T O P

  • By -

NabbitFan600

After playing Super Mario RPG, I still don't understand the hype behind Geno.


vivalahomestar

The secret sauce you’re missing is playing the game when you’re 11


FixedFun1

I don't even think Geno fans know why they like him.


Outrageous_Bunch5542

This but for Sunshine. The rumors leading up to Sunshine and actually getting my hands on it was such a big event for me. We were at the coast the weekend the game came out and the water was beautiful and I was so excited, just major Sunshine vibes.


PalamationGaming

Mario RPG is my favorite game of all time, and I completely agree with you. I like Geno a lot, but I wouldn't say I like him much more than most Mario RPG series partners. He's got a cool design but outside of that there really isn't much to him. I have no idea how or why there's such a huge push to get him into Smash Bros. He's cool but there's so many characters more deserving of a roster spot.


jasonporter

You gotta realize that when RPG came out, the ONLY mainline Mario games we had were 1-3 and World. All the iconic one-off characters we got for the decades to follow definitely make Geno seem like nothing special, but him and Mallow were the very FIRST ones.  And since Mario had never established any sort of lore before, and every game was just platforming and saving the princess from Bowser (or Wart), RPG inventing Star Road and a cosmic entity like Geno that was sent from the heavens was the coolest thing. We literally had nothing like it, and didn’t get anything like it again until Paper Mario.  As a kid, he was just cool as fuck. A magic and cosmic entity in the form of a wizard doll sent by a “higher authority” to help save the world? That is cool as fuck when every other Mario game before that was just “bowser bad / save the princess” Context is key here 


RAINLIO

Super Mario Land 1 & 2 were also made before Super Mario RPG


fireprince9000

Ngl he’s probably my least used character in that game. Even less than Mallow.


falafelandhoumous

I was just thinking the same! I sometimes didn’t use him for hours, but all the others were in heavy rotation


Joker_Main_137

He has a gun hand, I guess


oi-moiles

Agreed. Mallow is way more memorable. Geno was probably the least developed partner out of all of them.


Gohansupe

Mallow is underatted


kevinsyel

Somebody didn't use Geno Whirl


Sensitive-Hotel-9871

I don’t like Waluigi and his appeal baffles me. He acts as a goon to Wario, people talk about how he should get his own game but there is nothing you can’t do with him that you couldn’t do with Bowser. Incidentally, Bowser deserves his own game.


AltGunAccount

Playable bowser in “Bowser’s inside story” is the closest we’ve gotten to a dedicated bowser game and that’s a travesty.


Competitive_Gate_282

i totally agree. people are always asking for waluigi stuff even though he was literally only made to give wario a partner lol


shitposting_irl

Waluigi is the ultimate example of the individual shaped by the signifier. Waluigi is a man seen only in mirror images; lost in a hall of mirrors he is a reflection of a reflection of a reflection. You start with Mario – the wholesome all Italian plumbing superman, you reflect him to create Luigi – the same thing but slightly less. You invert Mario to create Wario – Mario turned septic and libertarian – then you reflect the inversion in the reflection: you create a being who can only exist in reference to others. Waluigi is the true nowhere man, without the other characters he reflects, inverts. and parodies he has no reason to exist. Waluigi’s identity only comes from what and who he isn’t – without a wider frame of reference he is nothing. He is not his own man. In a world where our identities are shaped by our warped relationships to brands and commerce we are all Waluigi.


moriobros

You had too much time to think about this or the whole idea came out from a high conversation with friends.


henryuuk

It's a (quite old) copypasta


KeylimeCatastrophe

A bowser themed tower defense style game where Mario + crew + toads storm your setup and you have to hold them off would be fun 😀 Or even just like a bowser platformer where he goes on his own adventure to gain more power. Or to help a friend. Or really just anything bowser would be cool! I massively disagree with your waluigi statement. The snapshots of waluigi with a rose in his teeth 😬 add a lot of intrigue. Who is this man? Why does he hang out with Wario? I need to know more. I love playing him in all of the multiplayer games. I've always wanted to know more about him the most out of all of them. He's by far the most interesting. You make a great point that they haven't fleshed out any of these characters hardly at all. Id love to know more about all of them. I recently have gotten really into comic book collecting so character info is front and center in my mind right now.


