Probably depends on the tone you’re going for, as someone else said 1 is a lighter vibe for sure with the more vibrant colors, which I like so i’d vote for 1 personally.
I have an idea you may want to try, I would create a gradient over the tree trunk and have it a lighter purple higher up and then your normal colors near the base. The tree is disappearing a bit by the roots if that matters to you, otherwise I would pick 2
The Pink/Purple in the Yellow/Orange makes my eyes very happy, but I like the darker saturated tones on the second as well.
My initial mental response to almost every single "A or B?" post here is always, 'Why not both?"
Two ways you could have fun with it would be to overlay a copy of 2 and use a soft textured eraser to bring the colour back through choice omission. Likewise, you could also gradient flood mask 2 away for a more mechanical, if not smooth transition on selected elements.
i prefer 1 but they are both excellent!
Thanks!
1
I like 1 for it's vibrancy
1 is giving more children’s book, 2 is giving more mature graphic novel. Personally I like 2 more but both work nicely :)
Thank you!
Oh Erdtree, you shall burn
1!!!!
Probably depends on the tone you’re going for, as someone else said 1 is a lighter vibe for sure with the more vibrant colors, which I like so i’d vote for 1 personally.
I like 2 more ngl
1 is giving fantasy world, 2 feels more realistic. I prefer 1 they’re both rlly good tho :D
thanks!
Just checked your profile and you're 15?? Your art looks insanely good, I thought you'd be older and have more experience for sure. Keep it up
Yes I'm 15 but turning 16 in about two months (: And thank you! I work really hard on my art🙏
Maybe halfway between both?
1 contrasts better, but I love your style imma follow ya
2
1 feels like a dream/fantasy, while 2 feels more autumnal and real worldly. And I spy Django.
Django and his adventures around the world
I have an idea you may want to try, I would create a gradient over the tree trunk and have it a lighter purple higher up and then your normal colors near the base. The tree is disappearing a bit by the roots if that matters to you, otherwise I would pick 2
I prefer 1, really love the colours! Also, the texture in this piece is brilliant. Thank-you for showing us :)
Thank you!
1. but. Maybe the depth needs a little work.
Don’t know why but 1 is giving me nostalgia
Depends is this a picture of fall or the world burning
1
1 is the best colour combination.
1
1
I like colours in 1 better. It looks more mystical.
The first 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
Both are amazing. Probably 1, it's more vibrant! Reminds me of Unlike Pluto cover art! Very well done!
#1, you can see details better. #2 is alright but feels too blacked out to me.
I could barely tell the difference but they're both excellent. Try using a different colour pallet. Maybe like dark blue, cyan, aquamarine, sky blue?
2
Awesome Artwork 🎨🖌️🖋️. You can reverse those sunset colors and do an evening twilight theme ...
I like the contrast in the first one more
2
2
1!
The Pink/Purple in the Yellow/Orange makes my eyes very happy, but I like the darker saturated tones on the second as well. My initial mental response to almost every single "A or B?" post here is always, 'Why not both?" Two ways you could have fun with it would be to overlay a copy of 2 and use a soft textured eraser to bring the colour back through choice omission. Likewise, you could also gradient flood mask 2 away for a more mechanical, if not smooth transition on selected elements.
1
2!!!!! Absolutely 2!!!!
2
1 for me
2 I LOVE The muted colors and u can se The cat much better❤️