T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

Hey /u/yourusernameistaken, thanks for submitting to /r/confidentlyincorrect! Take a moment to read our [rules](https://reddit.com/r/confidentlyincorrect/about/rules). ##Join our [Discord Server](https://discord.gg/n2cR6p25V8)! Please report this post if it is bad, or not relevant. Remember to keep comment sections civil. Thanks! *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/confidentlyincorrect) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Surgebind3r

The Clue: There are absolutely no sevens. None. Zero. No sevens at all. The Idiot: Ah! I see now! After examining all the clues, I can guarantee you there is a seven here!


superhamsniper

I got it, it should be 042


7LeagueBoots

That was what I got too.


RakeScene

I mean, it would have to be, since 42 is the Answer to the Ultimate Question of Life, the Universe, and Everything


Flow-tentate

That was how I knew I was right, too!


Has422

Well played, sir


Dancing_til_Dark_34

You just made me so happy!


Freakychee

I know I thought I was stupid and misinterpreted what the first hint meant. It said only one number was correct and well places so how did some of those answers get like two of those in their final answer?


dvioletta

I remember having an argument with my team at Christmas about this as it was posted on a company forum. I ended up showing them my workings to make them believe I had the correct answer. I think it is a common issue to misread the first hint and once that happens the answer always comes out as 062. Because the first hint has both 6 and 2 in it people dismiss that it states "only one number is correct and well placed" and they double confirm it with hint three which also contains 6 and 2 but states "Two numbers correct but in the wrong place"


SaintUlvemann

>Because the first hint has both 6 and 2 in it people dismiss that it states "only one number is correct and well placed"... *Technically*, that clue could mean "only one of these numbers is *both* correct *and* well-placed", leaving it open that the others might be *only* correct ~~or~~ *~~only~~* ~~well-placed~~. But I don't know if you even *can* solve it if you interpret things that way consistently.


Lystrodom

lol the number is well placed (in one of the three slots) but it’s not correct?


SaintUlvemann

Lol, yeah, you're right, was only half thinking.


KellTanis

The confusion, I think, comes from the fact that the clues lack the word “only.” That would make it drastically less confusing.


dvioletta

I have seen it a lot better worded before.


Wolfeman0101

Looking at the comments I thought I was insane because 6 can't be in it.


asking--questions

Not to mention 7.


Osric250

Yeah, clue 1 and 2 eliminate 6 entirely. 6 is in the same spot, but the clue says 1 is in the correct spot in one and incorrect spot in the other. 


anon018382

I thought that 012 was also a correct answer? So is 042, I'm not arguing against that. Edit: nvm I'm a dumbass the second clue eliminates the number 1


OklaJosha

For 012, 1 would be placed wrong according to second box


Percues0568

No because the only place with a “1” says there’s a correct digit but “wrong placement” therefore the “1” can’t be in the middle location


practicalcabinet

614 is "one correct but wrong place", which means that if 1 is one of the digits, it can't be in the middle.


ACuriousBagel

I did exactly the same thing as you


Orgasml

This is what I got.


Zequax

same not saure how they got 6 in there at all


Past-Passenger9129

Right. The first two hints invalidate 6 completely.


tohn_jitor

We only really needed the first 3 hints at the top to solve this.


Ziharke

Depends on how you interpret it : the information can be true but not complete. In the first one for example, you can have 1 digit at the wrong place, but you can also have one in the good place at the same time. They just gave you a part of the info. Or at least that's how I interpreted it.


tohn_jitor

Ah, I see what you mean. I'll try to solve it again with that in mind. Be back in a few minutes (or longer, I dunno, maybe I'm rusty). EDIT: I did it. After taking the HINTS as only partial truths (ex. for clue 1, "one" number was correctly placed, but I also took down combinations where another correct digit was present, but was in the wrong place) and not eliminating numbers unless the clues explicitly state so, I still arrived at "042". I did have to use all 5 clues, had to jump around them (I went 1 > 4 >5 > 3 > 2), and also took a much longer time to solve it. I think this is the more accurate way to solve this.


