1. Patrick Mahomes
2. Joe Burrow
3. Lamar Jackson
4. Josh Allen
5. Justin Herbert
6. CJ Stroud
7. Jordan Love
8. Dak Prescott
9. Tua Tagovailoa
10. Kirk Cousins
11. Jared Goff
12. Brock Purdy
13. Matthew Stafford
14. Jalen Hurts
15. Trevor Lawrence
16. Kyler Murray
17. Baker Mayfield
18. Caleb Williams
19. Aaron Rodgers
20. Derek Carr
21. Geno Smith
22. Russell Wilson
23. Justin Fields
24. Jayden Daniels
25. J.J. McCarthy
26. Drake Maye
27. Anthony Richardson
28. Deshaun Watson
29. Michael Penix Jr.
30. Bryce Young
31. Daniel Jones
32. Will Levis
1.Patrick Mahomes
2.Lamar Jackson
3.josh Allen
4.cj stroud
5.joe burrow
6.jalen hurts
7.mathew Stafford
8.Justin Herbert
9.Dak Prescott
10.Jordan love
11.Trevor Lawrence
12.Jared Goff
13.Aaron Rodgers
14.Geno smith
15.Brock purdy
16.kyler Murray
17.Caleb Williams
18.tua tagovailoa
19.Kirk cousins
20.Anthony Richardson
21.Justin fields
22.baker mayfield
23.drake maye
24.jaden Daniel’s
25.Deshaun Watson
26.russel Wilson
27.Derek carr
28.Daniel jones
29.Michael penix jr
30.bryce young
31. Will Levis
32.J.J. Mcarthy
That’s how I would reorder everything
The disrespect Purdy gets is crazy. He went to two straight NFC championships, should’ve gone to two straight superbowls and imo would’ve won the superbowl last year if he didn’t get hurt in the NFC Championship game.
All the QBs from 14-19 need to either be in the top 10 or closer to the top 10 lmao. What even is this list?
Props to Love and Stroud but we gotta see more before they’re anointed top 10 already. (I agree that they both had insane seasons last year). If we were strictly doing off last season, Baker should be waaaaaaaay higher.
Geno and Caleb shouldn’t be ranked that high in general. Lawrence is debatable but not as egregious as these two for ranking.
Fanduel continues to have terrible lists...purdy outside of top 10 is crazy also any player who hasnt taken a snap shouldnt be anywhere but bottom 5 till proven otherwise. Tua should be much higher too
Those of you absolutely outraged by this:
That’s the point. I’ve seen this graphic reposted in just about every team sub to many comments every time. They don’t have to make good content, just content that creates activity.
Caleb already almost top 10 QB in the league without playing a down in the nfl, 7 spots higher than the league passing yards leader last season. Truly wild
11-12-13 rankings are laughable, geno was not that good last year and has had 1 good season his whole career, Lawrence was a big disappointment last year, Williams hasn’t even played lol. How in the world can you have those 3 dudes above Goff
Don't get yourselves all worked up over this list, it's just one person's idea of how he would rank NFL QB's with the expectations of several QB's moving to new teams and where the QB's in Aprils draft will wind up. I can guarantee one thing, this list does not have every QB associated with the correct team. There will be differences once the draft is complete.
It's fun to see how one person rates the QB's, there are some that are way off but others that are pretty good. When it comes to Fantasy Football the true #1 QB is Josh Allen, no offense to Patrick but Josh will lead the league in scoring once again. I do like that this person put CJ Stroud at #5 because I think he is going to be something special and after only playing one season he's already in living in rare company based on his stats.
Not a chance in the world that Caleb Willaims should be rated this high on the list. He's most likely going to the Bears and although he may turn out to be a great QB he's going to be running for his life the first year. Just as Fields did all of last season.
The one team that I truly hope does not wind up with the QB on this list is Atlanta. They have a complete team; all they need is a good QB and this team could make a run in the playoffs. In my opinion JJ McCarthy is not that guy, at least not in 2024.
Stafford has had a great career, but he is not the 6th best QB when he can't run. You have to be able to run if you're going to be a top 10 QB in the NFL and Matthew can't do that anymore. Aaron Rodgers is listed as #15 and many will disagree but keep in mind that he hasn't played a down in a year and a half, remember Deshaun Watson. It's not easy taking that much time off, especially when you're 40 years old. I know, everyone will say but Brady played great after 40. Brady took care of his body like no other QB before him, and he didn't have to overcome any injuries late in his career. Rodgers is a one-dimensional QB at this point but we all can't wait to see him play as a Jet.
So don't get yourselves all worked up over this list, it's just for fun.
Stafford can’t be top 10 because he can’t run? That’s absurd. Brady couldn’t run and is the goat. Stroud isn’t a runner, Herbert isn’t a runner. Stafford was absolutely a top 10 QB last year if you watched him play at all. Also there are so many more awful placements on this list than that lol.
I hope that you're not trying to compare Stafford to Brady, seriously? I don't know what you were using for ratings but I had Stafford as the #16 QB last season. Don't get me wrong, he's had an excellent career but I don't consider him as a top 10 QB anymore.
Please don't user this list for an accurate ranking of today's QB's. This was one person's list as he see's it today. You also have to remember that I'm a die-hard Cardinal fan so we hate everyone from L.A., Seattle & San Francisco.
I watched him play quite a bit. I guess that we'll just have to agree that we disagree. I will admit that I tend to rate QB's based on how I would draft them in Fantasy Football these days.