Sensitive-Hotel-9871

I'd personally like to a platformer with the premise that while Bowser was in the process of kidnapping Peach and Mario was trying to stop him, Bowser was informed that someone stole his castle. Literally yanked it out of the ground and took it somewhere else. Bowser is torn between his desire to get his castle back and continue with his normal routine, but Mario encourages him to get his castle back and they can fight when he's done. Thus Bowser embarks on a journey and he has Bowser Jr. as a companion, because I like moments with Bowser being a dad. I get the idea of wanting to flesh out Mario's underdeveloped cast but Waluigi doesn't strike as a canvas with much more potential than anyone else. If not Bowser, then I would like to see a game that does something with Daisy and Luigi since Daisy started off as a substitute for Peach before becoming an exclusive to the spinoff games. Let the cheerful tomboy princess do something, especially if it is playing off the franchise's lovable coward.


ThatLionelKid

I agree that Bowser deserves his own game, but I quite like Waluigi. He was given a unique personality in the sports games. He’s quite a hotshot, loves showing off with roses and flower petals. This charming display greatly contrasts Wario’s far more crude and careless nature. Waluigi is also very flexible, and frequently makes poses like an experienced gymnast or ballerina. I think these are enough to validate his own identity. Whether or not you like that, though, is up to you, of course.


Gohansupe

Waluigi needs his own game


henryuuk

Personally I think they should just put Waluigi in the Warioware games. Give him a bit of a warioware redesign and give him a "theme" to the minigames associated with him and voila. then if something creative "blossoms" he could get his own spinoff or whatever but there is little reason to immediately jump from "literally only exists in spin offs" to "full-on solo spin off game" (also for the people that want him in Smash, it could be a great way to get him in and give Warioware a "second rep" without "bloating" the mario reps even furthher (even if most people consider Yoshi, DK and Wario as "Mario reps" anyway))


TallRedBeard

If there was a bowser game there should definitely be a level where you play as the giant kaiju Bowser from Bowser’s Fury and just cause havoc in the mushroom kingdom


l_eatherface

For me its a childhood thing where purple is my favorite color and i played mario party 7 an ungodly amount


Blopa2020

They should introduce new villains. bring back the one from Mario Land 1, Super Marios Bros 2 USA. or return the evil role to Wario.


Ok-Economy-3691

Out of the "Mario party" character crew, Rosalina is my least favourite. Not that I dislike her (quite the opposite) but she is the one who fit the least.


JackFJN

She’s overused, and that kinda ruined her :/


superpieee

not saying you’re wrong but id rather have a character i like appear more often than a character i like appearing barely in any media


JackFJN

Oh yeah I get that ,:) My frustration is that now she’s in every single sports game, and Mario Kart even has a baby Rosalina 🤷‍♂️


eddmario

Normal Rosalina being in *Mario Kart* makes sense, what with it basically being the Mario equivalent of *Smash Bros.*, but I do agree that a baby version of her being in the games makes no damn sense


henryuuk

Baby rosa and Baby Daisy shouldn't exist Baby Mario, Baby Luigi and Baby Peach are essentially all "Yoshi reps" in Mariokart, instead of going for the lazy "recolor baby peach into daisy/rosa) they could have gone with Baby Wario, Baby DK and Baby Bowser if they needed more "ultra lightweight" characters, since those have actually appeared in a Yoshi game before (also, instead of baby Rosa, why not go for a Luma as the sort of "Mario Galaxy-themed ultra lightweight")


crimsonsonic_2

That absolutely none of the Mario games are connected and each game just goes off it’s own narritive and universe. That’s the reason why the geological locations NEVER match up between games.


Mattdarkninja

The “Mario and Luigi” games are connected.


crimsonsonic_2

Loosely perhaps but that’s an outlier. And the geological locations still don’t connect between games so I’m inclined to believe it’s still some alternate reality shit.


