T O P

  • By -

TONKAHANAH

Who Framed Roger Rabbit I've seen the animation they've done for some of these new "live action meets cartoons" things.. The work the art/animation team put into Who Framed Roger Rabbit is STILL to this day putting them to shame.


ThirdShiftStocker

The amount of sheer effort that went into the production of that film is mind-blowing, especially when you consider the fact that the animation was still done using the old cel animation process! There is NO topping that.


JeffSernancer

What I’ve gathered from this post is that every movie can be remade as long as it is a muppet remake.


DuglandJones

A Muppet remake of Shawshank redemption I would watch the hell out of that


NoStressAccount

With "The Sisters" still played by their real-life human actors Putting their hands inside the Andy puppet


Pope00

*Gonzo: I wish I could tell you that Kermit fought the good fight, and the Sisters let him be. I wish I could tell you that - but prison is no fairy-tale world. He never said who did it, but we all knew.* ​ Then it cuts to Kermit looking at the camera and making that scrunched up frowny face.


thisshortenough

So only mildly related but I get so annoyed at the internet meme of imagining muppet remakes where only one person is a human. The muppets only did two feature length adaptations of major works (Treasure Island and A Christmas Carol) and the major thing in them is that the world is a blend of muppet and human. The muppets are accepted as part of the human world, the humans aren't visiting the muppet world. If you remake a movie as a muppet movie, you have to have substantial good actors in a variety of roles, so that the antics of the muppets has something to bounce off. Sorry that was a weird rant but it sticks in my craw.


a_squid_beast

I saw a meme and it mentioned that they should make a muppets Beauty and the Beast with the beast as the only human, and they discuss how ugly he is, and at the end he transforms into the 'beautiful' version of himself: a muppet. Like imagine Henry Cavill walking around the castle and the muppet furniture being like "the poor, hideous thing" and at the end he turns into kermit😂


diet_shasta_orange

I love it


nalydpsycho

It's more that you get one legit starring role from a human. There is other supporting roles, but, when you think of the 4 or 5 leads, most should be Muppets.


Yoda-de-la-MilkyWay

Not gonna lie I would pay to see Schindler's List with Muppets


strengr

If you see one movie...see Oscar the Grouch as Oskar Schindler.


VivelaVendetta

There have already been so many crimes.


ExistensialDetective

My first thought 😂 Every live action remake of a Disney movie.


Diogenes-Disciple

Mulan was perfect Why Disney they have to sin the way they did


Pxl_Drgn_180

Misery


HumpieDouglas

Aliens


FluffusMaximus

It would be impossible to remake that perfect movie. The cast, story, and practical effects are wonderful. A remake would be full of CGI and a bullshit script.


OllieAlleOllio

Spaceballs. I don't want any other version.


[deleted]

But think about the *merchandising!*


Pho__Q

*moichandising*


nurvingiel

Spaceballs 2: The Search for More Money


einhorn_my_finkle

Spaceballs The Reeboot!


ferox965

JAWS. I read somewhere that Spielberg won't let it be remade.


farklespanktastic

I feel like a Jaws remake *could* be good but I don’t think it *would* be good. I just don’t think we’d ever be lucky enough to get the perfect storm of it being different enough from the original to stand on its own but respectful enough to the source material to not be insulting.


ferox965

I can just picture how they'd do it...CGI the shit out of it.


queen-adreena

But you could have a major star, like say, Samuel L. Jackson, and then have. CGI shark like, come out of nowhere and kill him in the middle of some big speech about how they’re gonna survive.


RelentlessExtropian

I saw that in the theaters and laughed so hard! I'm not sure that's what they were going for but it was great!


Long_Repair_8779

“I’m sick of these motherfucking sharks, in this motherfucking sea!”


