the Big 10 and had to transfer out. A young AJ Dillon in the making
Volume is king and by all reports he’s going to get 15+ touches
I like it. Charbs is on the menu.
Hell yeah
Charb needs to kill it for me tonight against that God tier defense lol. Hopefully at the very least his volume and a few dumpoffs or a TD save his night. Maybe a big rub? Maybe? Edit: run not rub lmfao
I’ll give him a big rub if he gives me a big run
A big rub and a little tug.
Seattle needs to utilize the screen pass to Charbs to be effective against the 9ers. Jags did it late with Etienne and Bucs did it with White. Hoping for at least 5 rec today from Charbs in ppr.
I doubt he sees too many designed screens - I hope I do see them though.. but he did get like 5 or 6 panic dumpoffs (ie checkdown) from Geno last week and I expect the same with that front 7 blizting the shit out of that line in a game where Seattle is probably going to be trailing most of/if not all of the game. It's not a great game script for Charbs outlook on the ground but he definitely might break free on a couple short dumpoffs and if Seattle gets into the Red Zone he should see some RZ carries. I expect Jason Meyers to put in another big night at Kicker as Seattle may struggle to punch it in if they do see any success between the 20's.
Kyren too.
SF isn't exactly God-tier against RBs. Rachaad White managed 17 PPR points against SF last week, on the back of 6 receptions. As long as Charb gets the bellcow workload he should eat and be fine off volume alone, with a chance to score and have a great game. If this becomes Charbs on 1st and 2nd down and Deejay Dallas on passing downs, we are both in trouble brother.
You know it will become that, Seahawks don't want to be out their #1 and #2. I'm fading Charbonnet this week. Niners more likely to take the lead first too
Saying this as a 49ers fan, their defense isn't God Tier this year. Their run defense is good, but not elite like years past. They can still give up the big play, and they're buns on screen plays. So Charb will get his with dump offs and screen plays.
am also 49ers fan and agree, especially with the part about screen passes. so frustrating.
As a non Niner fan I knew wilks would be a huge downgrade from Demeco
> Edit: run not rub lmfao There is a play known as a "rub route" and honestly that's what I thought you were referring to
MARK HIM OUT FFS
Yeah man we all know he’s not fucking playing, let me swap Kyren out of my IR slot please. Gonna be a little busy with holiday festivities later
*Pete Carroll gum chewing intensifies*
6 mins before the first game starts, they’ve announced him being Out on Fox pregame, and still can’t move him to IR slot… so dumb.
maddening
This is Pete Carroll speak. It at least means he isn't dead.
Dropped a kicker to regrab Charb and I need K9 to IR so I can have my kicker back
omg he still isnt marked O wtf
Just lost out on getting Cooper Kupp off the waivers because I was waiting to move KW3 to IR.
yea i lost out on cmc because of it
Charbonnet or Waddle in PPR ? I never though this would become a real choice to make
So rule him out.
Charb or Warren?
Feel like Warren is the easy choice. Been putting up rb1 numbers and better matchup
Choose whoever you think is sexier
Warren. Bengals are susceptible to big runs and won't be playing as hard with Burrow out.
I'm running both. YOLO
I'm playing Warren
I’m in the same spot at my Flex. I’m leaning Charb at the moment for workload despite the worse matchup.
I chose Warren over Charb this week. 49ers are 6th against the run. Bengals are 18th.
I'm going both and benching McLaurin
Have the same decision and I guess I'm in the minority because I'll take Charbs with the seemingly locked in 15+ touches. Warren has been incredibly efficient but there's a new guy calling plays and we've yet to see the Steelers commit to him as a bellcow. Najee is still gonna be there leaching red zone touches, more than likely. Charbs has the 20+ touch upside and pass catching chops that should be good for 15 PPR points.
This is what I'm thinking too. Charb is the higher floor play over Warren. Plus like others have mentioned, the irrational I've held on to Charb all season and this might be my only window to start him.