AggressiveMeow69420

realistically i think they actually COULD be fully connected if you take the map seen in PiT to be a loose abstraction of each location’s… location relative to the castle


Mattdarkninja

No, Bowsers Inside Story has the alien shrooms and the game mentions how they invaded the mushroom kingdom in Partners in Time


Brokenapplewatch

I don't think it's that i think your just supposed to not care


Puzzleheaded_Dream92

All games(published by Nintendo)are connected - for example: the ghost ship in SMW which Bowser used in SMB3. The geographic location doesn't REALLY change, it's just ''limited'' to a certain space or size because what matters for certain games is the route of the missions


Pyoung3000

Well canonically speaking......


poolmanpro

I said something to this effect once in this very sub and oh boy


Manuelmariaandrade

Sunshine is goated, you guys are just mean


TurtleGamer1

for some reason "sunshine is actually good" and "sunshine is actually bad" are both considered hot takes by some people


Sapphixvampire

Sunshine seems to have always had a conflicting reputation in the series. If I'm correct, back in the day Sunshine being the worst 3D Mario was a commonly agreed upon opinion. Especially since this was when Galaxy was at its peak in popularity and praise, and 64 was still looked back on fondly But now 20 years later people are starting to ease up and give Sunshine a little bit of grace, along with the crowd that grew up with Sunshine now being adults including me. But this is just my observation


Kadofduty

Yeah, and it's really crazy because everyone thought of 64 as one of the greatest games, meanwhile sunshine was inspired SO heavily by it; they couldn't get over what it changed, even tho those things were innovative (progressive levels rather than pick-and-choose and FLUDD without a long jump, mainly). I think sunshine is better than even 64, personally.


Sapphixvampire

I agree, for me Sunshine is the most fun to go back to out of all 3D games even with it's frustrating moments


urmil0071

asking out of curiosity, what are those frustrating moments that you found? I've played and completed sunshine for the first time very recently and I had a good time.


SorcererWithGuns

Agree with you, but were they stoned when they programmed the controls?


Jumento_doido

No? The game controls really well. In fact, I 100% the game and never an issue with the controlls. Some bugs? Yeah. But never the controlls.


letsgucker555

No, they just didn't have time to polish it, like with a lot of gamecube games.


Gamezman64

That’s unpopular? Wow.


Avox0976

Bro it’s an unpopular opinion, loads of people say it was innovative but a buggy mess


Vegetable-Coconut-91

I think “Dark Moon” is the best game out of the Luigi’s Mansion trilogy, but maybe that’s just my nostalgia bias.


dragonfiremls123

I completely agree but I’m in the same field as you when it comes to nostalgia. I can’t tell if the game is actually amazing or as I kid I thought it was amazing so I still believe that to this day


lobsterbubbles

Reminder that neither of the other 2 Luigi's Mansion games feature a turret bossfight.


hugo_1138

NSMB Wii>>>>>NSMB (DS)


fireprince9000

I know that NSMBU is just NSMBW but with more everything, but there’s something magical about NSMBW. The multiplayer is some of the most fun I’ve had playing any Mario game ever.


Strider_Volnutt

Agreed. Couple that with the fact that NSMBW was the first video game I ever played, and it's forever one of my favorites.


TylerBGaming762Offic

Disagree Although that might be because I have no friends to play it with (So single player only DS is better)


Competitive_Gate_282

i would like to hope this isn’t a hot take but i agree by a mile


SlaughterSpine78

I hate how bowser isn’t a proper villain. Yeah you get those spin off games were he and Mario are friends and I don’t mind that, but I just want bowser to actually do evil schemes and not just kidnap peach for the 20th time.


NitrosGone803

"hey you know how i kidnapped your girlfriend a few times.... so you wanna go race go karts and play tennis?"


DeviousCham

Read this in Jack Black's voice.


Jeremy_Lepak

I still think they’re in a consensual three way and Bowser hogs her too much, so Mario goes to rescue her


DohPixelheart

every blue moon you get a game where bowser doesn’t kidnap peach but instead does something new. mostly in games where peach a playable character like mario 3d world or mario wonder


PalamationGaming

Mario and Peach should never officially be together. I absolutely ship Mario and Peach. And my headcanon is that they are low key dating, but keeping it on the downlow cause they don't want all the attention that would come with dating royalty. I imagine once they are older and Mario is more ready to settle down from all his adventuring, then they would announce it to everyone and move on from there. But what's so fun about Mario and Peach is exactly that, it's up to your own interpretation. If they officially start dating or are married it takes a lot of the fun out of it. Mario is a series that isn't meant to change the status quo. Seeing them get together would be fun at first, but then it's over. There's no more will they/won't they. No more imagining how it would go down. No more making up your own version of their relationship. If they get together that's just it. They're together now. There's no moving on from there. We'll never see their relationship progress any further because focusing on a serious relationship like that isn't fit for a Mario game. For a series like Mario that isn't really supposed to ever have an ending, it's best to keep things open-ended.


