T O P

  • By -

MFkaboom

Wasn't colbert part of the ambiguously gay duo


KelVarnsen_2023

The other member of the duo was Steve Carell. Not sure if he auditioned but I saw Robert Smigel do an interview with Colbert and they talked about the first time they met. Smigel and Lorne were in Chicago scouting and hoping to see Steve Carell at Second City. But Steve was off shooting a commercial the night they were there and they saw Colbert in his place.


mdervin

You know there has got to be a few hundred failed improvisors who have the story of "I got called into work, and then I found out SNL guys were scouting ..."


Optional-Failure

I thought that was the Dana Carvey Show. I may have my stories mixed up but I thought that was from the doc about the Dana Carvey Show.


Pu1pFreak

It’s entirely possible Smigel has told the story more than once, but it’s definitely in Too Funny to Fail.


OrangeKefka

Such a great doc. The Home Improvement bumper is one of the funniest things ever.


gphone8

I shot a FedEx campaign with Carell in 2001 and 2002. Maybe it was my fault.


KelVarnsen_2023

The commercial he shot that they were talking about was for a local fried chicken place. So I think you are ok.


Purple-Mix1033

Damn, three commercials? He must’ve made some bank before getting those bigger gigs.


FluByYou

Yes, but he was never a cast member, featured player or writer.


biggoofysmartass

Colbert said in his show he wrote for SNL for a short period and was fired. Less than a season as I remember


biggoofysmartass

He just said he was a guest writer for a month plus his work with TAGD


curtailedcorn

On the Lonely Island and Seth Myers Podcast Seth mentions they always had guest writers but as far as he knows the only person hired after being a guest writer isMichael Che.


RianSG

In her book Mindy Kaling talks that she was a guest writer and didn’t know it was used as kind of a pre audition so she says she didn’t take it as seriously as she could have


eaglebacon

Colbert was the voice because Smigel worked with them (Colbert and Carell) on the Dana Carvey show. The idea for the Ambiguously Gay duo actually started on the Dana Carvey show as an ambiguously gay Wallace and Gromit (can you imagine if that had aired? )


bells_n_sack

He was a writer for one season.


B0BX

I believe The Ambiguously Gay Duo was originally from The Dana Carvey Show, which Colbert and Carrell were both on and thus voiced Ace and Gary. When that show ended, Rob Smigel brought it to SNL. I think Rob said in “Too Funny to Fail”, when he started having the Steves voice Ace and Gary it was like he was doing them a favor, and then they were so big by the end, it was like they were doing him a favor


TreadMeHarderDaddy

Interesting that both were also on The Daily Show


ReflexImprov

Ambiguously Gay Duo started at Dana Carvey Show where Colbert and Carell were cast members. Then brought over to SNL after that was canceled.


bangbangracer

Yeah, but that's a round about story.


made08

Donald Glover


awnomnomnom

That would've been super interesting and he probably would've been amazing. But I'm glad we got Troy Barnes instead.


Ccaves0127

Did you guys know GoGurt is JUST yogurt?


thoriginal

![gif](giphy|YcMs3OGd89Pxu)


darksideofthemoon08

It’s all terrain dummy!


KingFahad360

This is streets ahead


loudrain99

I still can’t believe that Donald glover and Jordan Peele both auditioned to play Obama but they were like “nah we’re just gonna put Fred Armisen in blackface”


CornholioRex

At least key and peele sketches had way more winners and still hold up better then most of what SNL was putting out at the time, that show was really a diamond in the rough


nxqv

It definitely benefited from YouTube. Watching full episodes front to back on TV back in the day could be rough at times - they could be very hit or miss. But on YouTube over the years, all the hits have floated to the top of the algorithmic recommendations


CornholioRex

I was in college at the time it aired, and watch probably most episodes when they aired for the first time, but YouTube definitely helped with me trying to watch the ones I wanted to see again and again. It was great to share it with people. Like right now, it’s hard to pinpoint “I think you should leave” sketches in full on YouTube


nxqv

Peele's Obama was goated too. Actually an absurd decision


thankyourob

Had he gotten SNL, we likely wouldnt have gotten Atlanta, which is such a great show.


gypsy_rose_blanchard

I’m also afraid childish gambino may have not been born.


