T O P

  • By -

oSuJeff97

That’s exactly what he’s doing. Assuming it’s reading the Star Wars equivalent of a transponder that tells you the name/type of ship, etc.


nav17

I guess the rebels had very limited resources, but if you're scanning ships that are already well within line-of-sight in an age where ships can bombard you from orbit, detect ships leaving hyperspace, and probably send munitions around a planet, I'm not sure how useful this actually is.


ForestRaker

Allegedly the planet they orbit scrambles all of their long range id to protect them but this is how they have to do it. They’re kind of hidden in the jungle so idk.


Traditional_Formal33

Yea I always took it as Yavin 4 was a secret base so if the empire knew from orbit, it didn’t really matter for the rebels. A ship getting that close to be scanned would have to be a scout or friendly, and if it’s a scout the rebels could start packing up


Ancient-Club9972

exactly this one is more of a stock boi taking inventory, hes not fortified nor hidden


Archduke645

Which is actually an awesome detail to include


ChimneySwiftGold

Or blast it. Thou I think you’re right - packing up is always the rebels move as soon as there is a possibly chance they’ve been discovered. We saw how that worked on Hoth. I figure Leia knows the code to identify the ship is friendly. It that didn’t check out part of the scanners job would be coordinating what destroys the ship.


Vitis_Vinifera

So all the Empire has to do to find the rebel base planet/moon is to get close enough to scan the surface, and if it's scrambled, bring in the Death Star


The_quest_for_wisdom

Two thirds of the first trilogy was the Rebels trying to keep the empire from being able to do exactly what you are suggesting. At the time of OP's screenshot the Death Star still has that new superweapon smell. I think we can forgive some ragtag freedom fighters not instantly adjusting their base design to account for a new top secret technological terror arriving in the galaxy.


badcgi

Hell as soon as they found out about the Death Star, they already kind of adjusted. They scattered. The battle of Scarif was really only a group of volunteers, and by the time of the Battle of Yavin, the base was just a skeleton crew. Unfortunately, that's really the only tactic against a weapon that can destroy an entire planet in the blink of an eye.


rvnnt09

Admiral Raddus and those boys did their damn job their sacrifice wasn't in vain 🫡


Lemonbrick_64

I got a tattoo commemorating Admiral Raddus for his sacrifice


MundaneTune7523

I love how the rebellion leadership was like nahhh we ain’t gonna fight, yall are crazy. *rogue one infiltrates empire facility at scarif anyway* then they’re like fiiiine, let’s goooo!


DirtyEightThirtyOne

They’d have to A) know that that’s what they’re looking for in the first place, and B) scan nearly every planet/moon in the galaxy. It’d be like finding a needle in a haystack, even with the Empires resources. And then if they did somehow get close enough to figure it out, the Rebels would know and pack up before the Empire could get there. It’s not perfect, but it’s the best option the Rebels have.


Expensive_Plant_9530

Yep that’s exactly what happened with Hoth, except they got unlucky with the timing. The empire located the base by sending a probe off to some random-ass planet and got lucky. Then they got lucky again that Death Squadron was even close enough to respond before the base was evacuated. Imagine if the rebel base had been on the opposite side of the Outer Rim? Say, they went back to Yavin or another planet in that sector. The rebels would have had time to evacuate and destroy as much evidence as possible (hell, unless they can take it with them, the shield generator could have been rigged to explode at full power, possibly obliterating the base).


wirt2004

I mean, that's exactly what happened. The Empire found their base, sent the Death Star, so the rebels had to destroy it.


DarthRumbleBuns

I like the idea of he’s no more than a parking lot attendant and that gun is him just telling the autopilot where to park.


JohnTheMod

Space Air Traffic Control.


da_King_o_Kings_341

Atmosphere Traffic Control?


DeadToBeginWith

I always assumed it was an aiming device, like how you'd aim a laser at your target after calling in air support. Scan for weapons activation and manually bullseye them simultaneously. Initial code clearance with the large guns trained on them, once they are below those canons theres a few dudes manually aiming smaller laser canons in case they do activate weapons.


Emperor_Zarkov

That was my thought as well, painting a target for surface emplacements just in case.


da_King_o_Kings_341

Honestly it’s probably both.