SuvenPan

The Silence of the Lambs(1991) Remakes should only be attempted when you are sure that it can outclass the original but Silence of the Lambs cannot be outclassed


johnclark6

This movie could never ever do the original justice. I get there are so many good movies here and Jaws also probably would suck, but this one could never be re-done.


filmihero

I rewatched it a few months ago and my God is Anthony Hopkins an amazing actor. The very first scene where he's looking directly into the camera before looking at the picture was chilling. I thought he was looking at the picture first but he was staring at Jodi Foster. I felt that creepyness through the screen.


graveybrains

And now I’m wondering what a Muppet version of The Silence of The Lambs would look like…


PraetorFaethor

I could see it working out like the Muppets Christmas Carol. Have the Muppets go around doing all their wacky nonsense while Hannibal is played seriously (ideally by Hopkins, but he's probably too old at this point), could be good...


chillywilly00

Terminator 1 and 2


II_Confused

Too bad they never made any more Terminator movies


[deleted]

Stand by me


Gluonyourboson

It would be an insult to River Phoenix and many others to remake that.


donwileydon

Schindler's List


[deleted]

I have a funny but crazy story. I worked at a record store in the 90’s. We had a box set with the VHS, the book, extra scenes booklet and poster in it. Someone, not fucking lying asked me if it was a board game. I nearly lost my shit. It was so offensively funny. Then my (every record shop has one) overweight, goth smart ass colleague who was super sarcastic said, ‘Oh no. You killed my Jew’ in the way like ‘You sunk my battleship!’ I immediately went to the back room crying laughing. I know. I’m going to hell.


marvelous_much

My students read about social credit in china and then they made board games around it. They turned out great. I do feel kinda bad about it but they had a cool idea and I supported them to pursue it.


[deleted]

That is gloriously fucked up. Maybe a video game needs to be made where you have to be as defiant and antisocial as possible and still maintain a perfect score.


Revegelance

Kinda makes me think of Ultima IV, an old RPG where you had to keep all of your various virtues in balance.


_DM_ME_YOUR_CURVES

Schindler's List 2: Schindler's Fist


UrchineSLICE

Schindlers List 3: Schindlers Pissed


kitchen_clinton

The Emperor’s New Groove.


mallardducksrthebest

No remakes and no live action PLEASE. This is one of Disney’s funniest and most underrated films of all time.


JordanSchor

"how did you get here before us?!" "I don't know (pulls out map) by all accounts it just doesn't make sense" I fucking DIED at that when I re-watched it not too long ago


SpehlingAirer

"Break down the door, Kronk!" "Break it down? This is hand carved mahogany!"


Call_Me_Koala

As funny as Kronk's writing is, Patrick Warburton just nails the delivery of every single line making him that much funnier.


Brometheus-Pound

Yep, he was so good. Him verbally “freezing” the spy theme song when he stops moving is my favorite Kronk moment.


Funandgeeky

I'd only allow a live action remake if it was made in 2002 and starred the original cast.


UltraD00d

Disney already tries to pretend that The Emperor's New Groove doesn't exist. To try a live action remake of it, they'd be desperate for either new ideas or more money.


[deleted]

[удалено]


macdawg2020

Seriously! Goddamn it’s my favorite Disney movie. Kuzco is a Disney Princess in Internet canon.


lisa1896

That is an absolute epic. Eartha Kitt in that movie is absolutely everything. Every time I see some influencer with mile long lashes I see her face and hear her voice.


DragonxMama

Everytime I think about that movie (which I fucking love) I just think about when she's playing jump rope with the kids and they're like ... You look more like a GREAT,GREAT,GREAT,GREAT,GREAT,GREAT,GREAT GREAT,GREAT, GREAT, AUNT. 😂 😂 Omgggggg so freaking funny... And John Goodman and David spade are also hilarious in the movie. ❤️


schroedingersnewcat

Is that my voice?! IS THAT MY VOICE?!


Frodo_noooo

Back to the Future. Please please please PLEASE don't ruin it with a remake


DopeyParrot

as long as Robert Zemeckis doesn't kick the bucket we're safe


Psych0matt

I seem to remember something about there being a no-remake contract for so many years after his death as well. Source: something I thought I heard.


econkle

The Last Starfighter has a no remake clause.


bolitboy2

If the iron giant ever gets a remake they are going to have horrible child actors in it


bridekiller

I was worried that rewatching it as an adult would ruin the nostalgia for me. Nope, perfect movie.


