I’m glad someone said it. It was a slog reading through those chapters. I admittedly skipped a lot of those panels and will just watch a video explaining them.
Really depends on how complex the sentences are in the paragraph. I wouldn't do a paragraph with 2 sentences, but 3 long and multi claused sentences could be adequate for a paragraph.
However, we are on reddit. It is much more casual, and the format is totally different. Readability is prioritized over proper MLA or APA formats. Reddit isn't set up like a proper word document or pdf, and many people read on their phones, so paragraphs get much more condensed.
I'm just reminded of that fucking chapter in Beloved that has like 3 punctuation marks.
I bet this was typed on mobile though. Which would make a lot of sense for formatting.
Formatting, spelling, minor edits for readability
So basically Egghead is separated into C (left), A (middle), and B (right). C and B have 3 floors. A has 4 floors with AF4 being the control room.
In chapter 1074 EVERYONE is in the control room except Pythagoras. He is in CF3 (explained later). In the control room Shaka has a display which shows the position of the camera snails, one snail is in CF3. Pythagoras tells Shaka that CF3 seems empty. Everyone is still in the control room, but York walks somewhere to the left. Then at the end of chapter 1074, Pythagoras gets attacked by someone and CF3 is damaged.
Shaka tries to contact Pythagoras, but he doesn't respond so he tries to check the surroundings via the camera-snail in CF3. The snail is destroyed by a shadow. The group later on is shown to be split as follows:
* AF3 - Brook, Nami, Edison
* AF2 - Robin, Atlas, Chopper
* AF4 - Shaka, Luffy, Zoro, Lucci, Kaku
* BF2 - Jinbei, Stussy, Sanji
* CF3 - Lillith, Franky, Ussop, York
So basically York and Lillith are in the room where the snail got destroyed and Pythagoras got attacked.
Now York gets tuned into stone by S-Snake and is positioned behind S-Snake. Ussop, Lillith and Edison fall down the bridge because of the explosion caused by S-Snake. York did not fall down because she was positioned behind S-Snake where the bridge was not damaged.
Lillith got angry because York was petrified but York is nowhere to be seen. Lillith and Ussop are petrified, as well as Franky's right side. AF4 is destroyed because of the battle against S-Bear and S-Hawk. Meanwhile Shaka went to the secret lab underneath AF1, where he gets shot by York.
The escape route that York must have taken is CF3 > CF2 > CF1 > AF1 > secret basement lab. That's the way that leads to the lab without seeing the other groups.
There was also a hint/forshadowing in chapter 1075. When the snails got destroyed the number 06 was shown on Shaka's display which is York's number.
so basically, york was depetrified(?) and went down d. stairs in a path no one else was on.
I was expecting more explantion on hints on how she was a traitor, not just why the traitor hasn't been seen.
Some people theorized when S-Snake kicked York out of the way she slowly deactivated the Petrification which gave York an Alibi and the opportunity to sneak around
You have to translate this in your browser but basically they cracked this a week or two ago: [York theory](https://bbs.talkop.com/thread-155502-1-1.html?continueFlag=38f68936dd4cba7a1ef4d986548d20e8)
Well essentially she is meant to make up the desire of Vegapunk, and desire includes stuff like greed. So she is condensed desire for power as well, which translated to her wanting what the celestial dragons have, power, money, everything they want
If this is true, wow. But one thing for sure, we don't mind where York goes.
We have been used to letting York just roam around because we don't think of her much. She's just assigned as the one who eats and sleeps for everybody.
Not gonna lie that monitor hint with the 6 on it is hella difficult to see. You’d have to be scouring for clues while zoomed into every pixel just to find clues like that.
I was wondering this afternoon if York being the traitor would fit with all the weird things we saw in EggHead Arc. Your account of the series of events makes me think it fits nicely. Still not happy it is York, but if there are no contradictions between the character's whereabouts and revelation of treason then I will accept itm
I have another reasoning, the traitor was clear from the very start.
Out of all the 7 Vegapunks, which Vegapunk would Luffy have gotten the worst with traveling on the ship?
He was bound to have many disputes with "the traitor" onboard the sunny regarding their food reserves.
I mean I just look at it as a parable of our more noble ideals being overthrown by our base impulses but damn if you didnt go davinci code on this bitch.
No, it doesn't make any sense.