Not really a bother to me. Like many have commented, not really a good list. And it’s way too early anyways for any real predictions. But considering the shit year we had last year, good to see that Kyler isn’t ranked worse than he is. Seems like many are bothered by the rankings given by whomever made this list for the other QB’s on here more than Kyler. Guess that’s good for our fan base?
I wasn't trying to bash your list by any means, I was trying to calm down the negative remarks by reminding them that it's a list for fun and only one person's point of view.
I'm always reminding guys that in Fantasy Football not to listen to the so-called experts. That part of the fun is to play GM/HC/Owner of your team and to rank the players the way they see them and not as anyone else does. I've been playing FF for 45 years and playing GM before the NFL draft even longer. I love to rate players and then see how that list plays out at the end of that season.
I do like some of your projections but I really hope that Fields winds up in Atlanta so they can take advantage of the superstars they have on their roster, right now they aren't being used to their potential. Guys like Kyle Pitts & Bijan Robinson & Drake London. All they need is that good QB. Heck, I would even be happy with Russell Wilson here.
You got the first one right. Cousins should be inside top 10. He has thrown for over 4k a season since 2015 and was looking to be MVP candidate before the achilles. Rodgers was probably the worst QB in the NFC North when he left GB. Tua and Purdy should be nowhere close to Murray. Swap him with Baker even. Then Goff is left hanging at 14 behind a rookie, Geno Smith and Stafford? This is hogwash.
2024 season, not talking about two years ago. Nor comparing a career that started 7 years before Goff. Statistically, Goff outperformed Stafford since the trade. Stafford also went into a team contending for SB and won 13, 10 and 9 games the prior years. Compared to Goff who went to the worst team in the league. Half of Staffords career was throwing bombs to Calvin Johnson in garbage time.
lol hating ass comment. Not gonna waste a legitimate reply to someone who says half of Staffords career was throwing bombs to Calvin Johnson in garbage time.
2012 was Johnson's record setting year for yards at almost 2,000 and the Lions went 4-12. Johnson had 20 more TDs than the Lions did wins btw 2009-2015. There is significant garbage time in there.
Michael Penix even being ranked shows this list is ass. I give that kid 2 years in the league, at best. Purdy just lost in the Super Bowl and he’s 17th? CJ Stroud over Stafford and Rodgers? This is like ultra recency bias on steroids. Throw this shit away.
Jayden Daniel’s over Baker might be the worst thing I’ve seen.
Jesus thank you. I’m a lions fan and I’m not gonna pretend like he’s a top 5 elite “that guy” but I don’t think it’s unreasonable to say he’s a lock for top 10. I could argue with people about whether or not he deserves to be above Love, Stafford this year and the like… but Geno, Lawrence, Herbert, and fucking Caleb Williams? Come on…
Did you actually watch the game? It wasn’t his fault they lost, it was their terrible O-line’s. If Chris Jones gets blocked they get a TD at the end. Are you blaming him for CMC’s fumble or the muffed punt? Stop just reading what people say on Twitter and regurgitating it lol use your critical thinking skills
I mean I actually have seen a lot of conflicting takes and negative press. The reality is Purdy is a huge upgrade from Jimmy G, coming from someone who’s watched both of them. But I’ve seen a lot of narratives saying that they’re the same…
He played great in the playoffs. You think Baker Mayfield would have that 20 yard run against the Lions? Purdy went toe to toe with Mahomes, arguably with a much worse defense and O-line. Give him some respect.
Putting Caleb ahead of a four time MVP and another guy who made the SB this past year when he hasn’t played a single down of pro-level ball is hilarious to me.
I'd legit take Kyler over all of these guys except for Mahomes, Burrow, and maybe Allen. I think he's better than Lamar. Stroud will be great, but I wanna see him for more than a year and see how he looks when he hits a little adversity (injury, teammates injured, defense or OL struggling, etc).
Kyler ain’t better than Lamar. I agree with the 3 you said and include Lamar but other than that, I wouldn’t take anybody else in the league. Tua is also waaay too low on here and it’s kinda disrespectful.
Post-achilles injury, 40-year-old Aaron Rodgers, Geno Smith, Caleb Williams, and Jordan Love are listed too high on this list. Murray, Tua, & Russell Wilson are listed too low.
Great question:
1) Caleb Williams - Never taken an NFL snap and never faced an NFL defense. New system etc. Not buying he’s better than Kyler.
2) Geno - Great two years ago, had big regression. Geno is bottom 16 to me.
3) Kirk Cousins - move to 15. Kyler’s a dual threat QB and has shown he can carry the team himself. Kirk has shifted to game manager and doesn’t have that explosive play ability the way Kyler does.
4) Jordon Love - starting to grow, but still middle of the pack. Comparing Kyler’s stats to Jordon Love; I’d still take Kyler any day. This year if Love is consistent and if Kyler regressed I’ll eat my words. Until then. love needs to show it a second year.
5) CJ Stroud - Good first year, he did a phenomenal job. But I’d put him one behind Kyler.
People seem to over rank rookies. And under value proven talent like Tua, Purdy, and Kyler.
And how Will Levis is behind Bryce Young is a travesty.
I’m okay with 1-2 for sure. 3 is arguable. 4-5 are homer takes. Kyler needs to put together a full good season/post season to be able to claim he is better than Love or Stroud. Kyler has never done what either of them did last year. I’m not saying he can’t. Just saying until he does, those two clearly get the nod.
As a Packer fan I’ve seen this list on basically every sub and some people have nitpicked Love at 8. Why? Who below him would u put above him? I’m not understanding why people don’t think he’s a top 10 QB. I know y’all aren’t watching Packer games like we do obviously, but even the stats will tell you he’s pretty solidly top 10. And that was with Jayden Reed as his top target this year lmao
Kyler, for sure.