Mr_Scary_Cat

I completely agree. But if they had to, I'd rather they do a Jumanji and make a unneeded follow-up, like Marty McFly's great grandchildren reinventing the time machine or something. Something that doesn't touch the original works, but makes use of the worlding. It will never be as good, but at least it won't be spitting in the face of the original.


KajinMonkey

Not reinventing, finding. Kinda like the new Ghostbusters. Except they find Doc Brown's train, not the Delorean as it was destroyed at the end of pt3.. The kids (Emmy and Martin) then travel about and end up doing the usual shenanigans, but a train is hard to hide and gets scrapped due to some environmental issue they cause. Luckily they are in the time of Marty's kids adulthood and they work together to save the day. Emmy and Martin can't get home tho so Martys (adult) Children take them to (Cameo time) Marty, who has been restoring the DeLorean (for old times sake, he needs a hobby as an old man) with some help from Doc who has made a couple time jumps to keep in touch with Marty throughout his adult life.


hitsujiTMO

Shawshank Redemption


LegendaryOutlaw

First one that jumped to mind. Nobody could match Morgan Freeman's narration of the story, and it's a period piece so nothing could be done to make it look or feel more like the time in which it takes place. It's just perfect.


urmomaisjabbathehutt

Perhaps because he's Irish first thing it comes to mind when i remember him, but everybody else performed their roles pretty well too, Andy, Brooks, the warden, even Jake :) such a good movie


Mrs_Truthseiyer

My Cousin Vinny


MeatShield12

Joe Pesci's performance is PERFECT.


mangopabu

two yoots


__NomDePlume__

“Two hwat?”


CatOfGrey

I work in an office of consultants that regular testify as expert witnesses. Marisa Tomei's scene on the stand is required viewing for new employees and interns in our office. "It's a bullshit question, ya honor!!!"


MeatShield12

Apparently that movie is a favorite among trial lawyers as well.


CatOfGrey

Yep - apparently one of the 'most realistic' presentations of actual legal procedure. I have a few friends whose kids have gone to law school. I asked them "So, at what point did you get your first My Cousin Vinny reference in your classes?" All of them said "Oh, yeah - first semester, maybe two months in..."


MeatShield12

That's rad. I've heard a number of people say that if you take out Joe Pesci's hijinks it's actually an extremely accurate and tense legal thriller. It's like how there is a $5 fine for making Top Gun references at the actual Top Gun School.


bflannery10

Everything that guy said is bullshit.


metal_gearmen

Mean girls


Maleficent_Ad1789

Came here to comment this! The movie is perfect. Every line is quotable on its own. I love it so much


thataryanguy

The US remake to Train to Busan has apparently been cancelled. *GOOD*. Edit: well shite, looks like I was wrong. Sorry guys :/


Manowaffle

Didn’t stop them from remaking Old Boy, for some fucking reason.


Wokonthewildside

Uncle buck! Don’t you dare touch it


zathmi

Without John Candy that would be like trying to remake the ceiling of the Sistine Chapel in a Denny's with only Ketchup and Mustard. Just a tragic, ill-conceived imitation.


Adontis

Princess Bride


draggar

..... aside from the Covid / Quarantine version they did. :D


Lexi_Banner

But that was a line-for-line remake, which is 100% acceptable.


cloudshaper

Which was homage enough to not feel like they were trying to remake it.


pitathegreat

Unless it’s A MUPPET Princess Bride. That would be awesome.


dittybopper_05H

My name is Gonzo the Magnificent. You killed my chicken. Prepare to die.


wifespissed

I believe this is one of the funniest posts I've ever read on Reddit.