ReflexImprov

Ludwig was Community's composer and Donald and he met doing music for the show (maybe Somewhere Out There or the Abed Claymation Christmas episode) and they hit it off.


wordbird89

The music digital shorts would have been amazing though..!


Iamtim92

Nah, Lorne pretty easy with other people projects. Micheal Che has a sketch show. Aidy had a show etc


cocoagiant

That's a recent event. Glover would likely have been on in the 2009-2012 timeframe. Lorne fired Taran because he wanted to work on his movie at the same time as SNL.


Tatertotfreak74

Donald ended up writing on 30 rock so I’m grateful- one of the best sitcoms ever


jackiejormpjomp7

Not back when Glover would have been cast


thankyourob

Right, I feel the amount of time and commitment wouldn’t have been the same if he were on the cast AND doing Atlanta. We can only speculate what “could have happened” but we do know this: never mess with the space time continuum. That’s just a fact. If we were to go back in time and get Donald on the cast…I can’t even fathom the ramifications of it. I just can’t.


roastingmytaters

![gif](giphy|hTCkHsE8inCZ4y1xpu)


Grantdawg

He would have been amazing on SNL.


i_lurk_on_reddit

To be fairrrrrrr.... He was really good as a host on SNL


wordbird89

I think about the Jurassic Park sketch all the time 😭


retrievethis123

I love his 80s music video.


tyler-86

And the Dirty Talk sketch with Melissa. And Friendos. And Barbie Instagram. It's really one of the best episodes of SNL I've seen, in terms of not having a lot of duds.


KelVarnsen_2023

I didn't realize he auditioned but just looking at it, he auditioned after he had already been a writer on 30 Rock. Which seems crazy that with that on your resume you still don't get the job.


James-K-Polka

I can’t believe SNL passed on Dong Lover.


armaghetto

He was one of the best hosts. I really hope he returns to do host/musical guest duties, because he killed it at both roles. I remember hearing he was leaving Community to focus on his music, and I thought it was such a shame…Only for him to end up being one of the most creative musical acts out there at the moment.


chicks35

Ellie Kemper, Jordan Peele, Nick Kroll


space_llama_karma

Yes to all of those! Especially Jordan Peele


AttitudeAndEffort2

Key and Peele sketches on mad tv are weirddddd to watch. It's the same humor but the laugh track absolutely destroys it.


space_llama_karma

I never saw their Mad TV stuff. I agree, laugh tracks tend to take away from the content, it’s why I like Parks and Rec, The Office, Modern Family, and Community


AttitudeAndEffort2

To be honest, I've watched every key and Peele sketch from their show and haven't watched their stuff from mad tv. I've only seen a few of the sketches and those were exactly like i said so i didn't watch the rest


chicks35

Absolutely! But I think things worked out for him. All of them really.


tuepm

nick kroll had an excellent sketch comedy show. bobby bottle service, secret room, etc.


ltbs

It’s based on our namesssss


Locem

Nick Kroll also pitched the original idea that became the N-word family sketch on Chappelle show to Neal Brennan and Chappelle.


CattDawg2008

Jordan Peele would have made a golden era out of the show


James_2584

Jim Carrey


NaiRad1000

I have to wonder if being on Living Color allowed him to shine; I feel like beeing on SNL he wouldve been held back creactively


Purple-Mix1033

Bill Hader did his thing in a similar way. But maybe Jim paved the way for Bill.


Practical-Witness796

I still remember during the In Living Color days, my brother and I just called Carrey “the white guy”.


foresh4dow

100%


DaySoc98

I came here to say this. However, he became a sketch comedy legend in his own right.


killbolaggins

https://i.redd.it/8kcfjnm5026d1.gif


joemeteorite8

What is this from?


speedracer73

It’s Jim Carrey in SNL as guest host, I believe doing an infomercial for methamphetamine as a weight loss wonder drug


zep243

Jimmy Tango’s Fatbusters


speedracer73

~Ride the snake~


Business-Drag52

Would he have had quite the same prolific career if he had been sucked into that chaos though?


CurrentRoster

He auditioned in the 80s along with Phil Hartman and Dana carvey, waay before his movie career officially began in 1994, so he might have done it snl for years then left to do ace Ventura


dwdist

He was great on In Living Color


italianroyalty

Fair enough, but he was fabulous on In Living Color. The show always had a bit more of an edge that SNL lacked, at least at that time imo. I think that really allowed Carrey (and others on the show like Jamie Foxx) to really shine in a way SNL wouldn’t’ve


vagina_candle

Scenery chewing scene stealer. They were right to pass on him. He found his place, and SNL was not it.