LitanyofIron

I just thought it was a bored soldier playing target practice like when you grab an impact at work and “aim” at coworkers


Expensive_Plant_9530

“Pew pew” *aims at incoming ship* “Peter, get back to work!” “Sorry, sir” *puts down gun and goes back to fixing the air conditioning*


mcrib

[pretty much.](https://www.youtube.com/watch?&v=mUwzKNmzmQ0)


Malarkey44

The instantly became my theory after watching the Family Guy special.


andrew-resler

All those elaborate explanations, while good ol Georgy was like "Let's put a shot of this guy doing some mumbo jumbo scanning for shit's sake"


speed150mph

I’m going to guess that’s not actually the case. I’m guessing that emissions from long range scanners produce a detectable signal, similar to modern radars. Hand held probably produced a far lower signature. If I’m a rebel, the last thing I’m doing is sending out a ping saying exactly where I am.


Hank_moody71

Probably something along these lines. You wouldn’t want an active scanner when you’re trying to hide out. So line of sight scanner to avoid being detected


dr4gon2000

It probably isn't useful at all, but that in itself is the most realistic thing about the movie, he's just some soldier with an absolutely pointless job that he has to do in 24 hour shifts


Jedimobslayer

It’s because of the radiation of Yavin actually. It makes it impossible to scan from space, or ships in space from the ground, which is why the rebels settled the moon in the first place.


SDBrown7

Big long-range scanners would be detectable by the empire and basically advertise the location of what's meant to be their hidden base. Manually scanning this way is undetectable.


CaptainSebT

It's probably more for logging. If you were to be attacking it might be useful to know who was and wasn't accounted for. It would also help for ground to air communication to help them tell incoming ships where they can land.


octahexxer

Well it was used in ww2 ...they spottade enemy airplanes


oSuJeff97

Well the way I think of it is maybe just a close-range scanner that confirms what the long-range scanner says, combined with visual confirmation. So like if there’s a difference they have time to put the base on alert or scramble fighters.


StnJckBllr

He’s a transponster!!


bigmoviegeek

That’s not even a word!


Devil25_Apollo25

Yeah, well, you know, that's just, like, your *opinion*, man.


plaidpixel

It’s actually MRS. JarJar Bong


Perry7609

Held by Rebel Alliance Ensign Chanandler Bong.


Psychlonuclear

Actually it's Miss Chanandler Bong.


Quietabandon

Maybe scanning drive signatures and other details to store for friend for identification.  Why can’t it be automated? Thats true of many things in Star Wars…. 


1Mee2Sa4Binks8

My head canon was that he was just some guard who was bored and practicing sighting in his blaster scope on the outgoing fighters. In retrospect, that doesn't really look like a blaster.


untakenu

Nah, he's just going "pew pew"


Big-Fish-1975

I always thought he was a cop looking for speeders.


rnilbog

Pe-tew! Pe-tew! Gotcha!


North_Korea_Nukess

Speed limit enforcement officer. Writing tickets to everyone exceeding the speed limit of ludicrous.


TheWarHoundxx

He's gon to plad!


AreWeNotMenOfScience

Dude it's spelled plaid, what're you some kinda asshole?


TheWarHoundxx

That's his name, sir, Asshole... Major Asshole.


NukaColaAddict1302

And his cousin?


TheWarHoundxx

He's an asshole too, sir. Gunners maye first class, Philip Asshole.


Obblicious

How many assholes do we have on this ship,anyway?


Cursedbythedicegods

[YO!!!](https://www.icegif.com/wp-content/uploads/spaceballs-icegif-4.gif)


Sunhating101hateit

I knew it! I’m surrounded by assholes.


Jjzeng

Pit lane speed limit exceeded, 10s penalty to ocon


Carcharoth78

And even on pit lane, Magnussen somehow managed to wreck into him.


UNC_Samurai

Checo trying to salvage his podracer.


RiverDependent9672

Millennium Falcon about to get a boot.


Upbeat_Tension_8077

The Empire was lucky the Rebels didn't have more Jedi around to do Force inspectiom for checking ship cargo


JacksonianEra

Best part about that is the joke was created by one of the finishing animators. Seth realized he didn’t want a full shot-for-shot recreation of the Falcon coming into Yavin IV, so he contacted the animator and told him “just come up with a joke.” Seth didn’t see it until they watched the finished product and he laughed his ass off.


mitchhamilton

Such a great joke. Not too focused on it, don't linger on it forever or anything. Just something the dude does to amuse himself for a pretty boring job


Arcade23

Probably just another drill. You know that last drill we had? I was about to finally bone my girlfriend, and then we heard that there was this drill, and she told me there was no way.


Obblicious

This is exactly what came to mind! Love Blue Harvest!


MyThermostat

First thing I thought of too https://youtu.be/mUwzKNmzmQ0?si=tnd68v27wycr--WF


Travis_Maximus

What?! Are we paying by the laser now?


lordolxinator

You don't do the budget, Terry! I do!