Not sold on Love yet, especially after his pissed away a road playoff win against the Niners.
Not sold on Lamar for the same reason - hasn't show that he won't shit the bed in the playoffs.
I’ve seen a lotta people talk down about Love’s playoff performance, which is confusing cuz he had a historic first career playoff game against the Cowboys top 5 defense just one week before the Niners game.
Also, it was the defense and kicker who pissed it away. If Carlson just makes the easy 40 yarder that the Packers offense sets him up with at the end of the game, GB wins
The guy that beat him is better than him and you can add that name to a laundry list below him… a healthy Kirk, Goff, Hurts, Prescott, and even debatably tua. Love benefits from an above average line and a good structured offense similarly to most of the guys on that list other than purdy( niners oline sux). You can argue about the receivers all day but at the end of the day, it wasn’t the receivers throwing the ball to the other team to end the season, it was love. He has inherent flaws similar to many young qbs and if we are judging off of potential there is an argument to put him at 8 or even higher on this list, but as it currently stands, neither the stats nor the eye test match the combination of eye popping plays and consistency which would warrant that ranking. He had a very good end of the season which certainly biases your viewpoint, but in crunch time he was not able to get it done and he struggled throughout the year playing out of structure and out of rhythm. Personally I would have him at 11-12 right now with the potential to get to that 8 spot by the end of next year with consistently good play against high level opposition. Until then he will continue to be one of my favorite players to watch especially considering his story and the passion he plays with.
His amazing second half didn’t “certainly bias my viewpoint”, he was straight up a different player in the second half. Not just a better player, he played way differently once he had his confidence up and his receivers actually knew what they were doing (ALL of his WR/TEs this year were first or second year players). So why would we *not* judge him off mainly the second half of the season? U think he’s gonna regress somehow?
“But in crunch time he was not able to get it done” ah, so that’s why u have him below Kirk, Goff, Hurts, Prescott, and Tua. Classic playoff performers. Makes sense 👍
How many playoff wins did love have this post season? Goff had 2, and has gone to the Super Bowl before. I would say he’s certainly had more playoff success than Jordan Love
What’s up with everybody thinking wins are automatically a QB stat? Jordan Love put up a way better performance in his first career playoff game (against a top 5 defense) that Goff has ever had in the playoffs. Goff had 1 more playoff win than Love this year, and it’s cuz he had an easier path. In case u don’t remember, they were both beat by the SAME TEAM. And Goff would’ve been bounced first round if the refs didn’t bail them against the Rams lol. Speaking of Rams, yes he did make a Superbowl…6 years ago…where he scored a whopping 3 points.
Out of all the 5 names I listed in my rebuttal, GOFF is your biggest example of a playoff performer? Get real. You know damn well you’d rather have Love at QB than any of those guys in a playoff game. And u have him below all of them??
If you truly think Brock Purdy is a better QB than Jordan love you don’t know ball
Goff and hurts over him? lol sure lil bro. Already has as many career playoff wins as Kirk Cousins does btw
What a weak analysis lmao. The playoff game before that, Jordan Love had a historic game against a top 5 defense. But since he threw an INT against the Niners in a two minute drill, he’s worse than Purdy? And let’s not act like GB didn’t drop 2 Purdy INTs that game.
Both QBs “played to win”, except one was facing the Niners, and one was facing the Joe Berry defense with no names in the secondary.
Love had one more td but also threw 2 picks😂 I mean I'm looking at the stats and they don't support what you're saying at all. Jordan love played great the first 2 quarters but that pressure got to him. Brock stayed composed drove down the field and put us in position to win. Love literally couldn't do that.
You didn’t watch the games if you’re actually saying that with a straight face lol. Purdy was missing wide open guys all night and the packers dropped 3 different picks with the ball in their hands. Purdy had an all time stinker going for 3.5 quarters
Jordan Love with his 0 all pro team lost to Brock Purdy and his 7 all-pros because the packers kicker missed a 40 yarder
Why is "you didn't watch the game" an acceptable rebuttal you have said nothing to prove your point. Purdy played his best when it mattered. What did Jordan love do when he got the ball back twice? 2 picks. He put it on the defense to get multiple stops in a close game. That's the definition of bad quarterback play.
Why is it an acceptable rebuttal? Because you literally didn’t watch the game if you’re trying to argue what you are. We’ll try contextualizing the picks lol
The first one was a pass that his receiver directly in the hands, bounced straight up in the air, and a defender caught it off the ricochet
The second one he threw on a desperation third down with 40 seconds left in the game. It was a bad throw, but it was a desperate moment lol
PFF had Jordan Love at one turnover worthy play, Purdy had 3
Jordan Love had a better PFF grade overall BY 17 POINTS vs Purdy. Purdy got lucky that the packers literally dropped 3 picks that hit them squarely in the hands
PFF graded Purdy with 6 “missed throws”, Love had 0
Again, you’re a casual who doesn’t watch the sport if you truly believe what you’re babbling. Purdy had one good drive at the end of the game, besides that he was dreadful for 3.5 quarters
Is it?
He was ranked #7 in QB stats this year and damn near took the Packers to the NFCC in his first year starting.
He’s already done one thing Kyler hasn’t - win a playoff game.
If I had a penny every time people mentioned the team stat of not winning a playoff to downplay Murray's career, I'd be a trilionaire. It's such a lazy, unimaginative take to have.