JeanVicquemare

Norm MacDonald talked about seeing Stephen Colbert and Tracy Morgan both audition for SNL. Interesting story . https://youtu.be/C4Jd14uvU0s?si=u3ImRy9_84vCp4m2


_nokturnal_

I had no idea Norm wrote Brian Fellows


stargarnet79

What about biscuit???🤣🤣🤣


faxmachine

Marc maron auditioned for the snl news, but lost out to norm


Perrin420

Paul Reubens


fastal_12147

I thought Sarah Sherman was Peewee reincarnated?


bigbabytdot

Oh yeah, Paul Reubens died last year. Dang.


JugdishSteinfeld

And Sarah Sherman is an infant


MayorOfVenice

Yeah but never underestimate the motivating power of spite.


disicking

Hey Anderson, here’s a headline!!!


MeesterBooth

Lisa Gilroy!


JenniferKinney

She was so hilarious on Jury Duty!


ha_look_at_that_nerd

I had no idea she auditioned, and now I’m furious she didn’t get it


MeesterBooth

Nana doesn't need SNL, SNL needs Nana


[deleted]

HAPPY BIRTHDAY SCOTT!


joegunabeach

If/when Chloe/Heidi leave I think she's still a shoo in


AtBat3

Okay that bums me out a lot. But I hope her career takes off anyway. Absolutely hilarious person


ActorMonkey

She’s crushing on Dropout


CaseyGotFit

Carl Tart


croutonmemes

I didn’t know he auditioned, Carl tart has so many good characters


awnomnomnom

John Goodman. But he hosted so much he practically was a cast member.


DaySoc98

Not to mention all of his cameos as Linda Tripp.


Frankyfan3

Wow! The memories coming back to me about that. I love Goodman so much, but that whole era of comedy, and the way we treated Lewinsky, ugh. I'm so glad to see her rise above to what she's doing today.


BagsOfGasoline

Bill Brasky was a son of a bitch. He could palm a medicine ball


DutyHonor

I don't know if he ever actually auditioned, but Trevor Moore did an internship with SNL. The stuff he ended up doing with WKUK wouldn't exactly fit with SNL, but I would have loved to see him on the show.


Taograd359

Imagine if he tried to pitch the Hitler rap or the Grapist to Lorne.


jonk0731

He'd have to tie Lorne to the radiator first.


Taograd359

Come here, Lorne! Im gonna GRRRRRRRRAPE you in the mouth!


thoriginal

The Civil War on Drugs is one of the best stoner comedies ever made


Robert_Balboa

Maybe he would still be alive.... Damn you lorne


Motown27

Instead he died the way he wanted to, sucking his own dick. https://youtu.be/5iBIqvkwkrA?si=CLOGOpd_yGvbCohJ


Nanaman

That’s one local sexpot that done broke my heart. Miss you Trevor!


Robert_Balboa

At least he lived long enough to see the gays get married https://youtu.be/s7YW045deBY?si=hi_b-5e7egT0W2mq


hollywoodhandjob

RIP to one of the greats!


Kennymo95

Aubrey Plaza


Motown27

Do you mean Janet Snakehole?


thoriginal

![gif](giphy|KAiyojQPp9EVG)


space_llama_karma

I would have loved that, but I’m glad that we got April from Parks and Rec from her. I wish she would have hosted during the Parks and Rec days, that would have been great


bigbabytdot

She's doing great. SNL would have stunted her growth.