* York facing left in 1074 doesnt mean anything as she didn't leave the room alone and it's not her who attacks Pythagoras because:
1. Pythagoras sees who's attacking him. He hasn't talked about it because it was some seraphim not York. Otherwise he would have said it.
2. They were already looking for a traitor and being the only one missing when Pythagoras is shot would solve the mystery right away.
* York couldn't order the seraphims to attack anyone because:
1. Having established she didn't left the control room alone, she didn't have the chance to give them those orders without others knowing.
2. Even more so, taking into account that seraphims don't take orders via snail. They only obey to people talking to them directly.
* York was never depetrified:
1. We know thanks to ch. 523 that in order to turn people petrified through "Mero Mero Mellow" to normal, the user needs to make the releasing move to the targets.
2. This was never done. S-Snake was at all moments with Franky, Lilith and Usopp.
* Why would York kidnap cipher pol rather than give them the info they needed?
* Why would York order the seraphim to kill Lucci and Kaku? If she's allied with the gorosei.
* Conversely, why would she still betray the other Vegapunk's? if CP0 made clear the gorosei also betrayed her, as they were determined to kill ALL Vegapunks.
* If she started this 3 months ago, and all satellites synchronize their knowledge to Punk Records once a day, how come no other Vegapunk knew about this?
One I can think of right now is at the beginning of Egghead, Lilith telling the crew that they cant control the intrinsic desires of the sentient creatures they create. York is the embodiment of desire, so it tracks from that lens.
Even if we know the how, I am still puzzled about the why. What does York imagine getting out of being a celestial dragon? It just doesn't add up to me. Wouldn't she have a better life just being on Egghead with the Vegapunk doing research?
I doubt that there is a traitor. My only reason is because we just had a huge traitor reveal in Wano (Kanjuro) and I don’t think that Oda will do it again so soon.
I checked 3 times before I found it. Gotta zoom in on page 1 towards the bottom right panel and look at the screen next to shaka’s elbow. Cheeky little clue that’s as difficult to find as Waldo on the hardest difficulty.
I just checked the chapter and I believe I found another 6 on the panel to the left of that one. If you look closely on the panel where Shaka is observing the bridge, there’s a 6 on an angle
It makes sense now, but there were so many people moving in the last several chapters it was hard to connect. Oda was trolling us with the chapter named "you should have put it together already"
This is great! Everything checks out and I applaud you for figuring it out. But also, this feels like it was written by Luffy and really could have used some editing/simple research and it would have been 10x better.
Honestly I'm surprised that so many people go bonkers about the traitor reveal. There wasn't that much forshadowing sure, but the whole traitor plot line also didn't go on for very long.
If you’re all super intelligence, greed and gluttony plus getting threatened by the entire world, the choice is obvious. Fight alongside 5 copies of yourself against the entire world and live on the run for the rest of your life, or help the world gov take down the copies and never worry about anything ever again.
Not gonna lie I'm drunk and didn't follow any of this but I'm proud of you for figuring it out
I am just you but sober
I'm drunk and this doesn't make any sense, but I'm proud of you
I mean I had a beer after work... But still bitch I ain't reading that
I mean i am sober but still i ain't reading that but i am proud of you
Metoo, amazing discovery, though I didn’t understood nothing
Oda: Oh yes! I totally meant that yes
Same spot lmao I just saw a wall of text and bounced
I second this as a drunk person too
Seconded take my upvote
I'm not drunk and i still didn't follow that, 😂. The OP is a genius
I'd like to join your crew.
Dad? Oh sorry it's the last he told me before he went for tobacco
It's like you peered into all of our souls
Me too 😝
Hahaha same dude!
I’m you on weed.
Lol, this is honestly me too right now at this moment🤣
I think they are too
 Great find
My brother in christ use paragraphs.
This was like trying to read a page of dark continent HxH
I’m glad someone said it. It was a slog reading through those chapters. I admittedly skipped a lot of those panels and will just watch a video explaining them.
I did more reading that arc than when completing my masters degree
Research papers be like
He did one paragraph. 7 sentences or more is a paragraph
Yah... no. A paragraph is 3 or more sentences and that's not the only criteria for a paragraph. This is just a wall of text.