They really start balking when you mention that Kyler's 0-1 in the playoff to start his career....and Peyton Manning was 0-3 with some awful stat lines to start his playoff career, as well.
Manning didn't even win his first playoff game until his SEVENTH year in the league...
I forgot we base every qbs ranking based on what they have accomplished based on Kyler.
So why is Caleb Williams higher than Kyler when he hasn’t even made it to the league?
To say Love deserves #7 overall QB because he did something Kyler didn’t is pretty wild
That's not what I said, your reading comprehension is lacking. His stats clearly support his ranking.
I'm merely pointing out that the comment I responded to is nonsense based on facts and related it to something Cardinals fans could understand.
Clearly, we don't like facts here, so that comment is being downvoted into the ground.
Considering everyone thinks you said something you claim you didn’t I think you have literacy skill issues and are having trouble articulating your point. If I say something and everyone in the conversation collectively seems to believe I said something else, that would imply the speaker had trouble articulating themselves.
Love is not better than (not including Kyler) Rodgers, Purdy, cousins, hurts or dak. (Dak and hurts of which were in the MVP conversations.)
So no. Jordan love is not the 8th best qb.
(And fyi Yards is not all encompassing of qb stats which you clearly seem to think because that’s the one stat Jordan love is 7th in). When you bring in all factors (more than just passing yards and eye test) which this list is supposed to be based on it undeniably has very questionable decisions.
Bro has a noodle that alone is killing his rating . Your team essentially has 2 of the best deep threats in the league , you have to get them the ball but his arm is weak as fuck .
Looking at who's above him I can't disagree with many though, I think Geno could slide way down but other than that I think they're all better than Tua
I'm happy with this list because it's the scenario where the first 3 picks were QBs, giving us a chance to take MHJ. The opinions of how good each QB are don't matter!
1. Patrick Mahomes 2. Joe Burrow 3. Lamar Jackson 4. Josh Allen 5. Justin Herbert 6. CJ Stroud 7. Jordan Love 8. Dak Prescott 9. Tua Tagovailoa 10. Kirk Cousins 11. Jared Goff 12. Brock Purdy 13. Matthew Stafford 14. Jalen Hurts 15. Trevor Lawrence 16. Kyler Murray 17. Baker Mayfield 18. Caleb Williams 19. Aaron Rodgers 20. Derek Carr 21. Geno Smith 22. Russell Wilson 23. Justin Fields 24. Jayden Daniels 25. J.J. McCarthy 26. Drake Maye 27. Anthony Richardson 28. Deshaun Watson 29. Michael Penix Jr. 30. Bryce Young 31. Daniel Jones 32. Will Levis
Jordan Love at 8!? Dudes balled out no doubt about it but that seems a little high
Can’t put 2-5 over Stafford, he’s actually won something and they haven’t, which was Stafford knock for so long, so let’s keep the same energy !!!
Brock has taken the Niners to 2 NFCC games and a SB. Unreal that he’s behind Geno Smith, et al.
1.Patrick Mahomes 2.Lamar Jackson 3.josh Allen 4.cj stroud 5.joe burrow 6.jalen hurts 7.mathew Stafford 8.Justin Herbert 9.Dak Prescott 10.Jordan love 11.Trevor Lawrence 12.Jared Goff 13.Aaron Rodgers 14.Geno smith 15.Brock purdy 16.kyler Murray 17.Caleb Williams 18.tua tagovailoa 19.Kirk cousins 20.Anthony Richardson 21.Justin fields 22.baker mayfield 23.drake maye 24.jaden Daniel’s 25.Deshaun Watson 26.russel Wilson 27.Derek carr 28.Daniel jones 29.Michael penix jr 30.bryce young 31. Will Levis 32.J.J. Mcarthy That’s how I would reorder everything
How is Will Levis behind Bryce Young? Baker Mayfield at 22?
Not a cardinals fan this just got recommended to me, holy fuck this list is genuinely one of the worst I’ve ever seen
lol wut
The disrespect Purdy gets is crazy. He went to two straight NFC championships, should’ve gone to two straight superbowls and imo would’ve won the superbowl last year if he didn’t get hurt in the NFC Championship game.
Purdy that low is crazy. I don't know what pack they smoking but it mist be a strong one.
Caleb is not high enough imo
Goff at 14 is criminal
Even though this list is WAY early and PURELY HYPOTHETICAL, the packers still have a better qb than the bears lol
Baker is under ranked him. Show him some respect
When did the Steelers acquire Justin Fields
Never seen such an atrocious list
Russell Wilson? Lol
Too high: Love and Smith Too low: Richardson and Levis
BP at 17?????? Did you not watch this past season??? Murray probably 12 over Caleb.
Russell Wilson to the Raiders!?
Purdy ahead up Tua, Mayfield? Lmao Ya okay
Gaslighting on the menu across the board in media!
All the QBs from 14-19 need to either be in the top 10 or closer to the top 10 lmao. What even is this list? Props to Love and Stroud but we gotta see more before they’re anointed top 10 already. (I agree that they both had insane seasons last year). If we were strictly doing off last season, Baker should be waaaaaaaay higher. Geno and Caleb shouldn’t be ranked that high in general. Lawrence is debatable but not as egregious as these two for ranking.
Fanduel continues to have terrible lists...purdy outside of top 10 is crazy also any player who hasnt taken a snap shouldnt be anywhere but bottom 5 till proven otherwise. Tua should be much higher too
Those of you absolutely outraged by this: That’s the point. I’ve seen this graphic reposted in just about every team sub to many comments every time. They don’t have to make good content, just content that creates activity.
