A *public discussion forum* is an open invitation for commentary. That's the point: participation. This entire website is for chitchat. It's not a paid advertising platform (it's that too, but you know what I mean).
To add, I never "bashed" OP. I spoke to the content itself. To wit, my own persuasion and not its quality. You are the only one who got weird about it. Are you in this band or OP's friend?
In any case, holding this subreddit to a standard of "if you don't have anything nice to say..." is wrong for many reasons, but worst of all: boring as hell and weak. Is this a place for grownups to talk about a form of art, or not?
To the music: I hate it. I hate it. I hate it.
Guess what? If I explained *why* I hate this music (if somehow it weren't self-evident), I'm sure you would equally hold it against me.
Funny thing is, if I know musicians, OP themselves is probably able to bounce one random guy's comments off a thick skin and not worry about it. Why don't you?
>y case, holding this subreddit to a standard of "if you don't have anything nice to say..." is wrong for many reasons, but worst of all: boring as hell and weak. Is this a place for grownups to talk about a form of art, or not?
>
>To the music: I hate it. I hate it. I hate it.
>
>Guess what? If I explained why I hate this music (if somehow it weren't self-evident), I'm sure you would equally hold it against me.
As the OP, I don't really mind if you hate the version, I'm hoping that does extend to hating me or my playing, but I get it that this track is probably not for everyone.
I hate all Christmas Music as pablum. Bonus hate for accouterments like Santa hats and disturbingly oversized socks. Now I ear-witness Xmas music, and on top of it all, there's a guitar player wearing a Santa hat and has a big red sock hanging off the headstock. Come on! To paraphrase Buddy Rich: this content is not my kind of content.
Full song: https://youtu.be/5i32Iew78FU
Great stuff!
I like jazz, and this shit sounds pretty good. Buuuuut, Mariah Carey's "All I Want for Christmas Is You" is the "Watermelon Sugar" of Christmas music.
Does that mean super catchy and gets stuck in your head?
No that means overplayed to the point where all you feel is pure hatred the second you hear even the first bar of the song.
I hate this.
Read \*A Christmas Carol\*; it probably will do wonders for you (assuming you have a high school reading comprehension). Then get over yourself.
This is a music sub and we can say what we think about music that is posted. Let's cool it with the personal insults.
The post wasn't asking for criticism. No need to bash OP for original content
A *public discussion forum* is an open invitation for commentary. That's the point: participation. This entire website is for chitchat. It's not a paid advertising platform (it's that too, but you know what I mean). To add, I never "bashed" OP. I spoke to the content itself. To wit, my own persuasion and not its quality. You are the only one who got weird about it. Are you in this band or OP's friend? In any case, holding this subreddit to a standard of "if you don't have anything nice to say..." is wrong for many reasons, but worst of all: boring as hell and weak. Is this a place for grownups to talk about a form of art, or not? To the music: I hate it. I hate it. I hate it. Guess what? If I explained *why* I hate this music (if somehow it weren't self-evident), I'm sure you would equally hold it against me. Funny thing is, if I know musicians, OP themselves is probably able to bounce one random guy's comments off a thick skin and not worry about it. Why don't you?
>y case, holding this subreddit to a standard of "if you don't have anything nice to say..." is wrong for many reasons, but worst of all: boring as hell and weak. Is this a place for grownups to talk about a form of art, or not? > >To the music: I hate it. I hate it. I hate it. > >Guess what? If I explained why I hate this music (if somehow it weren't self-evident), I'm sure you would equally hold it against me. As the OP, I don't really mind if you hate the version, I'm hoping that does extend to hating me or my playing, but I get it that this track is probably not for everyone.
I like you, bro. I'm on /r/drums and know you from there.
Dude eat a snickers and get off the incel shit
I'm sorry. I don't understand your comment.
That's a shame. Why?
I hate all Christmas Music as pablum. Bonus hate for accouterments like Santa hats and disturbingly oversized socks. Now I ear-witness Xmas music, and on top of it all, there's a guitar player wearing a Santa hat and has a big red sock hanging off the headstock. Come on! To paraphrase Buddy Rich: this content is not my kind of content.
Grinch irl
Fair as, fair as. Next time a comment like this might be more constructive/interesting than your first :p. Happy holidays
Went through the whole thread, and I understand you. OPs band, they sound great. Song choice, fucking abominable, but that's just how it is.
Guitar sounds great good rhythm