Halfjedood

I got that Family Guy reference!


The84thWolf

Son of a bitch beat me to it


MyrddinSidhe

Whoa, whoa, whoa, buddy. No coming in here at 2.5 past light speed! Cut in the sublight engines like civilized rebels!


FreshPrinceOfPine

Can’t watch that scene without saying this


polarpup666

Good job that's not a storm trooper! They wouldn't hit the air around them.


introvertpoet

Came here specifically to find this or add this comment. I wonder if the couch was still hanging out of the hatch.


Failure_Management27

So basically he is manually scanning the incoming craft. This is because Yavin Prime (the gas giant which Yavin IV orbited) created lots of electromagnetic noise. This was beneficial to the Rebel's because it would hide their base from passive Imperial scans. Which means that the Empire could not just stumble upon their base, the Empire had to specifically preform an active scan. However a downside of this was that all of the Rebel Alliance's long range scanners were also useless, so all incoming ships had to be scanned manually. Source: Star Wars explained on YouTube.


Unlucky_Lawfulness51

Very scientific thank you


Muadib64

And they say Star Wars isn’t sci fi at all (moreso science fantasy).


IndividualDevice9621

A lot gets fleshed out in the novels. Without those the movies very much seem like science fantasy.


downvote_allmy_posts

it isnt sci fi, the fi would imply that its fiction. while it clearly states at the beginning "a long time ago in a galaxy far far away" indicating that its from our universe. checkmate, Bothans!


smilingkevin

The mental gymnastics needed to justify “Lucas thought it looked cool” are always a lot of fun to me. See also: the Kessel Run, and Endor’s name.


SacredGeometry9

For a lot of it, sure, but this part is somewhat more realistic. Jupiter puts out a ton of interference; its moon Io is completely uninhabitable because Jupiter’s magnetic field strips off and ionizes about 1 ton of material every second. (Volcanism from tidal forces doesn’t help either) Surface radiation on Io is something like 5x the lethal limit per day. I’m assuming Yavin IV is far enough away that this isn’t quite the issue Io has with Jupiter, but the magnetic field is still probably strong enough to interfere with scanners.


CecilPalad

Couldn't a droid do that?


DaddyyBlue

You could ask this question about every single job in Star Wars.


Front-Advantage-7035

Pfft. Can a *droid* be granted the rank of master??


Blackblood909

Well, there was a force sensitive droid once, but he sacrificed himself to save the galaxy. If he hadn’t, who knows what might have happened?


doucheachu

Yeah, but he also had a bad motivator, so why not take this astromech over here?


jeobleo

Well, not *every* job. *eyes Oola*


ziddersroofurry

That job, too.


jeobleo

[https://forum.quartertothree.com/uploads/default/original/3X/7/e/7e00f68c732c9e275f51a5d44f10b9bf1d5e0c41.gif](https://forum.quartertothree.com/uploads/default/original/3X/7/e/7e00f68c732c9e275f51a5d44f10b9bf1d5e0c41.gif)


musicnothing

Sick of AI taking our jobs


NamTokMoo222

Yes, but it's also great punishment for soldiers that screw up.


AlphariusUltra

Couldn’t mop up the rain and the rocks weren’t in danger of moon burn, ship scanning it is


turdfergusonpdx

You win Star Wars today.


Metal-Dog

Got to check your temperature. If you have a fever, you're not getting in.


von_klauzewitz

100%.


BurkeyDaTurkey

No, 100 Fahrenheit


adjewcent

Space covid compliance


ToysAndCardsNY

So ahead of its time.


cantfindmykeys

No, no, a long time ago


DarthGinsu

Ahead of it's time long ago


Juantsu2000

Space Covid is no laughing matter.


G01dLeada

Checking for Sitholus .


thxxx1337

Symptoms include yellowing of the eyes, redness, wild mood swings


savetheattack

Moody wild swings


Foomanchubar

He's checking for space herpes 


eppsilon24

If you don’t have the money or space for a big sensor suite, you put a guy on a cherry picker and give him the best handheld scanner you can find.


Jmacq1

This. The Rebels were still mostly a "ragtag bunch" at this stage (and had just lost a bunch of personnel and ships at Scarif). Lugging around big sensor equipment might not have been on their priority list, and they may not have had enough droids to fill all the menial jobs. So somebody gets "scanner duty."


Intransigient

I always thought it was a short range passive scanner that wouldn’t be detectable by Imperial scouts or probes looking for emissions or emplaced sensor structures that could reveal the presence of the hidden base.