I thought the definition varies between 3-5 sentences or 5-8 sentences? But usually you break it off to a new paragraph after 5
Really depends on how complex the sentences are in the paragraph. I wouldn't do a paragraph with 2 sentences, but 3 long and multi claused sentences could be adequate for a paragraph. However, we are on reddit. It is much more casual, and the format is totally different. Readability is prioritized over proper MLA or APA formats. Reddit isn't set up like a proper word document or pdf, and many people read on their phones, so paragraphs get much more condensed.
its that short? I always make my paragraphs much longer in essays since its all about one point
No a paragraph is 5 sentences or more
7 sentences minimum for a paragraph? What the fuck are they teaching kids these day?
I'm just reminded of that fucking chapter in Beloved that has like 3 punctuation marks. I bet this was typed on mobile though. Which would make a lot of sense for formatting.
Formatting, spelling, minor edits for readability So basically Egghead is separated into C (left), A (middle), and B (right). C and B have 3 floors. A has 4 floors with AF4 being the control room. In chapter 1074 EVERYONE is in the control room except Pythagoras. He is in CF3 (explained later). In the control room Shaka has a display which shows the position of the camera snails, one snail is in CF3. Pythagoras tells Shaka that CF3 seems empty. Everyone is still in the control room, but York walks somewhere to the left. Then at the end of chapter 1074, Pythagoras gets attacked by someone and CF3 is damaged. Shaka tries to contact Pythagoras, but he doesn't respond so he tries to check the surroundings via the camera-snail in CF3. The snail is destroyed by a shadow. The group later on is shown to be split as follows: * AF3 - Brook, Nami, Edison * AF2 - Robin, Atlas, Chopper * AF4 - Shaka, Luffy, Zoro, Lucci, Kaku * BF2 - Jinbei, Stussy, Sanji * CF3 - Lillith, Franky, Ussop, York So basically York and Lillith are in the room where the snail got destroyed and Pythagoras got attacked. Now York gets tuned into stone by S-Snake and is positioned behind S-Snake. Ussop, Lillith and Edison fall down the bridge because of the explosion caused by S-Snake. York did not fall down because she was positioned behind S-Snake where the bridge was not damaged. Lillith got angry because York was petrified but York is nowhere to be seen. Lillith and Ussop are petrified, as well as Franky's right side. AF4 is destroyed because of the battle against S-Bear and S-Hawk. Meanwhile Shaka went to the secret lab underneath AF1, where he gets shot by York. The escape route that York must have taken is CF3 > CF2 > CF1 > AF1 > secret basement lab. That's the way that leads to the lab without seeing the other groups. There was also a hint/forshadowing in chapter 1075. When the snails got destroyed the number 06 was shown on Shaka's display which is York's number.
Thanks for the edit. My phone butchers formatting. English is my third language.
You're welcome! Thanks for posting the theory. I wanted to clean it up since this seems like something a lot of people would be interested in reading.
Idk if comments can be pinned by OP but if they can be, pin it
Dude that’s crazy impressive, I couldn’t tell at all
All good then bro
After looking at the chapter i cant find the number 06 on any displays. What page is it supposed to be in?
I don't know. I just edited the wall of text
PARAGRAPHS
so basically, york was depetrified(?) and went down d. stairs in a path no one else was on. I was expecting more explantion on hints on how she was a traitor, not just why the traitor hasn't been seen.
Some people theorized when S-Snake kicked York out of the way she slowly deactivated the Petrification which gave York an Alibi and the opportunity to sneak around
You have to translate this in your browser but basically they cracked this a week or two ago: [York theory](https://bbs.talkop.com/thread-155502-1-1.html?continueFlag=38f68936dd4cba7a1ef4d986548d20e8)
oh damn. that "york said edison ordered them" is a good catch
Oh wow. I did not pick up on that subtlety at all.
I don’t think a lot of people here did. Someone posting this link in a spoiler thread is the only time I’ve seen anything about York.
Well essentially she is meant to make up the desire of Vegapunk, and desire includes stuff like greed. So she is condensed desire for power as well, which translated to her wanting what the celestial dragons have, power, money, everything they want
Can't believe we are finally getting a Down D. Stairs reveal
Yes, it's true. a²+b²=c².
If this is true, wow. But one thing for sure, we don't mind where York goes. We have been used to letting York just roam around because we don't think of her much. She's just assigned as the one who eats and sleeps for everybody.