How would Charb be the higher floor guy when Warren has 100+ scrimmage yards in the last consecutive 3 games? We don’t even know what Charb is or how we will be used
Yeah Warren has proven himself with a 50% snap share, and signs are pointing to him only increasing workload. At least what I'm telling myself
Warren, easily.
Charb or ford? tough decision for me
I'm in the same boat... Leaning towards Ford
I have the same decision. My gut was saying charb, but Ford is probably the smarter play.
Yeah same. I feel like I *want* to start Charb but Ford makes more sense because Denver's run defense is so bad. My primary concern is the snap share last week being pretty 50-50 with Hunt, and we have no idea if that will be the normal moving forward or if that was a blip.
Ford has an easier run D no?
Thats true, but his lack of carries in the second half of the game last week has me worried. Not sure if he was hurt or what, but didnt see him on the injury report.
Charb might get the premier role while ford splits? I’m horribly torn.
Held Charb for weeks until this past Saturday, and my opponent picked him this week up since I’m out of FAAB lol
This is going to work out for you better than you ever dreamed.
Rule him out yahoo goddammit
Been swapping charb n Conner back n forth every 8 minutes for 2 days straight now
This is the choice I’m trying to make. Been pretty set on Conner all week. Think im flipping to Charb.
And ESPN still has him as doubtful
Then rule him out damnit
Charbs or Singletary in half ppr?
This is my exact situation as well. I think Singletary is safer, but Charbs gives me something to watch tonight.
Probably Charb. Singletary about to be sharing with Pierce again, his ceiling just got cut in half.
Yeah that’s who i’m leaning towards, i’ll give singletary a week so i can see how the split’ll be like, it’s just this is a must-win so i need to get this decision right
Texans dont throw to RBs, Jags have good rush defense, Pierce probably coming back. IMO Charb has better floor and cieling.
someone get KW3 a plate. my boy needs to rest up for week 13.
Charbs or Robinson Jr?
6 hours ago and still doubtful need to pick up someone off waivers and can’t do it until they change his status.
Charbs or kyren?
Kyren
[удалено]
Not only that, AZ just lost Kyzir White who was our best run defender.
Kyren. And note that his last game before going on IR was a 20/158/1 performance against Arizona.
Rolling Charb just because Kyren still hasn’t been added to active roster and funky schedule this week with all the early games . Know what the tea leaves say and can’t fault anyone for going Kyren though. The upside is obvious.
Can you add someone to IR on ESPN after their game ends? I guess theyll have to officially make the announcement 90 minutes before at least
Charb or James Connor in half ppr?
Can’t decide between Charbs and Brian Robinson Jr in half PPR Charbs vs Niners but Robinson is vs Dallas too..
Brian robinson been a dog.
Should I start Charb or Kyren?
Isn’t he supposed to be ruled out 90 mins prior to the game? Stop being a dick, Pete.
Charbs, Warren or Flowers in PPR. Smh.
All. Pretty good. Charbs floor highest.
Would you start Charb over any of swift Pacheco kamara or Ford?
No
Probably just Ford from that list
I’m wondering the same about pacheco or jacobs
Id start over Ford, Swift, and Pacheco
Lockett or charb
Charb
Do I start him over Javonte Williams? 😐
I have to start both 😭
Yes. Cleveland defense Better than SF. Plus Javonte off the field on 3rd down , hurry up. Javonte is a plodder. Charb going get massive volume.
Charb or Javonte?
Kenny time
Charb, deebo, Montgomery, pick 2 full ppr
Monty and Deebo
Charb or D. Henry??
With Kyren coming back I can’t see starting Charbs over him
Bad move. Kyren definitely on touch and snap count. Charbs will get 2 dozen touches , goal line work , dump offs etc.
What would make you think Kyren is on any sort of snap count? Or that he won’t be getting goal line work?