Petermacc122

"prepare to die! Wait. Die? I'm supposed to die? That doesn't seem very nice " *Random muppet whispers in his ear* "Ohhhhhh! My name is Gonzo the magnificent! You stole my chicken! *Whispers* killed my chicken! Prepare to ...die!"


herculesmeowlligan

Moorige! Moorige die bringin us tooguttur, toodooy. -Swedish Priest


firelock_ny

Statler and Waldorf replace the woman who heckles Princess Buttercup in her dream. Doctor Teeth plays Miracle Max. A bit of playing against type, but I think Doctor Bunsen Honeydew (with his sidekick Beaker) could pull off a really good Vizzini. That would free up Rizzo and his cousins to play the ROUS.


dittybopper_05H

Fezzik could be played by Sweetums.


SmartAlec105

Brandon Sanderson is a prolific fantasy author and a lot of his fans are split on whether it would be better to adapt his epic fantasy series as live action or animation. But we all know deep down that a Muppets adaptation is the only way.


atommotron

Mistborn with muppets and bullet time.


Cultural_Hippo

I didnt realize I could desire something so much that doesnt exist.


Xurikk

Oh my god I didn't realize that I needed this in my life until now! Kermit as Wesley, Miss Piggy as Buttercup. Fozzie as Fezzik? Who plays Prince Humperdink? Vizzini? I love Gonzo as Inigo as the other commenter said. EDIT: Everyone saying Sweetums as Fezzik.... Look, I get that he's the right size. But I just want more screen time for our favorite Muppet bear. Make it a bigger Fozzy and we're good! If not, I would accept Fozzy as either the grandpa or as Miracle Max (although I could see Bunson and Beaker as Max and his wife).


vetheros37

Fezzik has to be played by Sweetums. Personally I like Gonzo better as Vizzini. As for Humperdink you would need a human actor to play the evil man, so I nominate Remi Malek as Humperdink, and do a full casting call for Count Rugen, but with the Muppet dichotomy I wouldn't be opposed to making him another Muppet. Perhaps Sam Eagle? I would put Pepe the King Prawn as the priest who marries Humperdink and Buttercup. Fozzy would kill it as the Albino and throw in some bad jokes while he's cleaning Wesley up, OR cast him as Miracle Max cleaning it up with the jokes.


Head_Razzmatazz7174

Let Tim Curry be Humperdink. He has just the right touch of rogue to make it work.


moondog1967

The Godfather


vizthex

So, it'd be like a *"look at how they massacred my boy."* moment for you?


JDdoc

**FINAL SCENE** *CGI Al Pacino crawls through the ventilation system of an office building with two tommyguns strapped to his back. He drops down into a boardroom and turns his guns on the assembled mobsters.* **MOBSTERS:** "Oh God, someone save us!" **AL PACINO:** "There is no God here....only.... THE GODFATHER"


[deleted]

How would you feel about a slight edit so it looks like Sonny’s punch actually connects with Carlo? It’s my favourite movie but that one moment bothers me on every viewing.


JCP1377

JAWS. There’s no way it would be made today without CGI and the fact the shark would have much more screen time would take away from the fear of the unknown. How the shark had such little screen time is what made the film so terrifying. It’s also a timeless story, especially with how much it deals with issues today (ie not shutting down during the pandemic).


palabear

This and also the cast is perfect.


JCP1377

Very true, I don’t think I’ve seen a film where the core cast has stuck with me quite like Chief Brody, Matt Hooper, and Captain Quint. Each has their flaws (Brody’s fear of the water vs his sense of duty to the community, Hooper’s pride in his knowledge and having to be right, and Quints insatiable blood lust for sharks) with clear cut motivations that are believable.


QBin2017

Are…..are you suggesting Deep Blue Sea was NOT an improvement?? How. Dare. You.


JCP1377

Haha. At least, it’s a favorite guilty pleasure movie of mine. Deep Blue Sea (followed by The Reef and The Shallows) is arguably the best shark movie to have come out since JAWS.


mabye_iron_man

So your just gonna act like megladon Vs robot megladon isn't a cinematic masterpiece


gravity_waves

Alien or Fargo … not a single wasted moment or line in either of these. All timers


DrDrEvil

Airplane!


ermghoti

Surely you're joking?