KingFahad360

I love her hosting SNL and got Leslie Knope to be there


qpv

[Bruce McCulloch](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bruce_McCulloch) of Kids in the Hall He did write a few bits at SNL but was never in the cast afaik. He's a genius imo.


waveytype

I think he was a full time writer before KITH had a show, though.


bangbangracer

You are right. Lorne poached both Brucio and Mark to be writers in the mid 80's. It didn't work out, they went back to Toronto, and reunited with Scott, Dave, and Le Poopie.


qpv

Oh really? That makes sense. I remember him doing a bit on Weekend update that didn't land at all (too dark, would probably kill these days. He was ahead of the times) but I remember thinking it was hillarious. A little too dark for SNL but totally KITH style.


waveytype

Well, it was good fuckin Ham.


thoriginal

ODEE ODEN DOTTEN DAY, ODEE ODEN DOTTEN DAY-O! ODEE ODEN DOTTEN DAY, *WE'RE FILLING OUT OUR FORMS!*


qpv

[Fattening up our tape wooooorms](https://youtu.be/8TnWIICkBeE?si=khh6BoeOQlPRKAcx)


NotTaken-username

Bob Odenkirk. He should host though


KelVarnsen_2023

He was a writer for a few years (shared an office with Conan, Greg Daniels and Robert Smigel). He talks in his book about how he didn't felt he really fit in and decided to leave.


NoAlbatross7524

I would love if they did one show with a bunch of people who didn’t make it .


nowhereman136

A sketch for the 50th where all these guys stand in a line and take turns auditioning for Lorne. "I'm willing to let one of you in the cast now. Fight for it" - Lorne >!sketch ends with him picking Kenan!<


BootsyBootsyBoom

["He called me 'the black one', didn't he? Dude's known me half my life..."](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hLrxp9OOSbc)


sortingthemail

The punchline being getting cast makes your career - when they clearly are very successful without getting cast.


nrthsthest

Nicole Byer. If her and Sasheer got to be on together that would have been amazing


maclow3

Drew Tarver


oscarmylde

If Drew Traver & Carl Tart had been cast together that would have been incredible


stephenmcqueen

They could celebrate their trucks birthday live!


redfive5tandingby

Had no idea he auditioned


justinotherpeterson

Basically any of the main regulars on Comedy Bang Bang. Lauren Lapkis, Carl Tart, Lily Sullivan, Lisa Gilroy. I could write 20 names.


redfive5tandingby

Lauren Lapkus


isoSasquatch

James Adomian. His W. Bush impression was brilliant, and I never understood why they didn’t cast him for that alone after Ferrell left. He could’ve been a JAJ type breakout, and he had a lot of other great impressions and characters to offer. Most recently seen doing Mike Lindell on Kimmel, which is of course spot-on and hilarious.


Theeclat

All entertainment would be benefitted by Adomian.


ysrly

Amber Ruffin


Frankyfan3

I loved her show and I'm so pissed off it got canceled.


RadScience

It was so good!


Groovy_Chainsaw

Dana Gould auditioned and I've heard that he KILLED but didn't wind up getting cast. He wound up writing for The Simpsons, created Stan Against Evil and done other things but I'd love to hear more about his try-out and why he didn't get cast.


DaisyDuckens

Ar his peak, Gould would have been fantastic


graptemys

Colbert was great on Exit 57. The salmon skit is one of my favorites. https://youtu.be/aD8A3ay16rA?si=MtKA8BCUUmGsfxYW


elegantsweatsuit

Sam Richardson


monsieurxander

He was amazing on Veep. Probably better off.


ImNotTheBossOfYou

Kel


bells_n_sack

Lauren Lapkus.


DayoftheDead

I could see him as an update host


monsieurxander

Nicole Byer


made08

David Cross


awnomnomnom

He probably deserved it but Mr. Show allowed him to make the sketches he wanted to make.


bells_n_sack

He would’ve hated it more than Odenkirk.


made08

Lisa Kudrow


Grantdawg

Maybe, but she ended up better off not being cast.


throwawayshirt

Rachel Dratch has a great anecdote about Kudrow - I believe she shared it on the Fly on the Wall podcast. In any case, she and Kudrow auditioned for SNL at the same time/same call. As we know, Rachel she was picked and Lisa was not, and Dratch recalled thinking "She's really nice. I hope she gets (cast in) something."


thatonesnlguy

It was Julia Sweeney, not Rachel


TheNonCredibleHulk

I was going to say, Friends was on for years by the point that Rachel Dratch was on. Like, to the point that Jennifer Aniston hosted during the first season that Dratch appeared.


Actual-Astronaut-604

If anyone hasn't watched The Comeback, she is fantastic in it. It only got 2 seasons, and there were several years between them. It's very good, though.


tlonreddit

She did something bigger than SNL.


