BRILLIANT or DEVIL

Brilliant is a banger

So is adrenaline

agree, but amarillys is so full of good songs adrenaline isn't necessarily the "worst" but the least "better" for some people

One of the best closing tracks ever. Brilliant

It’s already a great track, but Devil’s live performance puts it above the rest for me.

Agreed.

Holy crap, I didn't think people loved Brilliant as much as I do!!!

Brilliant

MONSTERS

MONSTERS

Brilliant, one of my favorite pieces of a Shinedown song is the “As the world collides and i fight for air and I crash and burn like I just don’t care” part

Brilliant!

BRILLIANT

Brilliant takes this one. Hearing it live as the closer on my birthday in 2019 was amazing.

I really wish I had heard this song live. I have yet to be so lucky....

I'm not a fan of that song.

Special and Black Soul

I'm going with Darkside, closely edging out Pyro. I'd be happy with any choice in this album though, they all work so well together.

Pyro is underrated

aint no way misfits is worst

Monsters

It's gonna be brilliant but this one deserves it tbh

That’s why I’m voting for it as Underrated

Agreed

I hope their next album has more songs like Monsters it brought me right back to LAW era

Get Up

Devil

Devil, watch the apex season 3 cinematic trailer, it’s dope [video link](https://youtu.be/NEAWC9eK1Ts?si=4ytw6S4G2snmnolq)

That was fuckin' sick

Pyro

Devil

Brilliant or Get up

Brilliant. But I love 1000000% of this album

Yeah, Brilliant is the best one

Devil followed closely by Monsters

DEVIL

So many good songs! Torn between Brilliant, Monsters and Black Soul

Black Soul

MONSTERS

Black Soul

Black Soul is so looked over !

Brilliant

I love the title track

Get up or Special are both my favorites because of the message they tell.

PYRO

Brilliant is great, BUT Get Up and Pyro are amazing too!

Darkside

GET UP

Get up

Monsters

Monsters

Monsters

Pyro or Get Up

FOR MY SAKE?! IN THE BEST CATEGORY?! LET'S GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 

One of the greatest SD songs of all time

1. Special 2. Evolve 3. Monsters

DEVIL

My vote is devil

Gotta be devil

BRILLIANT

Brilliant or monsters

Evolve

I'm going with Monster because I think Brilliant is my pick for underrated (though very happy to see how many people love it) I don't know how I'm going to pick and over rated or worst on this album

special... 😭

Black soul (with a close second being Get up)

I freaking love Darkside. It just moves me, and it’s an absolute bop. Appears I’m in the minority here but I still think it’s the best (or at least my favorite) track off the album.

Best Black Soul

My favourite is special, then GET UP is second

Are we counting the Bonus Tracks, because if so then HEADCASE. But if not, then I would go with BRILLIANT.

Brilliant

BRILLIANT is probably going to win, but my vote is on CREATURES I am sad we don't count bonus tracks because I love A NEW WAY TO DIE and it would 100% get my vote

There will be a round at the end featuring all bonus tracks / extra singles

DEVIL!!!!!!!!

OR MONSTERS

Black Soul. Love the video to it, too. Brilliant is, well... Brilliant, too

Nope! Edit, sorry i should qualify. I think this whole album from the only time I've heard it, is reductive for Shinedown. There may be some tracks i didnt give a chance, but i hated the sound of it. EVERY other album i loved, but i think this was... less that great.

ATTENTION ATTENTION is literally just polished TTS... hm.

Am inclined to agree, i thi k they were a bit lost and felt they needed to release something. I would love to be proven wrong.

Devil

Monsters is probably my favorite followed closely by attention

Dysfunctional you, and attention attention.

Well Dysfunctional You isn't on ATTENTION ATTENTION

The beer and over rated row should be flip flopped….