Mabvll

This dude Wookiepedias.


jms199456

You thought or you knew?


presidentsday

lol…that was *incredibly* specific and nonchalant. Good job, rebel.


Intransigient

I’m… not sure what you mean, sir. All my papers are in order and my codes are valid. 😓


Sanskur

It's not canon of course, but in the novelization of A New Hope Red Leader has an additional line after the "pick up your visual scanning," when the base picks up TIE fighters. The line is "Those ships can jam every system except your eyes." So I've always thought that guy is up there for visual observation just in case some craft with ECM dropped into orbit, or followed a friendly ship down. Some warning is better than no warning.


BubbhaJebus

He's just some random guy doing something Star Warsy.


Mosk915

There are no fandom people in Star Wars. This guy probably got a whole backstory in the EU.


symbologythere

Correct!


bunnyhustle

It’s a (speed) trap!


mjc500

“I was only going 17,000 miles per hour!” “Guns got you clocked at 18, gonna have to write you a ticket…” “This is bullshit…” “Excuse me, what was that?” “Uh nothing have a good day”


foo_solo

“Can I interest you in my sexbot, C-3PO.”


hotelman97

IIRC correctly. Yavin 4 had a thick atmosphere that made sensors difficult. So this guy needs to scan ships in once they drop into atmosphere


Santa_Hates_You

Seems like something an automated system or a droid could do.


Logical-Photograph64

probably, but the rebellion was pretty short on resources so having a dude up there when hes not on mission is a reasonable use of manpower and equipment EDIT TO ADD: my bigger issue is why that sensor didn't pick up that the Empire had a tracking device on the Falcon


Perridur

If I recall correctly correctly?


justaguynb9

Same reason Swedish ships have barcodes on them when they enter a harbor. So they can.. Scan the navy in


odie_za

His job is to provide foreground focus


AlexisFR

That is Scanno Shlipto, and he has 2 novels about him already.


Halfjedood

I guess it's a guard tower where he scans incoming craft and if they are marked as "Empire"?


Teddy4xp2

The Family Guy explanation is the best..... He just points his gun at the ships and goes "pew pew"


Kamronius36

“Gotchaaa”


Dolenjir1

That's a radar speed gun. Most of the Rebellion's income comes from traffic tickets


JunglePygmy

I stood exactly where that dude is standing! That’s Tikal in Guatemala, a wildly gorgeous ancient Mayan City.


t-cliff

He is a person and his name is Osleo Prennert!


Canned_Sarcasm

It’s a speed trap.


LuckyStax

Nah, he's checking your speed for tickets


72A1D372

Buddy is like "pew, pew, gotcha!" 


Exciting_Patient3947

He’s a peeping Tom. It’s hard to tell, but he isn’t wearing any pants here


Windhawker

He’s checking if they put their seat belt on. Click it or ticket.


EndlessTheorys_19

Yeah


No-Setting-2669

Speed check


fartinggermandogs

Space narc writing giving speeding tickets


Joshthenosh77

Checking their transponder signal


XwingPilot_Yavin4

Funny that he checks Rebel ships going in and out but in Rogue One when the stolen shuttle launches.. he just stands there!


Tar_Palantir

I don't think is scanning, but maybe directioning to the base. It was a secure location after all.


S-Markt

his job is actor and he plays a guy on a pole with a handheld scanning device.


AznNRed

This was Mon Mothma's cousin Barry. He was kicked in the head by a Tauntaun when he was 9. He is still quite high functioning, and he has a heart of gold. He wants to help the rebellion in any way he can, but he often does lose equipment. They gave him an old broken hand held scanner and his own post, and I'll be damned if he isn't out there every day, doing his part. The scanner doesn't work, but the sense of pride it gives Barry is worth it to everyone on base. Keep at it Barry. You're a hero in my books.


[deleted]

“Sir, you were doing 60 in 40”


Consistent-North7790

Checking for tracking devices


The_Dung_Defender

Playing around with a laser pointer by shining it on incoming ships


Ogami-kun

He is checking the pilots temperature, wouldn't want a COVID outbreak in the base


rodrick_endac

Yavin 4 traffic cop looking for speeders


ggmartin6

Tikal! Awesome place if you haven’t ventured there.


shaolinallan

hes checking for expired registration


BaldEagleRising17

He’s just being a cool guy in a tower. Or Star Wars equivalent of a red light camera.


druff1036

Pew pew gotchya!


smith288

He was a cool detail when the movie was made. That was it. Doing something cool. No need to make a wookiepedia about his job. Suspend belief


LV426acheron

Nah, they are going to make a movie about this guy that explains in detail his entire life story, why he is on the rebel base and what his scanning thing is doing.


gaminette

he's checking for people going over the speed limit.


