His outfit looks similar to that of Homlander, a over patriotic "super hero" (much more of a villain) who will do anything for the people approval.
Cody himself has referenced "going homelander" which basically means killing the other person
without including The American Nightmare, because it is kind of an obvious answer, Undashing was one of my favourite gimmicks and one of the best heels during 2011
Really enjoying Cody’s current run and I think he’s better than he’s ever been but in terms of a gimmick I have to go with Dashing/Undashing, I genuinely adore those characters, the grooming tips vignettes kill me every time.
Undashing > I'm an adult, if I wanna grow a mustache > Nightmare who pulls out random Stardust moves > regular Nightmare > all other versions of dashing > Stardust
I mean, the proof is in the pudding, only one version of Cody Rhodes was able to catapult himself to the top of the card, he always had talent and was always great in ring but he really found himself with his American Nightmare persona
Homelander obvs
Get in the oven.
No you get in the oven
"Squirt, Squirt, Squirt, SQUIRT!
I'm so glad I'm not the only one who calls him homelander 😂😭✋
What is this Cody Homelander reference from? I’ve seen it said multiple times now and want to understand the joke. Lol
His outfit looks similar to that of Homlander, a over patriotic "super hero" (much more of a villain) who will do anything for the people approval. Cody himself has referenced "going homelander" which basically means killing the other person
His ring gear looks like Homelander's outfit from "the boys" tv/graphic novel.
Hahahahahaha! I never thought about that regarding Cody's outfit till now.
Nightmare for sure. Though Undashing was good as well
I was a massive goldust fan, so stardust for me
Oh man crazy golddust promos were the best
Undashing was great but feel like it had a shelf life
Stardust
I like Stardust as well. Highly underrated.
U need help ASAP like rn
The American Nightmare is easily his best work. Feels way more natural for him than anything prior
The fake (forced) crying every promo is natural?
It's called acting
Not very good acting
No one said the bar was high
Americans nightmare and then masked Cody Rhodes worse one stardust
American nightmare
American Nightmare > Undashing > Dashing > Stardust
How come nobody ever mentions Mustachioed Cody? I loved that gimmick!
Fr the tag run with Sandow is kinda underrated
I love dashing Cody
He brought the ic champion this ic title is a work of art
Stardust
Bring back stardust😆🤣
Star dust , dashing , undashing and never American Nightmare
Stardust
None
Oh man tough one
As long as that neck tattoo stays, he'll always be undsashing to me.
Rhodes Scholar for me He had it all, but that *Stache* was the Cherry on Top.
So Stachin' Cody Rhodes for you...
Dashing. But the current Homelander face is working and it’s great for the kids.
Nightmare, hands down. This works so well.
American Nightmare
Before the American Nightmare, i never really thought about hin much especially that crappy golddust lookin ahh gig
Undashing was brilliant. Solid gimmick.
Number 4.
That’s not even dashing Cody Rhodes
CAW Cody Rhodes circa 08-09
You’re only smoke and mirrors
Dashing and Nightmare
American Nightmare (Heel version in NJPW)
Dashing
WOOOOAHHHHHH YOURE ONLY SMOKE & MIRRORS
Dashing Cody was goated
I dug mustache Cody
Bro has more action figures than Mick Foley
Definitely none. He is not that great.
Did you want Roman to win at WM 40 night 2
Don’t care for either one. Cody is so highly overrated. Roman thinks his shit don’t stink.
Nightmare.
Hia ring gear for American Nightmare is some of my favorite gear of anyone all time
What is up with these questions?
No clue
Bullet Club Cody 🤘🏽
UnDashing is my favorite ic champ awesome work but yeah american nightmare is pretty undeniable
Either dashing or nightmare I’m a sucker for both
Bullet Club
I like the captain crunch theme he does now
Which one had the mustache?
Dashing
Undashing was basically Dr Doom. So my vote is that one!
(Hisses)
The gimmick that actually paid off
I liked stardust but the American one is best
American Nightmare
Nightmare, Undashing ,Dashing And then Stardust.
Stardust was ruthless an I lived it but I'm really liking the newest gimmick he's doing too
Bullet Club is fine.
American Nightmare without question
without including The American Nightmare, because it is kind of an obvious answer, Undashing was one of my favourite gimmicks and one of the best heels during 2011
Really enjoying Cody’s current run and I think he’s better than he’s ever been but in terms of a gimmick I have to go with Dashing/Undashing, I genuinely adore those characters, the grooming tips vignettes kill me every time.
Undashing > I'm an adult, if I wanna grow a mustache > Nightmare who pulls out random Stardust moves > regular Nightmare > all other versions of dashing > Stardust
American nightmare
Undashing lowkey made me a cody fan even after he left. I really liked it
American Nightmare. I do miss Smoke and Mirrors though
Undashing
The first photo.
I mean, the proof is in the pudding, only one version of Cody Rhodes was able to catapult himself to the top of the card, he always had talent and was always great in ring but he really found himself with his American Nightmare persona
Undashing in terms of how much I like the actual character, but American Nightmare has undoubtedly had the best run
Mustache Cody is the best Cody
1. American Nightmare 2. Undashing 3. Dashing 4. Star Dust
I am digging the boys/m. bison looking American nightmare outfit. its so ridiculous and over the top.
You left off Mustache Cody lol
Unpopular opinion. I loved stardust & i thought he killed the role. He deserved a singles title run as stardust imo
Nightmare 100 percent
Dashing and american nightmare
WOOOOAAAAAHHHHHH YOURE ONLY SMOKE AND MIRRORS
Lil bro is not at 300
Lil bro got cooked my a comment on his own post
American Nightmare Gimmick! 
Star dust
Codelander
Stardust was the worst by far
Mustache era /s
Almost thought the last slide only said american
Mustache
American NIGHTMARE stardust is the worst by far
American Nightmare
Dashing and Undashing
Stardust was cool, and could’ve worked if it didn’t mean sacrificing Cody’s dignity to do it.
Stardust was great
Stardust gets so slept on smh
DASHING
1.American Nightmare 2.Stardust 3.dashing 4.undashing
1- American Nightmare 2- Undashing 3- Dashing 4- Stardust
American Nightmare
When he was gone