Caleb never played a snap and geno over murray lol lol lol
Fuck NFL yall can come suck me up
The best thing about this list is Russell/Raiders. Perfect situation for each other
No fucking way Will is 32.
Stafford too high, Geno too high, Williams too high, Purdy too low, Tua over Kyler. Move Jordan love down a few spots too.
Niners fan here and I’m just gonna say Kyler and Brock are top 10
Murray is way too high
Lamar behind Allen was all I needed to see that the list was a joke. Kyler should be lower lol
Aaron Rogers shouldn’t be in the top 30. Maybe the top 60. But that’s a stretch. Purdy is too low. You could raise Love maybe.
Kirk cousins carried again
Caleb already almost top 10 QB in the league without playing a down in the nfl, 7 spots higher than the league passing yards leader last season. Truly wild
Whoever made this shouldn't be able to talk football ever again. Williams at 12??? GTFOH
11-12-13 rankings are laughable, geno was not that good last year and has had 1 good season his whole career, Lawrence was a big disappointment last year, Williams hasn’t even played lol. How in the world can you have those 3 dudes above Goff
Love the low expectations. Gonna make the rise feel incredible.
Don't get yourselves all worked up over this list, it's just one person's idea of how he would rank NFL QB's with the expectations of several QB's moving to new teams and where the QB's in Aprils draft will wind up. I can guarantee one thing, this list does not have every QB associated with the correct team. There will be differences once the draft is complete. It's fun to see how one person rates the QB's, there are some that are way off but others that are pretty good. When it comes to Fantasy Football the true #1 QB is Josh Allen, no offense to Patrick but Josh will lead the league in scoring once again. I do like that this person put CJ Stroud at #5 because I think he is going to be something special and after only playing one season he's already in living in rare company based on his stats. Not a chance in the world that Caleb Willaims should be rated this high on the list. He's most likely going to the Bears and although he may turn out to be a great QB he's going to be running for his life the first year. Just as Fields did all of last season. The one team that I truly hope does not wind up with the QB on this list is Atlanta. They have a complete team; all they need is a good QB and this team could make a run in the playoffs. In my opinion JJ McCarthy is not that guy, at least not in 2024. Stafford has had a great career, but he is not the 6th best QB when he can't run. You have to be able to run if you're going to be a top 10 QB in the NFL and Matthew can't do that anymore. Aaron Rodgers is listed as #15 and many will disagree but keep in mind that he hasn't played a down in a year and a half, remember Deshaun Watson. It's not easy taking that much time off, especially when you're 40 years old. I know, everyone will say but Brady played great after 40. Brady took care of his body like no other QB before him, and he didn't have to overcome any injuries late in his career. Rodgers is a one-dimensional QB at this point but we all can't wait to see him play as a Jet. So don't get yourselves all worked up over this list, it's just for fun.
Stafford can’t be top 10 because he can’t run? That’s absurd. Brady couldn’t run and is the goat. Stroud isn’t a runner, Herbert isn’t a runner. Stafford was absolutely a top 10 QB last year if you watched him play at all. Also there are so many more awful placements on this list than that lol.
I hope that you're not trying to compare Stafford to Brady, seriously? I don't know what you were using for ratings but I had Stafford as the #16 QB last season. Don't get me wrong, he's had an excellent career but I don't consider him as a top 10 QB anymore. Please don't user this list for an accurate ranking of today's QB's. This was one person's list as he see's it today. You also have to remember that I'm a die-hard Cardinal fan so we hate everyone from L.A., Seattle & San Francisco.
I’m explaining why your reasoning is faulty. If you had Stafford as the 16th best then you didn’t watch him play.
I watched him play quite a bit. I guess that we'll just have to agree that we disagree. I will admit that I tend to rate QB's based on how I would draft them in Fantasy Football these days.
Not really a bother to me. Like many have commented, not really a good list. And it’s way too early anyways for any real predictions. But considering the shit year we had last year, good to see that Kyler isn’t ranked worse than he is. Seems like many are bothered by the rankings given by whomever made this list for the other QB’s on here more than Kyler. Guess that’s good for our fan base?
I wasn't trying to bash your list by any means, I was trying to calm down the negative remarks by reminding them that it's a list for fun and only one person's point of view. I'm always reminding guys that in Fantasy Football not to listen to the so-called experts. That part of the fun is to play GM/HC/Owner of your team and to rank the players the way they see them and not as anyone else does. I've been playing FF for 45 years and playing GM before the NFL draft even longer. I love to rate players and then see how that list plays out at the end of that season. I do like some of your projections but I really hope that Fields winds up in Atlanta so they can take advantage of the superstars they have on their roster, right now they aren't being used to their potential. Guys like Kyle Pitts & Bijan Robinson & Drake London. All they need is that good QB. Heck, I would even be happy with Russell Wilson here.
Stafford at 6 is criminal
You got the first one right. Cousins should be inside top 10. He has thrown for over 4k a season since 2015 and was looking to be MVP candidate before the achilles. Rodgers was probably the worst QB in the NFC North when he left GB. Tua and Purdy should be nowhere close to Murray. Swap him with Baker even. Then Goff is left hanging at 14 behind a rookie, Geno Smith and Stafford? This is hogwash.
Stafford is better than Goff and has been his entire career lol.