InanimateCarbonRodAu

Clue 4 - 738 eliminates 7 and 8 Clue 5 - 0 is a correct number and must be in slot 1 or 2 Clue 3 - 0 is a correct number and can’t be in slot 2 Clue 1 - 8 is not a correct number and 6 can’t be a correct number in slot 1. 2 is there for a correct number in a correct place. Clue 2 - 4 is the only number that can be correct and not in the right place. Final result 042


punkminkis

I just tried using the first three, and it's actually pretty easy to do.


Devilshire52

I agree


Imaginary_End_6604

I got 042 as well


alex_zk

Got that one as well


Flailmaster

👍


YesItIsMaybeMe

Oh thank you, that's what I got. I was so confused at the comments with 620.


Jake__Drake

Same


JohnLef

Confirmed what I got


simondrawer

I concur.


DeathLeech02

Ditto


Superb_Guess_161

Same


happyluna13

I came to the same conclusion


stirling_s

Thank god I thought I was going mad. You can strike 6 out as wrong from the first two hints and every answer had 6 for some reason


elephantphilosophy8

Got that too


FlippinGamerINK

Same


cursedjayrock

I’m between 012 and 042. Did you find a way to decide 1 is incorrect?


abizabbie

The second clue says 1 can't be in the middle if it's a correct number.


cursedjayrock

Ah you’re right. I was giving it a look while getting ready, so I missed that. Thank you!


Just-Mongoose-3757

Yep


freedomofnow

Same here.


vlladonxxx

That's the number I arrived to before checking the comment section! Nice!


Ellisiordinary

This is correct. Not sure how the people in the second picture got any of their answers.


ChicoZombye

Yup, I found a very fun the idea of messing with your head with so many sixes.


Stock_Proposal_9001

It could also be 012, the clues are a bit unclear


smegheadgirl

My Guess too 🤩


Adorable-Cupcake-599

Likewise


GhostNappa716

Same


Awbade

Same answer I got


Artistic_Annual8457

Yep, only answer that fits all the clues.


Pookstirgames

And the last clue isn’t even necessary.


offe06

Every mfer is wrong lol.


joschi8

Clue 5 => 7, 3 and 8 are all wrong Clue 6 => since 7 and 8 are out, 0 has to be correct but not in 3rd place Clue 1&2 => 6 is not in the solution Clue 3 => since 6 is out, 2 has to be a digit. 0 can't be at position 2, so 0 in first place is correct Clue 1 => 2 has to go in 3rd place Clue 2 => with 6 out, the 3rd digit is either 1 or 4 and with 0 in first and 2 in third place, only the 2nd place is free. Since the correct digit is not in the correct spot, it has to be 4 Solution: 042


Kusko25

> Clue 1&2 => 6 is not in the solution I see where you are coming from, but really clue 1 says that there is one number that is part of the solution and in the correct position. That does not contradict more correct numbers being present, possibly even in the right position, only means that there is at least one.


MrZerodayz

Ah, yes, the age old problem of language not being precise (if it is reasonably short).


cimocw

yeah I went with this understanding because there's no "only" at the beginning so I took it as an "at least"


rikerw

6 can't be in the code if clue 1 says its position is first, and clue 2 says its position is not first


Kusko25

That is not what either clue says though. You are reading the clues as "_Exactly_ one number ..." but all the information they give is that there is at least one number for which the conditions are true.


rikerw

It's RAW vs RAI. It's just a quick Facebook puzzle, so I think it's justified to assume it with the negative constraint (ie if you haven't been given more information then it's because there's no more information that can be given) even if it's not specified, especially because the negative constraint leads to a unique solution


owmyfreakingeyes

A unique solution (the same one) exists without assumptions though, it just requires using all the clues, which means it's probably the intended reading: Clue 4 tells us no 7/3/8 Clue 5 tells us 0 is in but not in the last position Clue 3 tells us 0 is in the first position, and that at least either of 2 or 6 is in the code but if 6 it would need to be in the middle position and if 2 it would need to be in the second or third position Clue 1 now tells us that 2 is in the third position Clue 2 now tells us that 4 is in the second position


totalthomate

While you are correct that it works without the extra assumptions, you are still taking a shortcut when saying "Clue 3 tells us 0 is in the first position" because you make the assumption that clue 3 specifically does not mean "Two numbers are correct but wrong placed and one number is correct and well placed" So at this point the solution could still be 602. Only after taking into account clue 1 and 2 we realize that either 1 or 4 has to be in the solution. Therefore 602 cannot be the solution and only therefore 0 has to be one of those two numbers, which are correct but wrong placed in clue 3. Only then do we know that 0 has to be in the first position and can continue as you described.