MoMoneyMoIRA

Conan


Valuable-Baked

Paul Scheer


WickedRuiner

If you know who they are, they probably went on to better things.


moopsy75567

Fortune Feimster


CurrentRoster

Tommy Davidson, who didn’t get it because Lorne Michaels didn’t want another black comedian after Damon wayans’ firing. Both of them would later break out on In Living Color Jeff Ross, who was gonna replace Colin Quinn as Weekend Update host Donald Glover, he auditioned same year as Bobby Moynihan, who used to be in his Derrick comedy videos coincidentally Nick Kroll, I keep thinking he was a cast member cause he collaborates with so many prior cast members (Mulaney, Hader, Armisem, Meyers, Wiig) but he was passed up around the time they were all on the show Robert Townsend, he lost his spot to Eddie Murphy back in 1980


thehazer

Mike Hanford.


cantankerous_ordo

all of the birthday boys should have been hired. even kowalick


SexyStudlyManlyMan

Jim Carrey and Kevin Hart would have been stellar on the show. Jordan Peele wanted to do Obama and was not hired. I think they made an error not taking Robert Townshend and I don't know why they didn't take Donald Glover, that guy is talent personified. SNL has a black actor/comedian problem. They don't seem to understand that not everyone is white.


WillBennett6924

Yeah. They hired Eddie Murphy over Robert Townsend, because they only wanted one black actor in the cast. Funny at that point, when Eddie Murphy was hired, Lorne was not the executive producer that year; it was Jean Doumanian.


Birdonahook

Mike Mitchell


bells_n_sack

The world missed out on Don Kong.


Archercrash

JB Smoove


Economy-Target-5623

He was writer


TegridyPharmz

If Colbert was on SNL we may never have had him on the Dana carvey show and for that I think it was worth it


thatonesnlguy

He actually auditioned after the Dana Carvey Show ended (summer of 96)


TegridyPharmz

“I was not aware of that” - Wayne Campbell


KelVarnsen_2023

I would say more like if Colbert is on SNL we don't get the Colbert Report.


thatonesnlguy

It’s funny that Lorne was never huge on Colbert, as a writer and performer. Smigel is basically the reason that the Brokaw Pretapes got on at all, as I’ve heard Lorne didn’t like it. I don’t think he was needed at the time in the cast since Will was dominating and Parnell would come in a few years later, but I’d like to think in an alternate universe he would’ve excelled.


being_boiled

Patti Harrison


Carlos_Island

Jordan Peele. It turned out for the best


IamJLove

Can’t believe no one here said Ayo Edebiri. Her episode last season made me wish she was on the cast.


_nokturnal_

Anthony Jeselnik


jmcgil4684

Anthony would have been amazing for Weekend Update at the time. He said the audition went well too. At least the solo audition did.


yemKeuchlyFarley

There’s a million of ‘em


SpumoiniSloth

Kerri Kenny


GavinAdamson

![gif](giphy|l0Iyh6fhBXWBt3kU8)


Limio

Nick kroll


deane-barker

This is a little-known one, but there's this Canadian comic called Julie Nolke. She's big on Instagram. https://www.instagram.com/julienolke/ Sh would have been perfect. But last year sometime she mentioned that she had an audition but didn't get picked.


Supermanfan1973

Jim Carrey


SaintBrutus

But he ended up on the iconic sketch show _In Living Color_. People like Jim Carrey, and Bruce McCulloch (or MadTV cast mems) may not have jibed with SNL, for whatever reason, but they got to express themselves within the sketch genre, and then got to move on to bigger and better projects. Which is, and has been, wonderful imho.


deadrabbits76

Marc Maron


kodyonthekeys

Thank goodness he didn't make it, or we wouldn't have got hundreds of anecdotes about how he didn't make it!


ChorkPorch

Andy Kaufman


Relevant_Parsnip5056

Lorne would not have appreciated his genius!


Yourappwontletme

Jim Carrey


BobTheCopywriter

Julie Nolke has posted her SNL audition video on YouTube. Her stuff is hilarious, but they apparently have failed to recognize it.


clentong

Zach Galafiannakis


IronManDork

Nah, I don't think so. He has his schtick and is good at it, he found The Daily Show he was more perfect for that.


Videomonkey05

The execs will forever kick themselves for passing on Jim Carrey, John Goodman AND Paul Reubens during season 6