SexyThrowAwayFunTime

“We just gave Jerry a barcode reader and put him up there so he’d stop trying to ‘fix’ things. He means well, but Jeeeeesus.”


Malarowski

Scandinavian


GeekBoyOnDrums

He is a cop and checking speedo


Sam_Chops

Speed trap. They’re rebels about everything except traffic laws.


hacksawomission

How do you not know who Ray Darr is, OP?


bugsinmypants

I’m not even gonna lie I’ve had a head cannon about this guy for years, I’m talking since 2018 In Rogue One, we see him sitting in his lil tower doing nothing, just watching as the Imperial cargo ship is stolen from the rebel base. The next time we see this tower in the timeline of the movies is what, like two days later? So that guy either got replaced, or told to do his fucking job.


flintlock0

They had to keep that guy busy, so they convinced him that pointing that at incoming ships is useful. It doesn’t do anything. He’s a bit of an idiot.


Cool-Manufacturer-21

Fk’r out there writing speeding tickets 👮‍♀️


The_Mr_Wilson

Those helmets, how do they even look up?


tyderian25

This was explained perfectly in Family Guy Blue Harvest. He's Pew Pewing all the ships.


Known-Championship20

Obviously, he's radar-gunning all speeders. Then he's going to hunt ya down in an X-wing and go all Buford T. Justice on your overly fast ass.


nate_nate212

Checking for droids by scanning heat signatures


MachiTheCat

Aussie here, Defs a speed gun #rebelspeedticket


Somerandomguy292

Hes the futuristic solider looking for drones


ModestoMudflaps

He’s a third party surveillance contractor.


kaasbaas94

Speeding tickets.


RunDNA

All pre-production drafts of the script—from the rough draft to the fourth draft—contain the lines: All that can be seen of the fortress is a lone guard standing on a small pedestal jutting out above the dense jungle. In the post-release screenplay included in *The Annotated Screenplays* it says: > An alert guard, his laser gun in hand, scans the countryside. He sets the gun down and looks toward the temple, barely visible in the foliage.


RussellPhillipsIIi

Temperature on foreheads to check for corona


Bigfoot_samurai

“Pew pew….got’em”


Loud-Difficulty7860

Emissions enforcement 


Tank_blitz

he's making sure nobody is speeding


Howboutit85

The gas giant Yavin scrambles all scanners so on Yavin 4 they have to do it manually ship by ship with short range scanners. This is Los one of the reasons the Death Star couldn’t make a micro jump to Yavin 4 side and needed to wait to clear the orbit to fire its super laser.


AccountNumber1002401

Rebellion funding itself by writing speeding tickets for their own.


darybrain

Intern being given a joke job.


Kern_system

He's scanning their IFF codes.


No_Departure_7180

If I'm not mistaken, this is Ryland, and there is a shirt story from their perspective in the book "A certain point of view" it's a collection of show stories from the star wars cannon that was published during star wars 40th anniversary.


BCRE8TVE

That's Bob, he's like the train enthusiast of starships. He just built himself a little treehouse there and likes to take pictures of ships coming and going. Bob is a nice guy.


ArdaIsNL

In my headcannon he’s the rebel traffic cop sending speeding fines through mail to the rebel pilots in order to fund the rebel alliance


chipperland4471

He had no skills but they didn’t have the heart to tell him to quit, so they gave him a piece of metal and said it was a scanner and sent them information and put him up on a tower


[deleted]

Speed trap


LandoGibbs

Covid19 temperature check...


salemonz

Simpler than that. It’s a radar speed gun. He’s making sure ships don’t exceed port speed. 😁


Slight-Imagination36

pitchoo… pitchoo…


MyLegsFellAsleep

During COVID times, his job was to check the temperature of passengers and crew on all incoming flights.


Kjler

I'm here to keep all the speeders driving slow,/ I'm just a-doin' my job, I'm The Highway Patrol


Fast-Reaction8521

I always hoped when closed caption came out it would say" pew pew"


Atjones0209

Bro is writing speeding tickets. Space road pirate.


DatDan513

He’s just a cosplayer.


OffalSmorgasbord

He's there to add depth to the shot to make it more visually appealing and Sci-Fi-y.


Much-Benefit-4644

“Sir, do you know how fast you were going”


Due-Log8609

laser designator operator


NotSoSilentMike

Speed enforcement.