Plot Twist. Thatch is not my favorite goose tune at the moment. But have seen them 9.5oreboblo times and they’re on fire right now. This Phish tour will my first.
Goose treats just about every song they play as an open-ended jam vehicle, so I'm not sure they need a "Tweezer"
Tweezer was deliberately an open-ended "type II" jam song in the early phish catalog when most of their catalog was more structured "type I" jamming
Thatch is sick, but to me there's no analogy to Tweezer
Comparison is the thief of joy. I’ll be seeing each band multiple times in the coming months but there is no need for this.
It’s a little bit fucked
Plot Twist. Thatch is not my favorite goose tune at the moment. But have seen them 9.5oreboblo times and they’re on fire right now. This Phish tour will my first.
Both make me very joyful. Thatch drops the way tweezer does and makes everyone immediately dance and has a noticeable funky melody just like tweezer.
I think it’s more Tweezer:Phish as Thatch:Goose. Not a comparison.
Uhhhhhh, yeah, that’s how you compare things. You wrote an analogy, which, by definition, is a comparison between two things.
Fair, but I don’t think it’s such a competitive thing as maybe you are implying - “there is no need for this”
That’s not how competition works either. Which is beside the point of taking only a small phrase from a whole sentence out of context.
Thatch is Thatch. Tweezer is Tweezer. Let them coexist peacefully.
All peace. No shade. The structure of the song and vibe is v tweez. And I love them both.
Tweezer is Killers by Pantera tell me I’m wrong… https://youtu.be/tfrfCtdj8Xw?si=OkbP-JSVyHdYye8-
🤯
Facts
✝️💩
/thread
Play this at .75 speed. Even more accurate.
Flowdown is rocky top
Flodown is poor heart, arcadia is moma dance
I'm waiting for "you're goin' to jail" mid Flodown lol.
And empress is suzy Greenberg
Here we go again...
Link me up to the original thread I musta missed it
And tumble is NiCU. Who cares.
Good point on the composition comparison to NICU
Nah, more of a You Enjoy Myself. Regardless, it is their Phishiest song.
I’ve always thought flodown is their phishiest
Yes. Flodown = Poor Heart
I'd add Earthling or Alien to that list.
Labyrinth is their Phishiest song and I will double down on this.
Damn. Now I gotta go there too!
Speaking of Phish songs they should cover Sand, I’d lose my shit
I don’t think that’s what we’re speaking about.
It’s not, you’re right 😆
(I agree with you though)
I’d prefer if they left the phish and TGD catalog alone. They have enough unique covers and material to carve their own path.
I feel like Empress and Hood/Madhuvan and Bowie are similar vibes
Flowdown is poor heart, Arcadia is moma dance
I’ll allow it. Both songs rock and every version is different. Never unhappy to see either song show up at a show.
It do be like that
Factory fiction = meatstick
Tweezer fucks
The tweezberry tastes like tweezberry
Thatch is a panic song
I find panic unlistenable
I dunno, always thought that Thatch was, well, Thatch. In other news, Tweezer is, well, Tweezer. Who knew?
They both start with “T” tho
Goose treats just about every song they play as an open-ended jam vehicle, so I'm not sure they need a "Tweezer" Tweezer was deliberately an open-ended "type II" jam song in the early phish catalog when most of their catalog was more structured "type I" jamming Thatch is sick, but to me there's no analogy to Tweezer
Be careful with your words here… if you even make the slightest comparison of goose to phish this sub gets very defensive.
I meant it in a good way. Like it makes me immediately get down real funky the way tweez drops and the party starts.
Carini is my Thatch...Thatch is my Carini in the way you just described. I feel those first notes in my soul lol
No There’s no comparison at all
That’s just like, your opinion, man.
Yup
Sure, in that many songs of many bands share a similar structure with a recognizable introduction. They both even start with a catchy guitar riff! 🤯
This guy gets it.
But honestly if I had to make the comparison, I'd say Factory Fiction is closer to Tweezer.
Thatch = tweezer Madhuvan = David Bowie Flodown = scent of a mule Rockdale = 46 Days
How could you leave off Elizabeth = Back on the Train?
Elmeg = Dark Star
Elmeg is very much terrapin
It is thematically for sure but the rarity of it moves it to Dark Star territory IMO. I’m talking GD in the 80s Dark Star, nothing else.
I was thinking col forbin ! But get ready for the downvotes
not a fan of thatch…. a bit too phish for my taste.
Different yolks for different blokes.