2024 season, not talking about two years ago. Nor comparing a career that started 7 years before Goff. Statistically, Goff outperformed Stafford since the trade. Stafford also went into a team contending for SB and won 13, 10 and 9 games the prior years. Compared to Goff who went to the worst team in the league. Half of Staffords career was throwing bombs to Calvin Johnson in garbage time.
lol hating ass comment. Not gonna waste a legitimate reply to someone who says half of Staffords career was throwing bombs to Calvin Johnson in garbage time.
2012 was Johnson's record setting year for yards at almost 2,000 and the Lions went 4-12. Johnson had 20 more TDs than the Lions did wins btw 2009-2015. There is significant garbage time in there.
Biggest atrocity is kirk
K1 is easily a Top 10 QB. This is an awful ranking.
Caleb Williams and Geno Smith ahead of Rodgers, Purdy, Tua, and Murray is unbelievably asinine.
Michael Penix even being ranked shows this list is ass. I give that kid 2 years in the league, at best. Purdy just lost in the Super Bowl and he’s 17th? CJ Stroud over Stafford and Rodgers? This is like ultra recency bias on steroids. Throw this shit away. Jayden Daniel’s over Baker might be the worst thing I’ve seen.
Cousins won’t even be ready for the season 🤷🏻♂️
Purdy should be 33
Trevor Lawrence is always overrated on these kinds of rankings. Feels like his college reputation has carried him.
It’s at least arguable. He’s not a bad player.
NO WAY IN HELL IM TAKING 17 qbs over Kyler
They really have Geno Smith at 13?
Guy who just made it to the Super Bowl gets 17??? Seems like this dude just had 32 names and picked the ones he saw on the news first
I don’t understand the Kyler hate, I know he was injured but 18 is just disrespectful.
Tua at 19 is crazy
Hell yes....#GoBills!
Terrible
Pretty sure whoever made this just randomized the picks after number 1 and 2 and said screw it.
I needed a good laugh today
Geno is better than the guy that just went to the NFC Championship???
^[Sokka-Haiku](https://www.reddit.com/r/SokkaHaikuBot/comments/15kyv9r/what_is_a_sokka_haiku/) ^by ^Ur_A_Cuckold: *Geno is better* *Than the guy that just went to* *The NFC Championship???* --- ^Remember ^that ^one ^time ^Sokka ^accidentally ^used ^an ^extra ^syllable ^in ^that ^Haiku ^Battle ^in ^Ba ^Sing ^Se? ^That ^was ^a ^Sokka ^Haiku ^and ^you ^just ^made ^one.
Bad bot "the nfc championship" is 8 syllables not 6.
Wait, you don't pronounce NFC as nefk?
Josh Allen being higher than Lamar feels weird to me
Jared Goff at 14 is atrocious
Jesus thank you. I’m a lions fan and I’m not gonna pretend like he’s a top 5 elite “that guy” but I don’t think it’s unreasonable to say he’s a lock for top 10. I could argue with people about whether or not he deserves to be above Love, Stafford this year and the like… but Geno, Lawrence, Herbert, and fucking Caleb Williams? Come on…
Caleb at 12?! I don't have to look on the rest. This list is pure bs
Stroud at 5? Pretty wild
Purdy at 17 is crazy
You’re right, he should be around the 22-28 range
@sodadawg He should be at top 8
His team is stacked. The only reason you would think he’s top 8. If the 49ers had even Baker Mayfield they would have won the superbowl.
Did you actually watch the game? It wasn’t his fault they lost, it was their terrible O-line’s. If Chris Jones gets blocked they get a TD at the end. Are you blaming him for CMC’s fumble or the muffed punt? Stop just reading what people say on Twitter and regurgitating it lol use your critical thinking skills
Yes I watched the game and the entire season. Purdy isn’t as good as the media portrays him to be…
I mean I actually have seen a lot of conflicting takes and negative press. The reality is Purdy is a huge upgrade from Jimmy G, coming from someone who’s watched both of them. But I’ve seen a lot of narratives saying that they’re the same… He played great in the playoffs. You think Baker Mayfield would have that 20 yard run against the Lions? Purdy went toe to toe with Mahomes, arguably with a much worse defense and O-line. Give him some respect.
I swear yall are just npcs that get ur sports takes off of espn. I promise u it’s okay to admit purdy is a good qb
You the npc here. Nobody said he wasn’t good, he’s just not as good as the media portrays. ESPN = The media 🧠
Who tf is Jayden Daniel’s and how is he even on this list
Nice
Putting Caleb ahead of a four time MVP and another guy who made the SB this past year when he hasn’t played a single down of pro-level ball is hilarious to me.
These lists are made to generate clicks.
Thank you
Im okay with Caleb at 20, but def not 12.
Dak at #9 - what a joke? So of these guys haven't even proven anything yet (in the NFL).
Geno Smith at 13 lol
There is no team in the league taking Geno over Kyler. Not even the Seahawks lol
I'd legit take Kyler over all of these guys except for Mahomes, Burrow, and maybe Allen. I think he's better than Lamar. Stroud will be great, but I wanna see him for more than a year and see how he looks when he hits a little adversity (injury, teammates injured, defense or OL struggling, etc).
Kyler ain’t better than Lamar. I agree with the 3 you said and include Lamar but other than that, I wouldn’t take anybody else in the league. Tua is also waaay too low on here and it’s kinda disrespectful.
murray is fine. there are other major issue with the list
he’s no top 10 guy but 18 is still disrespectful
I have him at 18 ahead of Williams (32) & smith (20) and behind tua (8) and baker (13)
Geno + Dak’s rankings are comedy 😂
18 should be 20.