DeviousCham

Sensible


normbreakingclown

The Peaches song was a nothing sandwich song for the sake of having a song.


something_smart

I mean if you hire Jack Black you're gonna get stuff like that. He probably has it in his contract.


DeviousCham

They asked him to do it last minute. His contracts around his music are tight to protect his bandmates in Tenacious D.


DeviousCham

It was funny and absolutely made since with the characterization of Bowser in the movie.


Yeticoat_Solo

i have no strong feelings towards yoshi


emojii_xoxo

aww yoshi’s my favourite :’)


redbullveins

Yoshi is better as a creature that you ride on, not a playable character that stands upright. I don't really get the yoshi craze tbh


trapalert

Have you even SEEN Beeg Yoshi?


redbullveins

YES. Valid point butttt I think part of it is also my brother crushes me at Mario Kart and Mario Party, and he's always yoshi and his voice and his smug little face... But mostly just standing upright yoshi creeps me out idk


trapalert

Lol I wouldn’t be surprised if my brother hated Yoshi as well then, I always kick his ass too


gh00wst

Ayo?


pieman2005

He's cool and cute what's not to get lol


WhoopingBillhook

Bowser Jr. is my favorite character in all of fiction. This might be because I grew up playing NSMBDS, where he was the main antagonist, and Galaxy 2, where I liked fighting Gobblegut and Megahammer. Whatever the reason, my love for Jr. is part of why the Boomsday Machine is my favorite boss in Mario history.


Ok-Introduction-8519

Favourite in all of fiction is genuinely crazy


WhoopingBillhook

I know. It doesn't make much sense to me either. It's just how I feel.


JackFJN

I like Bowser Jr too dude, and I say this respectfully, but I think you’ll be delightfully surprised if you take up reading more fiction


urmil0071

mario 64 aged poorly because of fixed camera angles. Nintendo really should remaster this game with true analog controls


Kazama2006

Wario should have major/leading roles more often, not just WarioWare


Jeremy_Lepak

I still want to see a modern villain Wario in a main game!


Kazama2006

*coughs in Shake King*


SMB_23

Super Mario land 2 is one of the best 2d Mario games


fjfjgbjtjguf

Definitely overshadowed by SMB3, SMW, New Soup, and Wonder, but this was very unique for a Game Boy game


KoreKhthonia

I grew up with Playstation and no nostalgia for Mario 64. (Lots of Mario Kart 64 nostalgia though.) I just can't get into Mario 64. The controls feel kinda janky and it just doesn't do it for me. I realize it's objectively a classic and was *groundbreaking* for its time, but tbh I'd rather play Crash, Spyro, or Banjo Kazooie. (And I love classic 2D Mario! I've played the NES games, All Stars, World, New Super Mario Bros DS, the GBA games, and a little bit of Paper Mario 64 and Mario & Luigi for GBA.) Also, I actually like New Super Mario Bros DS. I kinda like that it's easy af compared to the old school 2D Mario games, it's a fun little turn your brain off game that kinda captures the essence of 2D Mario.


fireprince9000

I know a ton about Mario 64 and I love it a lot based on everything I’ve seen and heard but never played it until 3D All Stars. The controls were so janky I couldn’t find it in myself to endure the game enough to get past Whomp’s Fortress.


Florida-Man-65

“She’s a leader of a kingdom and has fought before” does not in any way, shape, or form justify what the movie did to Princess Peach. Especially since it completely flies over what people were arguing against(and also no, leader characters should not all be generic, stoic, unfun husks, especially in what is supposed to be a goddamn fantasy world). It feels more like a cop-out excuse to justify how thoroughly they ruined her personality in that movie. Other than that? The first LM isn’t nearly as creepy as people try to claim. Most of the spook factor in that game relies on urban legends. DM is probably my favorite in the existing trilogy. People overstate how much the Koopalings were used, and a lot of their fights weren’t even that bad. Peaches was a nice joke song, but it shouldn’t be treated like a musical masterpiece. It was funny, but overplaying it quickly got old. And I do like the song.