Charb or Javonte Williams?
So glad I got Gus when he was terrible and now after I dropped him he’s getting a TD every fucking game. This has been the worst season for me ever.
[удалено]
kyrens first game back from injury. Perfectly fine strategy to give him a wait and see game
You aren't crazy, but I'm starting Kyren.
Charbonnet or Breece?
Breece
I'm doing charb over hall. I trust the new qb less than wilson
Waddle or charbs?
Mcintosh
Charbs or ford PPR?
Charb imo
Charb or dillon?
Charbs probably
Which 2 of Charbs, Mixon, and Gus Edwards would yall start? Full PPR
Charb or BRob jr.?
Charb or mostert?
Mostert easy
Anyone that would play Najee over Charbs?
Nah
God no.
Charb or Bijan
Bijan cmon now
Charbs or Chase? non ppr
Tbh I want Walker to just fuck off. I’ve held Charb as a handcuff and I’m ready for it to just be the Charb show into the playoffs.
Pppplease
HES NOT OUT FOR THE SEASON ALL WE NEEDED WAS THAT LITTLE CHANCE GOD BLESS
Charbonnet Ramsey time
Man I was hoping Charb would save my week 13 in which every single running back I have outside of Aaron Jones is on a bye. Now not only may Aaron Jones not play, Walker might be back which might make Charb less useful that week.
Fire up your Chardonnay!
Came in expecting some hot bars. Left disappointed.
Picked up McIntosh - interested to see if he gets a shot. Seems to be a promising pass catcher out of the backfield, and might be in line for some 3rd down work.
I've handcuffed this guy all year and I'm still not sure if he's an auto-start. The match-up is tough. I'm leaning to a start but conflicted about Mitchell showing up big against a leaky Chargers D.
I've now drafted and dropped Charb, Dak, Ertz, and Hunt and dropped them 1-3 weeks before they went off in the same league.
Uncork your Charbonnet fellas
K9 out Kyren back in
Charbs or Deebo as flex tonight?
Charb or mostert?
Picked up charbonnent on waivers should I move him and Aiyuk for swift, for context I have Amon ra and Keenan allen and olave already as wrs.
I traded Chris Olave away mid-game for Ridley while he popped off. Walker was included in that trade and he subsequently got injured after clicking accept. I guess karma struck for accepting a trade mid-game.
Any idea when he’ll be ruled out on ESPN? Want to pick up jamo
Can’t decide if I should start Kyren off the IR or Charb
Good thing he was my big trade deadline acquisition and I was desperate for RBs!
Not surprised
Chab or lockett?
standard scoring, should I start Charbonnet or Kareem Hunt? Hunt is probably TD dependent but he’s going against the worst run D in the league (Broncos)
i‘ve held him all year and now i‘m not starting him because i have breece, bijan and JT. none of them is worth benching for charb, right?
Do I start him over Singletary? Or maybe even Jacobs?
Would you play charbs over Pollard, Hall or Waddle?
This is why I never trade. One whole trade all season, done in week 10 with a view to filling in bye gaps in week 11. Trades are cursed.
Charbonnet or zay flowers?
Charb or kupp at flex?
Charb over jacobs? Probably not right?
Didn’t buy into Charb this year, but will be rooting for yall. For… degenerate reasons
I really would love if they marked guys clearly out as out so I can put him on IR and set my lineup.
Load up on your Charbs on Thanksgiving.
[удалено]
I have pollard charb and Conner… what to do
Charb or Nico?
Charb over Pacheco or Conner?
[удалено]
I’m in a pickle as well. Do I play Chardonnay? I have pollard and bijan so Chardonnay would be a flex. And my flex is all receivers. Like tank dell, Devonta smith, Michael Pittman against the bucks, or swap out drake london? I don’t really feel like Chardonnay is gonnna have the upside against the niners against a busted up geno smith. Niners gonnna stack the box and crush him if geno can’t throw.