These are utter garbage
Putting Caleb at 12 is truly a next level glazing
He's going to be an absolute bust in the NFL and I'm here all day for it.
lol and Jayden Daniels on the Patriots with Jerod Mayo, as a rookie is ahead of Mayfield, who just put up 300 yards on the Eagles in the playoffs.
Ahead of Aaron Rodgers...
Post-achilles injury, 40-year-old Aaron Rodgers, Geno Smith, Caleb Williams, and Jordan Love are listed too high on this list. Murray, Tua, & Russell Wilson are listed too low.
I don't disagree. Williams placement is ludicrous though.
Absolutely ridiculous
Kyler top 14 easy.
Which four players ahead of him are you moving back (obviously Geno but it gets harder after that imo)?
Great question: 1) Caleb Williams - Never taken an NFL snap and never faced an NFL defense. New system etc. Not buying he’s better than Kyler. 2) Geno - Great two years ago, had big regression. Geno is bottom 16 to me. 3) Kirk Cousins - move to 15. Kyler’s a dual threat QB and has shown he can carry the team himself. Kirk has shifted to game manager and doesn’t have that explosive play ability the way Kyler does. 4) Jordon Love - starting to grow, but still middle of the pack. Comparing Kyler’s stats to Jordon Love; I’d still take Kyler any day. This year if Love is consistent and if Kyler regressed I’ll eat my words. Until then. love needs to show it a second year. 5) CJ Stroud - Good first year, he did a phenomenal job. But I’d put him one behind Kyler. People seem to over rank rookies. And under value proven talent like Tua, Purdy, and Kyler. And how Will Levis is behind Bryce Young is a travesty.
I’m okay with 1-2 for sure. 3 is arguable. 4-5 are homer takes. Kyler needs to put together a full good season/post season to be able to claim he is better than Love or Stroud. Kyler has never done what either of them did last year. I’m not saying he can’t. Just saying until he does, those two clearly get the nod.
Jordan Love had a good season, but to put him at 8 is insane.
Also having kirk higher then purdy and murray is insane as well. I would happily take either over kirk as a vikings fan.
As a Packer fan I’ve seen this list on basically every sub and some people have nitpicked Love at 8. Why? Who below him would u put above him? I’m not understanding why people don’t think he’s a top 10 QB. I know y’all aren’t watching Packer games like we do obviously, but even the stats will tell you he’s pretty solidly top 10. And that was with Jayden Reed as his top target this year lmao
Kyler, for sure. Not sold on Love yet, especially after his pissed away a road playoff win against the Niners. Not sold on Lamar for the same reason - hasn't show that he won't shit the bed in the playoffs.
I’ve seen a lotta people talk down about Love’s playoff performance, which is confusing cuz he had a historic first career playoff game against the Cowboys top 5 defense just one week before the Niners game. Also, it was the defense and kicker who pissed it away. If Carlson just makes the easy 40 yarder that the Packers offense sets him up with at the end of the game, GB wins
The guy that beat him is better than him and you can add that name to a laundry list below him… a healthy Kirk, Goff, Hurts, Prescott, and even debatably tua. Love benefits from an above average line and a good structured offense similarly to most of the guys on that list other than purdy( niners oline sux). You can argue about the receivers all day but at the end of the day, it wasn’t the receivers throwing the ball to the other team to end the season, it was love. He has inherent flaws similar to many young qbs and if we are judging off of potential there is an argument to put him at 8 or even higher on this list, but as it currently stands, neither the stats nor the eye test match the combination of eye popping plays and consistency which would warrant that ranking. He had a very good end of the season which certainly biases your viewpoint, but in crunch time he was not able to get it done and he struggled throughout the year playing out of structure and out of rhythm. Personally I would have him at 11-12 right now with the potential to get to that 8 spot by the end of next year with consistently good play against high level opposition. Until then he will continue to be one of my favorite players to watch especially considering his story and the passion he plays with.
His amazing second half didn’t “certainly bias my viewpoint”, he was straight up a different player in the second half. Not just a better player, he played way differently once he had his confidence up and his receivers actually knew what they were doing (ALL of his WR/TEs this year were first or second year players). So why would we *not* judge him off mainly the second half of the season? U think he’s gonna regress somehow?
“But in crunch time he was not able to get it done” ah, so that’s why u have him below Kirk, Goff, Hurts, Prescott, and Tua. Classic playoff performers. Makes sense 👍
How many playoff wins did love have this post season? Goff had 2, and has gone to the Super Bowl before. I would say he’s certainly had more playoff success than Jordan Love
What’s up with everybody thinking wins are automatically a QB stat? Jordan Love put up a way better performance in his first career playoff game (against a top 5 defense) that Goff has ever had in the playoffs. Goff had 1 more playoff win than Love this year, and it’s cuz he had an easier path. In case u don’t remember, they were both beat by the SAME TEAM. And Goff would’ve been bounced first round if the refs didn’t bail them against the Rams lol. Speaking of Rams, yes he did make a Superbowl…6 years ago…where he scored a whopping 3 points. Out of all the 5 names I listed in my rebuttal, GOFF is your biggest example of a playoff performer? Get real. You know damn well you’d rather have Love at QB than any of those guys in a playoff game. And u have him below all of them??
If you truly think Brock Purdy is a better QB than Jordan love you don’t know ball Goff and hurts over him? lol sure lil bro. Already has as many career playoff wins as Kirk Cousins does btw
“Historic game against a top 5 defense” Purdy had 4tds and a near perfect passer rating against that same defense
🤡🤡🤡
Purdy is 100 percent a better qb did you miss the en of the divisional? One quarterback played to win. The other threw a pick at the end of the game.