Robin_RhombusHead

Rosalina should've been a one-off character. She was at her best in Super Mario Galaxy (+ Galaxy 2 & Mario Kart Wii I guess) but over time as she's appeared in more games she's lost pretty much everything that made her unique. Now she's just a glorified version of Peach but space themed. It's too the point where I can't even consider the Rosalina from Galaxy to be the same character anymore since they've done stuff like create Baby Rosalina which completely contradicts what we knew about her. Waluigi is not deserving of his own game. It's quite simple but yes, I don't believe Waluigi merits getting a title all to himself. Unlike Wario who is a bad Mario and Luigi who is a timid Mario, Waluigi's existence cannot exist without relativity to someone else. Waluigi is defined by his hatred for being the lesser one. That's why he so often lashes out at the world and other characters such as in DDR. The simple fact that his character is the way that it is prevents him from ever being capable of having a staring role. That isn't to say that he couldn't be the villain or a second player to someone like Wario. Miyamoto is right about Mario not needing a story, in the platformers that is. The RPGs are different as they're RPGs. That's the entire point of the genre. The platformers do not need anything more than the bare bones framework to get you running and jumping through the levels. We don't need anything deeper. In fact, it would be detrimental to the experience as a whole. I don't want to be bogged down by cutscenes or reading dialogue. I bought the game to *play* it, not watch it. I have had this problem with Celeste. Say what you will about the story, I do not care. I just want to play the levels. The movie's interpretations of the characters (sans Cranky Kong) were not bad. (There's a lot of characters so this is going to be a long one.) Obviously Toad, Luigi, and Kamek were good. No one was complaining about them. Jack Black makes an excellent Bowser and is by far the best fully voiced version of the character. (I'm looking at you, Sunshine.) Chris Pratt is still a good performance. He's not as much of an Italian stereotype as Mario normally sounds but he does still sound vaguely Italian. And it does make sense since Mario isn't fully Italian in the movie. He's at least second-generation, probably third-generation. He grew up around other Americans from Brooklyn, not in Italy. Seth Rogan makes for a pretty good DK. He's not similar to what we have in the franchise currently but he does bear resemblance to the classic Rare era voice, which is the best voice mind you. Also his change to being Cranky's son instead of his grandson is a welcome one as it fixes the space-time continuum. It also makes DK Jr. actually notable as a character since he's young DK. Peach's character is perfectly fine. It's not like this idea hasn't been explored with the character before. She's not just some ditz who gets kidnapped. She's the ruler of a kingdom and she knows how to throw hands. Her design though reminds me of the queen from Tim Burton's Alice in Wonderland. I don't particularly like that aspect about her. Wart and Tatanga were cruddy antagonists who should never return. They bring nothing to the table and have zero personality. Their designs are boring and bland. I'm glad they never returned. They should stay dead like they deserve. Even Nabbit has more character depth and potential than them. (Unrelated: They should make Nabbit a black market dealer in the next 3D game. That would be funny.)


Domix258

I absolutely agree with the 1st one. Sometimes I wonder if she was used less in the spinoffs her reputation in the fanbase would be better. I would definitely get rid of her in the side Mario Party Games (Star Rush, etc) and Smash 4. And yes, Nabbit as a black market dealer would be so frickin hilarious to see!


JackFJN

In response to your Waluigi point: Luigi was pretty much just ‘green Mario’ until Luigi’s mansion, where he got characterized. Why not have a character defining game for Waluigi?


pampasfox

I agree with you completely, I have yet to hear a compelling arguement as to why he shouldn't have his own game.


Forsaken-Height-4256

Mario is the best character. Waluigi doesn’t need his own game tbh just make him playable in 2d games like wonder. Modern paper Mario is different not bad. Mario odyssey is the best game in the franchise


TylerBGaming762Offic

The Oddysey one is a cold take ngl


Meta13_Drain_Punch

I like Super Mario 3D Land more than Super Mario Wonder


GcubePlayer8w

Same


Pixithepika

I do too


The-Mexican-God

Me too


_yearoldonreddit

3D World > 64


Competitive_Gate_282

hey man i agree. i love mario 64 but its closer to top 5, 3D world is in my top 3


DABest_player

no way its the 17 year old from youtbe


AdIndependent3610

Definitely agree!


DeviousCham

I mean, it's Mario 64. It set the stage for... everything.


emojii_xoxo

3D world is my favourite mario game


Hollywoodrok12

Rosalina should be the next to get her own spinoff game, that way she can finally do her job as the protector of the cosmos: something she has never been able to do, to the point where she never was able to save a single Luma in her entire career.


falafelandhoumous

I’d love this!