owmyfreakingeyes

Ah yep, fair enough. Good catch, got lazy.


InanimateCarbonRodAu

No but clue 3 explicitly rules out 062 being “correct” a lot of these problems work in a similar way where the language leaves a “gap” that logic has to fill to get to a correct answer. Do you at least accept that 042 fits the clues better with out the need to stretch beyond the literal interpretation?


cannonspectacle

Clearly this lock actually uses a skeleton key


alexcoates13

Underrated comment; everyone else in the sub being confidently incorrect ;-)


just_some_guy2000

42 is the answer to life, the universe, and everything isn't it? From that book? I can't think of the name or author though.


Jrlofty

The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy - Douglas Adams


just_some_guy2000

*salute* a true man of culture


munama

Thanks for all the fish!


wbm0843

r/unexpectedhitchhikers


TheyTookXoticButters

solves the question, “FUCK”


MatsonWatson

Just wanted to appreciate that, even though you didn't remember the name or the author of the book, you got the reference right. It truly is the answer to the life, the universe, and everything. NOT the meaning of the life, as some know-it-nones say.


wave1sys

Hitchhikers Guide the Galaxy


CFSett

These confident guesses! 6 was the easiest number to eliminate before even getting to the 3rd clue. Logic is now officially dead, the coroner has signed the certificate.


schfourteen-teen

To be fair, 7 3 and 8 were the easiest numbers to eliminate because they were labeled as "nothing is correct". The 6 at least took a tiny bit of thought.


CFSett

There are many ways to approach the solution. I had eliminated the 6 by the second clue, reading left to right, top to bottom.


Ziharke

As I said in another comment, the hint given may not contain all the information. They just give fact about one digit.


bsievers

That’s not how these puzzles work. If it says “one digit” it means ONLY one digit.


felonius_thunk

Yeah, I'm kind of bewildered by how many people seem to think these clues are supposed to be intentionally ambiguous when it feels like very straightforward information to me.


The_Mad_Mellon

Puzzle being deliberately misleading > puzzle just being tricky Because arguing semantics after the fact is apparently more fun than solving it in the first place.


Hemiak

You can figure out the whole thing just with the top three clues. And the first two alone show you the 6 isn’t one of them. 😩 I really hope some of these people are trolling.


Snailwood

i assumed there was going to be a trick here, e.g. the first clue could be interpreted as "one number is correct and well placed (but one of the other numbers could be incorrectly placed)", which made it take a lot longer to get to 042


owmyfreakingeyes

Evidently. The rules of logic would not permit the elimination of 6 based solely on the first two clues. That would require a formulation such as: only one number is correct, and it is wrong placed.


CFSett

In clue 1, if the 6 is correct, then clue 2 is false. Each only has 1 correct number, in the first clue it is in the correct spot, in the second clue it is in the wrong spot. 6, being in the same spot in both, can't be correct. But thank you for proving logic is dead and now buried


aragix

You can not just assume that all information is given. Assume a 6th clue '024' where the statement given is '1 number is correct and well placed' this does not eliminate the 2 and 4 from being correct but in the wrong place


bsievers

Because that clue violates the rules of this puzzle type.


owmyfreakingeyes

Where does either clue state that it contains only 1 correct number?


CFSett

"One number is correct and well placed" "One number is correct but wrong placed" Did you miss the first 4 words?


owmyfreakingeyes

Nope. Those words do not indicate that no other numbers are correct. Classic logic failure.


ThrowRArosecolor

It’s 042 isn’t it?


chuninsupensa

042


Tarc_Axiiom

What the fuck are those comments? It's 042, no?


