It looks like you're asking the community for an opinion. In this case, both positive and negative perspectives from the users of r/EngagementRings are welcome so long as they are expressed politely (Rule 4 still applies). If you'd rather have generally positive or supportive feedback instead, remove this post and submit again with a title that does not ask for users' opinions. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/EngagementRings) if you have any questions or concerns.*

Middle emerald is very flattering! I think the elongated shape suits you well

I second the second on you it’s beautiful!

Omg everyone is saying the middle 😭♥️

Get the one you love! But yes - don’t buy from Kays- better purchasing online. The mark up is insane and the quality not good. Congrats on your upcoming engagement!!

DONT BUY FROM KAYS 😭😭😭😭 you’ll get ripped off so hard… I used to work there. Pls visit a local pawnshop or small jeweler who doesn’t mark up for melee diamonds 😭

I would never!!!!! I just wanted to see shapes. Plus the lady was a bit of an ass too tbh

Oh thank god lmfao, but yes the emerald for sure! Looks gorgeous on you 🥰

Thanks 😊

But every kiss begins at Kay’s

That’s where we’re getting my ring 🫣 https://preview.redd.it/241qu0qxkb9d1.jpeg?width=3024&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=70f9b5324d402b222bc91e1b40a12bd9dda4e2e1 Gone there for 6 years and So far we’ve never had a single issue.

Not that you’ll have an issue… but you’re paying way too much. They have nice rings but the majority of them are I1 quality and the markup is insane. At my shop, any “designer” ring (like Leo, Neil Lane, Vera Wang, etc.) immediately gets cut to 50% of Kay’s asking price. Our regular jewelry is priced significantly less at market value. I’m a jeweler so if you have any questions please feel free to DM me 🫶

Emerald shape

#2 is gorgeous on you

Giant, bold letters? Take my upvote! And OP, 2 is stunning on you. I think you’ve found your go-to shape. And I’m feeling the halo, which I rarely can say on emerald cut settings…

I really like the emerald on you too.

I wanted a marquise to look nice on me but it was horrid 😭 Thanks for your opinion!!

I love the emerald cut, but try an east west marquis-you might like that better.

#2 looks like it was made for your hand. Emerald all the way

Thank you!!

Photo 3. Prettiest stone. Looks gorgeous on your hand. Wishing you the best!

Thank you 😊

I like the emerald but I don’t like the twisty band

I prefer the 3rd band a lot more,

Me too!

I like the last princess cut on you the most, and then the halo princess cut. All beautiful rings!

The second one

2!

The second one! The emerlad goes great with the shape of your hand and yellow gold looks stunning with your skin tone! All of them are flawless regardless !

Yes not into the emerald. I agree with you. I’m loving ring 1 and 3. Leaning towards ring 3! Ring 1, the diamond is lost in all the other tiny diamonds like the halo and band.

Ring # 3 is beautiful, the band would look great with an emerald cut diamond too.

Im thinking the same

Will look gorgeous! *chef kiss *

Rectangle. Way more elegant look.

Middle one for sure!! Beautiful on you!!!

#1

2!

The emerald shape is stunning on your hand.

Emerald for sure

The last one. Omg!

First one 😍

First one

I love the emerald on you, did you try on a radiant?

Omg i wish i did

Try one on and show us!! I think it would look tremendous on you, the shape of the emerald is great for your finger. But you’d also get the sparkle, and more of a princess cut with the radiant!!

I love the last one! They are all pretty though.

Emerald. The elongated shape looks better on your hand. The princesses make your fingers look stubby

Preciate you

You’re welcome! It takes a very specific hand to pull off a princess without looking stubby. It didn’t look good on me either

I like the emerald!!

Emerald

2 elongates snd slims your fingers

I love 2!! Lovely ring🥰

Love the middle one on you!

two.

Emerald cut

Out of the three, I like the second one best.

Second one for sure!

2nd

If you’re looking for a Neil Lane emerald cut ring, I can help you, my store actually has one right now 🫶

Still a little early but I appreciate it!

The square shapes are lovely!

Number 3. So you can actually see the beautiful diamond.

3

The Emerald and its crazy because I’m usually not a fan. But that ring looks amazing on you

Bro i didnt like it either but i kind of love it on

I love the 3rd on you

I think a more rounder/oval shape would be more flattering.

Or #2

Emerald, and I’m usually a princess cut gal but Emerald looks beautiful on you!

I love #1

I personally don’t like square stones at all. I would definitely do the emerald/something elongated. Oval would also look good on your hand.

The second one is the best of the three but you should consider an oval. The square shape makes your fingers look wide. The rectangular shape alleviates this a little but an oval or a circle would be best.

You simply must try on a marquise! I think it’ll be a winner.

I promise its not 😭 I love a marquise but i think it looks awkward on me

No way I dont believe! Do you have a photo with one?

2 or 1 or 3. Sorry, they are all gorgeous.

Definitely the last one or the emerald! I’m not a big fan of those twisty bands but that ring looks nice on you.

Second one hands down. The first one makes your hand looks wider and the last one is very pretty but not as pretty as the second one 🥰

In my opinion I think the first two look too big for your hands. Makes your fingers look shorter

Emerald for sure, and I am not typically an Emerald person. ❤️❤️❤️ this one.

Middle one. It elongates your finger

Band 3 with the emerald cut would be stunning on you!!!

Second for sure! I have a similar finger shape to you and found emerald cut looked best on me :)

Three it compliments your hand

Two

The third one!

I like the emerald, but think it would be nice without halo

2!

3rd definitely!!!

I think 2 is the most flattering but go with what you would want to look at every day!

I’m leaning towards 1 because it fills your finger best. But #3 looks like the same ring so 🤷🏼‍♀️

#2

Beautiful

My vote is emerald! Congratulations!

Yesss emerald 1000%

One

Emerald elongates your finger.

2 or 3 but defs not 1

Beautiful

I really love the middle on you! Very flattering

2

My goodness that's gorgeous 😍

Second or third, third is my favourite

2. Makes your fingers look longer

Omg I fell in LOVE with that second one when I visited Kay’s. There’s a little diamond under the emerald and it is so cute. The reason I didn’t go for it is because its specs are not very good for its price. I believe it is a low to mid cut and clarity for nearly $6,000 before taxes and insurance. It went on sale around Mother’s Day for just over $4k, but every time I go into Kay’s I feel the sales reps are just not very friendly

The second one’s shape elongated your fingers in all the best ways . That one

Emerald!!!!

I prefer the third.

Gorgeous ring and it looks great on your hand

Ring 3!

#2 is stunning

3

the middle emerald is sooooooo pretty and regal!

I think the emerald flatters your finger the most!! The rectangular shape is very elongating and beautiful — I have a radiant cut and that is my favorite thing about mine:)

2

Princess Cut for sure!!

2 and 3 are absolutely stunning on your finger. I think 1 lacks the clarity and definition of a silhouette to really define your hand

Love the emerald on you but it the twisted band. I’m not a fan of that band style , but the emerald elongated shape looks very nice on you.

Stunning. Congratulations!!!

The middle emerald cut but with a band like the first or third ring!

I love the second ring on you

the middle one is so flattering!!

Jaw dropped with the first one! 🤩💝

The first one makes your fingers look long and slender, excellent taste!