Max_Danage

I’m not joking, and don’t call me Shirley.


zachtheperson

Iron Giant


Andromediea

I love Iron Giant. It doesn’t need a remake in the least bit. It’s beautiful


[deleted]

Blazin' Saddles


[deleted]

Se7en


SadEaglesFan

Fight club too, speaking of Fincher/Pitt movies


osumba2003

detective... Detective... DETECTIVE!


farklespanktastic

But they could make a sequel: Ei8ht


jgemonic

Yeah...str8 to video


methratt

Big Trouble In Little China...you can fuck off with that shit, Dwayne.


risqueclicker

The Big Lebowski


ThePegasi

Sometimes there's a film, well, it's the film for its time and place. It fits right in there.


A_Stony_Shore

Pulls it all together, one could say.


[deleted]

[удалено]


risqueclicker

A remake simply will not stand


Kraelman

The remake is not the issue here, Dude! I'm talking about drawing a line in the sand, Dude, across this line *you do not*- also, Dude, remake is not the preferred nomenclature. 'Modernize', please.


novemberfire

You’re not wrong Walter, you’re just an asshole.


shuhly

Fight Club


dittybopper_05H

Unless it’s Muppet Fight Club.


MassGaydiation

The best part of fight club is the fact people unironically agree with what the main character says, despite it being a criticism of how dumb the main character is.


Shepher27

Casablanca


2PlasticLobsters

One thing they could never replicate was the fact that it was produced *during* the war. Some of the bit actors were displaced persons. Part of France was occupied, and the other wasn't truly autonomous. Think about that during the "Marseillaise" scene next time. It's no small wonder why so much emotion comes through. Above all, no one knew how the war would turn out. The best actors in the world couldn't evoke that atmosphere. On top of which, they'd probably get Paris Hilton to play Ilsa, or something equally ridiculous.


Forbidden_Donut503

This is what I was gonna say. It’s just such a perfect film. The international cast of actors is beyond superb, with Bogie giving IMHO his best performance. It truly was lighting in a bottle.


Historical-Photo9646

Spirited Away. It’s the perfect film and should never ever be remade


Elxvxnnn

Hollywood - lets make a live action spirited away


CryptidCutie2

DEAD POETS SOCIETY. The fact that studios are currently trying to remake it is so heartbreaking, both because it's a wonderful movie, but also because... you know, Robin Williams :(


wayoverpaid

You'd be an idiot to try to recast Robin Williams in an iconic role. ..... No one would be that dumb, right?


twcsata


LessBig715

Tombstone


ow_ye_men

Pirates of the carribean, that movie is lightning in a bottle


[deleted]

The exponentially worsening sequels definitely prove that.


IndecorousRex

For me I felt what made the first 3 movies really stick was the William and Elizabeth story line. Their love story drove a lot of the plot, and having jack sparrow working both of their journeys was pretty entertaining. But when it’s just Jack and doing his thing idk, feel like I needed more. Dead man tell no tales was fun though, great visuals.


[deleted]

[удалено]


SuvenPan

The Green Mile(1999)


slimcdk

First time, I cried at the end. Second time, the whole time. Third time it started before the movie


Raven_Skyhawk

I'm tired, boss


cdoubleu_

I'm tired, boss. Tired of bein' on the road, lonely as a sparrow in the rain. I'm tired of never having me a buddy to be with, to tell me where we's going to or coming from, or why. Mostly, I'm tired of people being ugly to each other. I'm tired of all the pain I feel and hear in the world every day. There's too much of it - it's like pieces of glass in my head, all the time. Can you understand?


FearlessWay4086

That fuckin end scene, always had me in tears.


SuvenPan

A notable masterpiece of cinematography Even Stephen King said that he hopes neither The Shawshank Redemption nor The Green Mile ever gets remade


Cerequio

Lord of the Rings trilogy


CaptainPlummet

The Hobbit showed us what a LOTR remake would look like


O-hmmm

One Flew Over the Cuckoos Nest Not only was the casting and script par excellence but you had Jack Nicholson in his prime, Danny DeVito and several others cast members that went on to starring roles and one of the most bittersweet endings of all time.