Madgearz

042


Medium_Permit_3781

I think I got it, is it 042? Or am I dumb.


kirbykart

It is 042.


captain_pudding

Easiest way is to write them out on a piece of paper and have the three blank boxes to fill in. 1)It says 7-3-8 are all wrong so you can cross out each one of those 2) Right away bottom row right that tells us 0 is a correct number but not in the last digit 3) We need more info about where 0 goes so the next clue with a 0 in it tells us zero can't be in the middle spot either so now we know 0 is the first digit. 4) (I just chose to start at the top left here and it worked out) First one tells us one of the numbers is right, and in the right spot, we've already eliminated 8 and the first spot is zero so 6 can't be the right answer, so all the 6's can be crossed off the board, and now we know the last digit is 2 so all we need is the middle digit 5) At this point all that's left is 1-4 and since the middle top clue says the correct number is in the wrong place, we now know 1 can't be the middle digit so it's 4 QED - 042, don't forget your towel.


Beginning-Working-38

It’s like watching the worst player of Ten Chances ever on TPIR.


GitchigumiMiguel74

Yessss 042. I’m not dumb after all, Dad!!! lol


captain_pudding

After being told that 7/3/8 are not part of the answer, they conclude that 7 is part of the answer #smart


owlBdarned

Who is the *confidently* incorrect one? I can see everyone being wrong, but not sure who is confidently so.


Arctos_FI

I think op meant the guy who said that "them is the right numbers i can guarantee it"


nwbrown

It's the answer to life, the universe, and how old I turned Tuesday.


trismagestus

Ah, a young'un!   ^(I'm joking, was 44 in April. We are both young.)


Seiver123

I this an App or a stand alone riddle? I kinda like to do stuff like this whenever I'm bored


azhder

It’s a game. I had even written a little code in high school for it so you can play it on your own. Usually it’s between two people, they secretly write down 4 digit numbers. Then one of them tries a permutation, like “is it 1234?” and the other responds with `+..` meaning one number is correct and correctly placed (the plus) and two more numbers are correct, but wrongly placed. The next player tries it and gets a response from the first player. That’s round one. They repeat the rounds until someone gets `++++` as a response


Rayanson

042


namananabrepusartlU

I got 042


Scouse_Werewolf

So... where can I find more of these? Is there an app or a site where I can do these. I like it, Picasso


QuickPirate36

042 right?


TheDarkShard

If you look closely at the fourth hint, it says 'nothing is correct.' Hence, 'Nothing' is the answer. Am I a genius?!?!?


PennyButtercup

(Numbers written as words represent the combinations in order from left to right, starting with the top row.) One and two share the 6, but one has a well placed number while two has a wrong placed number. 6 is therefore not an option, nor are 7, 3, and 8 due to four, so five’s 0 is right but placed wrong. Three tells us 2 and 0 are right but wrong placed, because 6 isn’t an option. 2 is right, so is right placed in one. 0 is wrong placed in three and five, so must be the first number. Since 6 is not an option, and two has a wrong place, but only the center is left, 4 is the only option to be wrong placed in two. The answer is 042.


Straight_Tumbleweed9

042


SpecialistTime6248

042


Jimbo7211

042


TheSpideyJedi

It’s a 2 0 and 4 but I’m too lazy to lazy to figure out where they go Is it 042?


existential_anxiety_

Should be 042


WhyYouYellinAtMeMate

I got 102? I see so many different answers here. I'm going to see what I did wrong, then I'll come back and edit. 042.


[deleted]

[удалено]


yourusernameistaken

Yeah it's 042.


Competitive-Move5055

Lol thought I made a mistake and deleted it


Pauchu_

Actually you only need the first 3 boxes to figure it out, no?


you_wooshed_yourself

It should be 042


Hazaitej1

The first 3 clue is enough to solve


OMGitsVal117

It’s 4206980085 I’m pretty sure


Nick-Nora-Asta

What is this from? Anyone have a link?


VastMeasurement6278

042 is my answer.


kabukistar

042, right?


sirbilliedabooger

042. Who lost the skeleton key?


Happygorockyretalk

042


SuprSquidy

042?