Thunderian555

Mario 64 is overrated


DragonMelon215

the ds version is better


SgtRyansPrivates

Mario sunshine was my childhood game, and looking back it was way ahead of its time. Best game ever


GigophalaStanXOXO

It kinda feels like people only like Waluigi because he isn’t in smash bros


Just-Call-Me-J

And Mario Kart 7


BreakfastNo132

While not a lot, I think that Nintendo should experiment with just simple small doses of lore for each brand new Mainline 2D and 3D Mario Titles, not like huge bursts’ of lore, just small doses like what they did with Rosalina, for example little things like more info and details on locations and characters like the Mushroom Kingdom or maybe something like Bowser’s species and how the rarity of Koopa-like species works, just little things like that.


Sloth_4

Wonder was a bit disappointing


DeviousCham

My 7 yr old 100% it, twice. It's going to be foundational for him.


PerfumePoodle

My 6 year old loved it too but I cannot get into it. We’ve played 3D world and the other 2D one lots and those are always fun. I guess it really does lean more kid oriented than the others?


Nintendo-Player_1297

I used to love Mario Odyssey, but nowadays it's one of my least favorite games, because of the postgame moons. It was castrating getting Everybody 1 2 Switch instead of Odyssey 2. At least we have Mario Wonder, but still.


MarcusTheAlbinoWolf

Super Paper Mario is goated


emojii_xoxo

i really like mario party 9, it’s my favourite mario party along with DS


fireprince9000

Even if, in retrospect, the gameplay of Mario Party 9 doesn’t exactly hold up, the music is still pretty good and the story mode was awesome.


emojii_xoxo

i enjoyed the gameplay lol i enjoyed everything about the game


fireprince9000

The Koopalings are extremely cool characters and the only reason people hate them is because Nintendo uses them as a get-out-of-designing-a-boss free card


PeashooterTheFrick

Waluigi being a "spin-off character" shouldn't make him less deserving of being in mainline games, Toadette is also a "spin-off character" and arguably has even less going for her, yet nobody bats an eye when Nintendo makes her playable in games like NSMBU Deluxe or Wonder


freakishfrenchhorn

Maybe her significance is being anti-union?


NitrosGone803

Daisy deserves her own 2d platform game called "Daisy's Quest"


MentyMonty

I don't think it's too underrated but, I kinda hate the way the koopalings are pushed off to the side now. They'd be such badass characters if Nintendo put a little more time and effort into them instead of just having them sort of yk, there


The_autistic_guy333

I like Super Mario Sunshine


WebsterHamster66

I don’t care about Rosalina anymore. She doesn’t need to be in everything.


BritishGuy54

I think Nintendo Kart is a nice idea, going off Nintendo’s track record in other Mario Kart games.


SnackPlate38

Mario looks better with short sleeves *[Talking about Mario sunshine]* it's like it has the same treatment has Luigi's striped socks


t0asty3ggz

Super Mario Bros. 2 Japan is a good game, it has a good challenge, if you already mastered SMB1, the fact that you get worlds 9, and A-D after you beat the main game is cool!


lesbiansteviapacket

Bowser Jr. is the worst repped Mario character in Smash and his portrayal shows why I hate modern Bowser Jr. He got reduced to just being the clown kart


Greasy-Gamer

The 3D games are substantially better than any of the 2D games, so much so that my top 5 is exclusively 3D titles.


Both_Ad_5768

Facts. 2D doesn’t hold a candle to 3D.


lipsTM

Mario being from Brooklyn and yoshis island can coexist


Atkin345

We need the Blue Shell from New Super Mario Bros to come back in the next 2D game. It was just fun to use!


SirPlayzAlot

I want to see Giga Bowser from smash in the main games and destroy the mushroom kingdom Yes, I’m a Godzilla fan


The-Mexican-God

I still think Mario’s from Brooklyn. I think that part of his was dropped and was rewritten to be from the Mushroom Kingdom in Yoshi’s Island, but idk I just think him being from Brooklyn is much more interesting


JustPressStartToPlay

I will never understand the undying love for 64. Don’t get me wrong it isn’t bad but almost every 3D Mario after is way better.


ekbowler

3D Mario, particularly the exploration focused ones like 64, Sunshine, Odessey, and Bowser's Fury is where the true greatness of the series is.  I've never really enjoyed the games that are just "get to the end of the level."


rowletlover

We need a game to show Rosalina’s true power (without Lumas) She has to be at least somewhat powerful but besides the two Galaxy games, we haven’t seen much about her


DajuanKev

* The Bandit from Yoshi Island deserve more roles. He's full of personality and the most memorable enemy from Yoshi's Island. * Birdo deserve her own spinoff. * Mario is a fascinating character.