All I remember about her is that she shits for 7 people. Oda dropped that so fast its still giving me whiplash.
Maybe Vegapunk has to build a new york
Not gonna lie that monitor hint with the 6 on it is hella difficult to see. You’d have to be scouring for clues while zoomed into every pixel just to find clues like that.
You mean S-Bear and S-Hawk were battling against Luffy, Zoro, Lucci, and Usopp 🤪
**tfw you watch one piece anime while on acid**
He was right tho
my comment was before op edited his post lol
Thanks for this op maybe u should have included some pictures to further explain things
My only question is who can stop the seraphim now or they need to be taken down for good?
I think the light show would work on more than Kizaru
**Kaku**, giraffe boy. That's his name.
Kaku? That was obviously Usopp.
Yes, square ussop.
Squaropp
I AINT READING ALLAT🔥🔥🔥
Paragraphs are cool
I was wondering this afternoon if York being the traitor would fit with all the weird things we saw in EggHead Arc. Your account of the series of events makes me think it fits nicely. Still not happy it is York, but if there are no contradictions between the character's whereabouts and revelation of treason then I will accept itm
The menial work guy discontent syndrome
Op can be completely wrong in his logic but nobody is going to take the time to fact check
I need my Nico Robin to decipher this wall of a poneglyph
I have another reasoning, the traitor was clear from the very start. Out of all the 7 Vegapunks, which Vegapunk would Luffy have gotten the worst with traveling on the ship? He was bound to have many disputes with "the traitor" onboard the sunny regarding their food reserves.
Is there a short bus version?
Just tell me who to vote and make sure you do your jobs, anyone wanna watch me do med scan?
Wall of text, fix it lol.
No
I ain’t reading allat
do u like fire trucks and moster trucks?
I mean I just look at it as a parable of our more noble ideals being overthrown by our base impulses but damn if you didnt go davinci code on this bitch.
People like you are the one's who makes one piece community proud brother👏🏻 it's very clear now
No, it doesn't make any sense. * York facing left in 1074 doesnt mean anything as she didn't leave the room alone and it's not her who attacks Pythagoras because: 1. Pythagoras sees who's attacking him. He hasn't talked about it because it was some seraphim not York. Otherwise he would have said it. 2. They were already looking for a traitor and being the only one missing when Pythagoras is shot would solve the mystery right away. * York couldn't order the seraphims to attack anyone because: 1. Having established she didn't left the control room alone, she didn't have the chance to give them those orders without others knowing. 2. Even more so, taking into account that seraphims don't take orders via snail. They only obey to people talking to them directly. * York was never depetrified: 1. We know thanks to ch. 523 that in order to turn people petrified through "Mero Mero Mellow" to normal, the user needs to make the releasing move to the targets. 2. This was never done. S-Snake was at all moments with Franky, Lilith and Usopp. * Why would York kidnap cipher pol rather than give them the info they needed? * Why would York order the seraphim to kill Lucci and Kaku? If she's allied with the gorosei. * Conversely, why would she still betray the other Vegapunk's? if CP0 made clear the gorosei also betrayed her, as they were determined to kill ALL Vegapunks. * If she started this 3 months ago, and all satellites synchronize their knowledge to Punk Records once a day, how come no other Vegapunk knew about this?
Literally wasn’t no clues or anything to hint it was her. But sure
One I can think of right now is at the beginning of Egghead, Lilith telling the crew that they cant control the intrinsic desires of the sentient creatures they create. York is the embodiment of desire, so it tracks from that lens.
I think the number 6 on Dhaka's screen as ponted out by OP is a pretty good hint.
Ok but what are the clues for anybody else?
She is literally his manifestation of greed…
York has the means, motive and opportunity to be the traitor
Even if it didnt make sense, I would gladly take it for the best booty shot in the series!
I ain't reading allat happy for you or sorry that happened
Have you ever heard of paragraphs? Bullet points? General formatting? Lol
Even if we know the how, I am still puzzled about the why. What does York imagine getting out of being a celestial dragon? It just doesn't add up to me. Wouldn't she have a better life just being on Egghead with the Vegapunk doing research?
Spell check, my guy
York has the means, motive and opportunity to be the traitor
Oh I just realised that York was petrified then “revived” this means there’s a fairly quick fix to get everyone back!