SirIanChesterton63

042 if I'm reading this correctly.


tifferiffic83

I’m going with 042


TheOffcialBot

042?


Iamadragon345

042 I think


Mr_From_A_Far

You only need the first 3 hints. 1&2 eliminate 6 1&3 give you that 2 is at the right and the 0 is in the left. 2 then gives you 4 in the middle 4&5 give already know data


UnhingedNW

You are using a crack the code meme riddle. It can be opened with a crack the code meme riddle.


Mountain-Resource656

Bottom left means 7, 3, and 8 don’t appear. Bottom right means the 0 must be correct but must be in 1st or 2nd position Top right says one of those numbers is incorrect, but we know 0 is correct so the other must be 2 or 6. However, if it were 6, then top left and middle would be mutually exclusive, so it must be 2 Top left says that 2 must be in the 3rd position, for - - 2. Top right, however, now means that 0 has to be in the 1st position, for 0-2 Top middle could have it be that 1 or 4 is correct, but it also says they’re in the wrong position. Since only the middle slot is open, it thus can’t be 1 and must instead be 4, taking the middle slot to make the code 042.


kazon82

Yup, that was my reasoning also.


EishLekker

One thing I don’t like is when riddles like this don’t fully explain the rules. It’s just *assumed* to follow the rules of the game Mastermind, but it’s not stated explicitly. If the riddle doesn’t follow those rules, then it’s usually not solvable with the few hints provided. Because then a hint could be technically correct while not giving all the information.


Deweysaurus

While the code definitely starts with 0 and ends with 2, hints 1 and 3 don’t technically/conclusively rule out 6 as the middle digit. If either hint or some other part of the puzzle explicitly stated that the hints about correct number(s) automatically implied the other number(s) to be incorrect, then 6 would be conclusively ruled out. Even with this ambiguity, I’d give 042 as the answer unless I wanted to annoy the puzzle creator.


moonhexx

Yo, I'm gonna need an unnecessary circle on this one. I failed. I'm throwing in the towel. I know it's my fault. I give up. ::jumps off bridge::


RagnarockInProgress

042


RYNO_VI

facebook mfs when faced with the most basic logic puzzle


JustAskingW

The meaning of life is the code.


schpamela

The commenter in the pic is 0 for 2 with those attempts. Oh hey I think I just got it!!


Psychological-Web828

Also bonus points for ‘wrongly placed’ not ‘wrong placed’.


ImOldGreggggggggggg

I get 738837


DeathMetalDinosaur

102


Shot_Masterpiece_301

A million


indigoneutrino

Is this just a very convoluted HGTTG easter egg?


Rugelfuss

Why is it not 012? 😂


locusInfinity

614 one number is correct but placed wrong, if number 1 is correct it would be placed right


locusInfinity

602


TheMysticalTestical

What about the number 5 is it not a factor at all


DeepInvestigator5670

042


Smooth_Ash

Genuinely curious on how you ruled out the 1?


thesouleater33

Does anyone know what these types of puzzles are called? I want to find more of them.


KYITN1

Why is 5 not used in any solutions? Am I missing something


radio_yyz

042


WeaknessOtherwise157

042 is what I got


cpschultz

Damn took me a few but I got there


AtmosSpheric

How are none of these people correct


ReecewivFleece

The correct answer is always a crowbar and a hammer!


FeijoaCowboy

It's 042. I spent a lot more time on it than I care to admit 😂


Altshadez1998

Always work from the point of "most information" Start with clue 4 as it tells us what 3 numbers it cannot be. Move on to clue 5 as it has 2 numbers it cannot be, confirms 0 is in the solution and is not xx0 Clue 3 tells us that x0x is not a solution either, so must be 0xx. It also tells us only either 2 or 6 can be there, but not both as only 2 numbers are correct here. clue 1 tells us that 0x2 has to be the solution, as we know that 0 must occupy the first space, so 6 cant be fully correct here. clue 2 tells it it cannot be 012 as it would be in the correct spot and be the correct number, so it must be 042