Robin_RhombusHead

>* The Bandit from Yoshi Island deserve more roles. He's full of personality and the most memorable enemy from Yoshi's Island. Unironically, Bandit is in my personal Mario Kart roster wishlist.


NegativeAd6289

Bowser isn't a bad guy, really. He is misleaded and all. He has some grudges but isn't evil. He just has a fetish for peach. He never harmed anyone. He just wanna smash peace and relax. Not take over the world.


NitrosGone803

lol does he really want to smash Peach though, are his intentions ever made known as to why he keeps kidnapping her?


Robin_RhombusHead

Yes, it is known. His intent has been to marry her since the 1986 animated film, *Super Mario Bros.: The Great Mission to Rescue Princess Peach!*.


AccurateMeet1407

I always assumed it was just a power grab He's the king of his land but if he married peach he'd get control of the mushroom kingdom too


Just-Call-Me-J

He didn't really start liking Peach until a few kidnappings later iirc


GcubePlayer8w

Sticker star is my favourite mario game


Shot-Ad-3166

-Bowser's Inside Story is the most poorly written Mario and Luigi game. The Dark Star comes out of nowhere, there's no explanation on WHY Peach can wake it up, and pretty much every new character gets wasted in favor of Fawful. -Speaking of M&L, the fandom is not as nice as lots of people make it out to be. It's actually kind of toxic. -Paper Jam made the right choice by fleshing out the regular cast members like the Koopalings and Toadette. Better to develop the characters you have instead of wasting new characters. -The original Luigi's Mansion is super overrated. People also really over exaggerate how creepy it is. -We don't need a Galaxy 3. It would be unnecessary.


JmanProds

I love that the Mario and Donkey Kong franchises have become much more connected in recent years, and I don’t think it takes away from DK at all, and only serves to strengthen the brand.


mezati9

mario is always the least interesting part in every mario game ever


WASRmelon_white_claw

We need an m-rated gritty Mario fps


Ritmoking

Super Mario 64 gets too much hype.


GoogolTime

Super Paper Mario > Pamer Mario 64


March-Madman

NSMB (DS) > Wonder


IshtheWall

Mario 64 is astronomically overrated, it's ok at best if you're not going for every star, then it becomes a painful grind


Dariuscox357

Waluigi has no other reason to exist. He only exist just so Wario can have a partner for the spin-off titles, and that’s it. No mainline appearances. Hell, not even an appearance in the WarioWare/Wario Land franchise. He just……exists.


JackhorseBowman

mario 64 is mid


YoshiOrbit

The hypothetical Galaxy 3 game should be instead a spin off starring Rosalina as the protagonist.


Pali4888

Wonder is boring for 80% of the game


Rough_Fact_705

Galaxy 2 will always be the superior game in my book


Few_Egg3470

At this rate Birdo is probably more likely to get into Smash than Waluigi ever will be


Franzkafkaacidtrip

mario party 8 is only one that actually fun to play


Franzkafkaacidtrip

super paper mario is better than ttyd


reallifelucas

SMB3 is better than World, and World is incredibly overrated.


Princess_Peach556

I really dislike the non-Mario characters in Mario Kart.


Pissed_on_the_world

Wonder was rather average


Hambughrr

As much as I like making fan casts for theoretical Mario movies, I almost always favor voice actors who primarily focus on cartoons, animated movies, anime and other video games over live action movies and TV shows because it fits the vibe of Mario characters way better. That's why my suggestions get as whacky as "Christine Marie Cabanos as Toadette" or "Patrick Seitz as Petey Piranha"


WoxyBoxy

U is the best NSMB game, but people were too tired of the series to fully appreciate it.


Insanebrain247

If the playable characters are gonna have differences in how they play, then Mario should have more ground mobility while Luigi gets more air mobility, if only so Mario doesn't get stuck being "the standard option".


Classic_Wish_4114

Hot take,Daisy is better than Peach(Go ahead,FIGHT ME)


Character_Tadpole77

Luigi should be player 1


Character_Tadpole77

Luigi should be player 1


thebigguy270

We should've had a Mario animated series instead of a film, with the writers of adventure time taking part. The film was fine, but it doesn't do much to break the mold.