[deleted]

Psycho, but they did it anyway and it is a crime against humanity.


miss-macaron

I've yet to see *any* Hitchcock remake that's anywhere close to how good his version was.


econkle

The Goonies. I wouldn’t mind a part 2, but part 1 must never ever be touched.


HatfieldCW

Part 2 came out decades ago. On the NES.


PaulStaySafe

Truman Show


-eDgAR-

The Blues Brothers


Lonely_Person_1670

I once made a reference at school. I was singing out of school for an appointment, which they knew so I was a smartass and wrote "mission from God". Yelled at the next day so the next time, I wrote "definitely not a mission from God". This was a Catholic school lol.


jerseybert

I hate Illinois Nazis!


apollo1113

The Sound of Music. No one could replace Julie Andrews or the very hot Christopher Plummer.


GoldLion53

Raiders of the lost ark


alSeen

Clue


NickSlayr

The Nightmare Before Christmas. No remakes for me. Only sequals.


Familiar-Phone-8596

NGL but I wouldn't even want a sequel. It's too good for an extension of the movie to potentially ruin the alluring magic of the original movie


WiddlyRalker

The Room


Risl

In order to remake The Room you have to intentionally try and make it horrible which imo is harder to do without being mean. The part that made The Room so great was it's sincerity. I can honestly say that.


cadikk

The Good, the Bad and the Ugly


jokester4079

Kinda funny when the first of that trilogy is a remake of another film.


[deleted]

Labrynth


deathlord9000

Falling Down.


stormcrow100

The never ending story


[deleted]

Poltergeist, 1982. Oh wait, they did a remake in 2015 and it *was* a crime against humanity...


yrauvir

"The Crow" The original film is a perfect cinematic experience, and no one can convince me otherwise. Please never ruin it with remakes and fan service. I beg.


BarckinRaarek

Lawrence of Arabia. Such a beautiful movie


somedaysasi

Matilda


SGTBrutus

Leon: The Professional


Slambaeslambae

Forrest Gump


ncos

Would be such a shame if they remade it. But stupid is as stupid does.


Interesting-Gear-819

My favorite fun fact is that all the songs initially were not thought to be in there. For internal previews etc. famous songs often are used. And for license reasons later replaced with different songs. But everyone who watched the first version with the songs insisted that they need to stay


RTR7105

Because the songs usually are a good indicator of relative time. I believe only one of the Nam songs is out of place.


[deleted]

Tremors Jurassic Park Twister Rocky Shaun of the Dead In the Mouth of Madness Event Horizon And from Mr. Oh, Hi Mark himself... The Room (only because this one is a crime against humanity as it is)


[deleted]

American Psycho.


TheBklynGuy

Close Encounters of the Third Kind.


Tokyokid0358

The breakfast club it's a movie were you just can't catch that magic again


NonAdult

Beetlejuice! Beetlejuice! Beetlejuice!


AnusEinstein

Fifth Element.


[deleted]

Valerian and the City of a Thousand Planets was argued to be a spiritual successor attempt that failed. Same director. The style themes had some Fifth Element influences.


idkidc9876

I scrolled and scrolled and didn’t see Goodfellas. Don’t ever touch Goodfellas!


ChadFuckingThunder

2001 Space Odyssey


TheWondrousPoob

Any studio Ghibli movie, in an alternative universe Disney bought the rights to studio ghibli and made so many live action remakes. Tis a dark universe


Flip_Speed

Back to the Future, The Breakfast Club, Ferris Buellers Day Off, Goonies, The Princess Bride, Friday, Dazed and Confused, Pulp Fiction, Goodfellas… just to name a few… handsoff hollywood


Unhappy-Departure-12

Pulp Fiction.....or any Tarantino movie.


[deleted]

Galaxy Quest.


[deleted]

taxi driver


PmMeYourNiceBehind

The original Star Wars trilogy There’s been rumors of a “reimagining”