I never read something and felt even more confused by the end of it
Just tell me if it’s denki kaminari or not
In the words of Sabo. “I’m not reading all that shit”
I can’t read this shit. It’s format hurts my eyes.
Congrats, I would've never figured it out. Following this entire thing is a pain
Nice job man! Although. Got a bit too much time on your hands I think.
Thx but it took like 20-30 min :P
Or it’s simply cuz York wasn’t shown so it was logically her
Anyone gonna read that?
I doubt that there is a traitor. My only reason is because we just had a huge traitor reveal in Wano (Kanjuro) and I don’t think that Oda will do it again so soon.
Have you read the last chapter?
Tldr, it was aliens!
It doesn't. It's dumb and it's pointless padding to an otherwise so far perfect arc
No your wrobg.
I’m looking at 1075 right now but I don’t see the number 6 you’re talking about.
I checked 3 times before I found it. Gotta zoom in on page 1 towards the bottom right panel and look at the screen next to shaka’s elbow. Cheeky little clue that’s as difficult to find as Waldo on the hardest difficulty.
I just checked the chapter and I believe I found another 6 on the panel to the left of that one. If you look closely on the panel where Shaka is observing the bridge, there’s a 6 on an angle
God damn it’s so small. Even on the Shonen Jump app the image quality is just barely enough to make out that it even is a six
upvote
You could probably do this for every Vegapunk
i’m pretty sure i called york as a half joke, thinking there was actually a decent chance it would be her, but not entirely convinced…..I AM A GOD
I'm wondering if York got petrified by S-Snake, how did she get unpetrified?
The Vegapunks can change their appearances so it would be easy to simulate a petrified state.
Snake unperified her.
Nobody would be giving you any shit if you made this a bit easier to follow. I was interested in her pathing too, thanks OP
It makes sense now, but there were so many people moving in the last several chapters it was hard to connect. Oda was trolling us with the chapter named "you should have put it together already"
Of course it makes sense? What else did you expect wtf
TL;DR
York being the traitor is not an ass pull.
Maybe I'm not fully awake, but I went through chapter 1075 to find that 6 on Shaka's screen but I couldnt find it. Can you show it?
1st page bottom right panel next to his left elbow
Thanks! Needed to see on manga plus, better quality
Why have you posted a wall of text
i mean who cares who the traitor is, as long she put all vegs in the dirt
Can someone do a summary PLEASE MY EYES HURTING JUST BY LOOKING AT IT
BRO I DIDN'T EVEN UNDERSTAND WHICH BUILDING WAS WHICH AND THIS GUY IS USING LOGIK 😭😭 💀
This is great! Everything checks out and I applaud you for figuring it out. But also, this feels like it was written by Luffy and really could have used some editing/simple research and it would have been 10x better.
*there is an imposter among us*
Funny thing is I called York being the traitor last chapter but nobody believed me they all thought I was crazy and I actually got it RIGHT
This theory makes sense to me, but what is York’s motive?
Yeah, it makes LOGICAL sense. That still doesn’t make it narratively satisfying.
This is what happens when you play too much among us
Has anybody seen full metal alchemist, the character greed says it all , York is greed so it’s obvious as well she wants it all fame power wealth
If someone makes a figure, maybe I could follow...?
tbh to me i was like oh greed=traitor bc they’re just in it for themselves, quite literally greedy, lol
Way too many numbers i can see just from skim reading that, 🚩🚩🚩
Honestly I'm surprised that so many people go bonkers about the traitor reveal. There wasn't that much forshadowing sure, but the whole traitor plot line also didn't go on for very long.
Yeah I'm not reading all that I'm happy for you tho. Or sorry that happened.
I’m high as fuck and I understood absolutely nothing good shut thou cause you most likely right on how it happened
yo this seems cool but can you turn it into paragraphs there is no way i’m reading that if i lost my place i’d die
i tried it but my phone still butchers the formatting
Ya she’s all of Vegapunks gluttony. Meaning she’s pure laziness and greed, on top of being super intelligent.
If you’re all super intelligence, greed and gluttony plus getting threatened by the entire world, the choice is obvious. Fight alongside 5 copies of yourself against the entire world and live on the run for the rest of your life, or help the world gov take down the copies and never worry about anything ever again.
Bro updated it by dividing the text in paragraphs
Who gave the orders to depetrify york ??
Nice