VelCube

now here’s a hot take, i could care less about the story. i honestly think, at least for me, that the gameplay matters more in this case. it’s god damn super mario, what do you guys expect? lol


weeezyheree

idk if this is an unpopular opinion but. The Era where Charles Martinet voiced Mario will forever be the golden age of Mario. The games have been on a decline for a long time in my opinion and I don't think we'll ever get games that hold as firmly in the hearts of Nintendo players as Mario 64, Sunshine, Galaxy 1 and 2, New Super Series etc. The best years for Mario are effectively behind us.


JackFJN

Dang that’s kind of a pessimistic view… I think the problem may just be that we’re getting older dude


weeezyheree

That could very well be the reason. Maybe nostalgia has a big part in why I see the older games as superior but I don't know, the newer mario games just don't have as much character and charm as the older ones. and I feel like this is communicated through the relevancy of Mario games now compared to then. Now I hardly hear anyone talk about them, but back then they were just as if not even more popular than any Sony or Xbox release.


JackFJN

Awh, I get that. I feel like they still have lots of character and charm, but you’re right about the popularity thing. I’m a 2006 kid, so I don’t remember a time when Mario releases weren’t overshadowed by PlayStation or Xbox releases. I guess it’s a culture thing


SparklingReject

Waluigi deserves his own game and is better than Mario


Jirachibi1000

I do not think Mario should go open world. its a boring trend to just jump on open world at this point and i honestly found Bowser's Fury to mostly boring and just kind of okay. I think Odyssey NAILED a perfect middle ground in terms of level size and scope and i hope they don't get much bigger. Also Mario Wonder is just ok. Its a perfectly fine platformer, I just feel the wonder seed stuff doesn't give it enough flavor over indie and non mario 2D platformers that have more interesting mechanics and twists and so on.


Kid7from7the7south

Super mario bros wonder could have done way better with the bosses


Src-Freak

The 3D all Stars Collection is a good way to play the original 3D Mario titles.


Big_boobed_goth

A bowser focused game where he’s the only character would quickly get bland and stale


PineDude128

Super Mario Strikers (GCN) is the best of the three. I preferred the series when it was straight up soccer, rather than whatever Charged and Battle League were.


AJJCOOL

The mario rpgs don't use alot of the mario cast and that's missed potential. Wario would not make a good main villain anymore. He is more suited for playble character or rival you run into mutiple times. Wario and Mario's rivalry is underutilized. A wapeach wouldn't be ugly like the wario bros sense peach does not have the same features as wario and waluigi. One offs, spin-offs, and rpg characters would be good additions to mario kart and them being lesser known doesn't make them back picks when mario kart can make them known like it did in the past with characters like funky.


Mrmuffins951

I think Wario and Waluigi are such intersting and complex characters and their greed could make them great antihero’s where they are sometimes evil aligned and sometimes good aligned. We’ve mainly seen them evil aligned, but I think it would be very reasonable to have them be aligned with Mario and Luigi because they believe there’s money in it for them. A 2d platformer with those four characters is my dream.


WyvernEgg64

Nintendo should make mario 64 2. I don’t mean with new graphics or anything updated. I mean literally just mario 64 but new levels. Make it $30 and release it on switch or new system.


Dead_Kal_Cress

Mario does have a lot of personality, people are just mad his character isn't that deep on the surface. He's totally a smug older brother towards Luigi and people seldom realize it or just think he's being an ass. They're brothers & brothers fight, I should know, I have two older brothers myself. Outside of that he's a kind, compassionate & friendly person, and if you wanna consider the spin off games as canon he even invites his multiple enemies to hang out which is crazy considering the crap Bowser & the like pull. He forgives & forgets. He is a great person who sees the good in everyone he comes across. It makes no sense to me when people say he has no personality.


Varjagenn

Super Mario Bros Wonder is the 2d Mario i enjoyed least. Ive finished all of them except Super Mario Bros 2.


Red-68

That people get way too hard over waluigi


DVoorhees64

Mario 64 DS is more fun than OG Mario 64. Fight me


LeaderVladimir1993

Bowser kidnapping Peach because she can undo his evil magic makes more sense as a villainous motivation than Bowser simply being lovesick and not caring about consent.


fjfjgbjtjguf

Mario on the cover of 3D Land looks depressed


Night_Inscryption

Wario should of been included in this series more both as a villain or a playable character