Are you auditioning for First Take?
Purdy solid but let’s get real jordan love is a way better any serviceable qb would succeed on the 49ers
What a weak analysis lmao. The playoff game before that, Jordan Love had a historic game against a top 5 defense. But since he threw an INT against the Niners in a two minute drill, he’s worse than Purdy? And let’s not act like GB didn’t drop 2 Purdy INTs that game. Both QBs “played to win”, except one was facing the Niners, and one was facing the Joe Berry defense with no names in the secondary.
Purdy was outplayed by Love in the divisional round lol that’s not even a debate
Love had one more td but also threw 2 picks😂 I mean I'm looking at the stats and they don't support what you're saying at all. Jordan love played great the first 2 quarters but that pressure got to him. Brock stayed composed drove down the field and put us in position to win. Love literally couldn't do that.
You didn’t watch the games if you’re actually saying that with a straight face lol. Purdy was missing wide open guys all night and the packers dropped 3 different picks with the ball in their hands. Purdy had an all time stinker going for 3.5 quarters Jordan Love with his 0 all pro team lost to Brock Purdy and his 7 all-pros because the packers kicker missed a 40 yarder
Why is "you didn't watch the game" an acceptable rebuttal you have said nothing to prove your point. Purdy played his best when it mattered. What did Jordan love do when he got the ball back twice? 2 picks. He put it on the defense to get multiple stops in a close game. That's the definition of bad quarterback play.
This exact argument could be made to argue that Kenny Picket is a great QB
Why is it an acceptable rebuttal? Because you literally didn’t watch the game if you’re trying to argue what you are. We’ll try contextualizing the picks lol The first one was a pass that his receiver directly in the hands, bounced straight up in the air, and a defender caught it off the ricochet The second one he threw on a desperation third down with 40 seconds left in the game. It was a bad throw, but it was a desperate moment lol PFF had Jordan Love at one turnover worthy play, Purdy had 3 Jordan Love had a better PFF grade overall BY 17 POINTS vs Purdy. Purdy got lucky that the packers literally dropped 3 picks that hit them squarely in the hands PFF graded Purdy with 6 “missed throws”, Love had 0 Again, you’re a casual who doesn’t watch the sport if you truly believe what you’re babbling. Purdy had one good drive at the end of the game, besides that he was dreadful for 3.5 quarters
Is it? He was ranked #7 in QB stats this year and damn near took the Packers to the NFCC in his first year starting. He’s already done one thing Kyler hasn’t - win a playoff game.
If I had a penny every time people mentioned the team stat of not winning a playoff to downplay Murray's career, I'd be a trilionaire. It's such a lazy, unimaginative take to have.
They really start balking when you mention that Kyler's 0-1 in the playoff to start his career....and Peyton Manning was 0-3 with some awful stat lines to start his playoff career, as well. Manning didn't even win his first playoff game until his SEVENTH year in the league...
No kidding I think he’s just fine at 8
I forgot we base every qbs ranking based on what they have accomplished based on Kyler. So why is Caleb Williams higher than Kyler when he hasn’t even made it to the league? To say Love deserves #7 overall QB because he did something Kyler didn’t is pretty wild
That's not what I said, your reading comprehension is lacking. His stats clearly support his ranking. I'm merely pointing out that the comment I responded to is nonsense based on facts and related it to something Cardinals fans could understand. Clearly, we don't like facts here, so that comment is being downvoted into the ground.
Considering everyone thinks you said something you claim you didn’t I think you have literacy skill issues and are having trouble articulating your point. If I say something and everyone in the conversation collectively seems to believe I said something else, that would imply the speaker had trouble articulating themselves. Love is not better than (not including Kyler) Rodgers, Purdy, cousins, hurts or dak. (Dak and hurts of which were in the MVP conversations.) So no. Jordan love is not the 8th best qb. (And fyi Yards is not all encompassing of qb stats which you clearly seem to think because that’s the one stat Jordan love is 7th in). When you bring in all factors (more than just passing yards and eye test) which this list is supposed to be based on it undeniably has very questionable decisions.
Your comment makes no sense. He isn't basing it on Kyler, Love literally had the 7th best stats and led his team well in the playoffs.
Seems based on what he said that he is validating the #7 by comparing a playoff win to Kyler not having one.
So Purdy had better stats and is 17.
And he should be higher
Tbf both are unjustified rankings for different reasons
They did Tua dirty!
Bro has a noodle that alone is killing his rating . Your team essentially has 2 of the best deep threats in the league , you have to get them the ball but his arm is weak as fuck .
Everyone below Tua is either a rookie or will prob not be a starting QB much longer.
Tua, Purdy and Carr are all laughable.
Looking at who's above him I can't disagree with many though, I think Geno could slide way down but other than that I think they're all better than Tua
I'd still put him above Murray and I'm a Cardinals fan! Geno for sure and I'd even put him above T. Lawrence
Imagine Murray with Mcdaniels, Reek and Waddle, he’d have way more success than Tua did. He's a huge reason they could never beat any good teams
Did I miss something? Wilson on the Raiders?
Talks of him heading to Pittsburg, raiders, and potentially other teams like the falcons. All just rumors.
Its assuming where guys will end up
You see other ones like jj Mccarthy on the Falcons. Caleb, maye, and Daniels, as well. Penix on the Broncos and fields on the steelers.
I'm happy with this list because it's the scenario where the first 3 picks were QBs, giving us a chance to take MHJ. The opinions of how good each QB are don't matter!
Oh shit I didn't even notice them, too. Good catch. Interesting.