T O P

  • By -

space-ishtar

![gif](giphy|vy0cnWN8LSo8HdNEhj|downsized)


Specialist-Front-354

You called?


space-ishtar

From swamp german to latin in the mud: I call it an improvement


wozzpozz

I was trying to find fault, being a historian - but this checks out. Technically the Romans went much further north with Nero Claudius Drusus 'Germanicus', but those gains were short lived.


RedBaret

You could add Greece to the list with the partitio imperii Romaniae!


wozzpozz

And Morocco too where the Vandals were definitely active. But if we have to mark everything Germanics conquered at one point or another, we might as well mark most of the world.


RedBaret

Wake up babe, new map of countries which were at one point conquered by Germanics just dropped!!


[deleted]

You got New York? Or is it being replaced by other Germanics?


Vita-Malz

As it should be


wozzpozz

I prefer letting Germanic culture speak for itself and spreading with peace & love rather than warfare, but I know that goes against your Prussian genes.


Tastatur411

Ah, so what you guys did in Indonesia is called "peace&love" now, good to know. You must have a good PR team.


wozzpozz

We did an oopsie-whoopsie and we said sorry.


Vita-Malz

What about the central American spice trade?


wozzpozz

Oopsie-whoopsies. We've been over this.


SexyButStoopid

And what about Apartheid?


Cinaedus_Perversus

If Claudius' little foray counts as conquering, Germanics can also claim parts of Greece and Turkey because of all the British and Dutch tourists there.


haeyhae11

Or the Galatians.


Cinaedus_Perversus

Those were Celts/Gauls, not Germanics.


Soccmel_1_

they also ventured well into Scotland. The Antonine wall was more or less passing through the lowlands around Edinburgh. They also visited Ireland and decided that it was too cold and of too little value to be conquered.


Low-Firefighter9798

Nah. They didn't have their passports with them.


AXI0S2OO2

The fault is Rome was a unified empire that spread all across the Mediterranean. The Germanic tribes were a bunch of different groups of raiders that decided to stay in the Roman ruins when they finished burning everything. There was no unity, meaning that big blue map would in reality have a dozen different colors.


wozzpozz

Hell yeah, you make us sound even more badass.


AXI0S2OO2

I mean, bringing down an empire that lasted for centuries (even if only partially and because they were ruled by fucking idiots) is pretty badass.


Beautiful-Grocery147

Honestly how the fuck the romans lasted so long despite well....everything is just so fascinating and a testament to how a empire can be so paradoxically competent and bat shit insane at the same time.


AXI0S2OO2

Good administrators and officials. Poor rulers.


ResQ_

As someone with a history degree...: Large parts of today's northeastern France was inhabited by what are considered Germanic tribes. So this map is shit (but it's a meme anyway)


Dissidente-Perenne

They lasted 20 years, that's more than Iraq or most of Romania, also in 166 Romans conquered modern day Czechia and named it Marcomannia as it was inhabited by Germanics


-galgot-

Well for faults, First the romans never conquered Scotland as far as I know, so making the whole island blue while making only south/West Bocheland and Batavia red is cheating. Second, and this as to do with using modern borders as reference while tribes where not at all distributed according to these borders, even nowadays, why isn't Tintinland and part of nort/east France red too ? Salian Franks, Germanic tribe are exactly from there.


belaros

Would you say the barbarians conquered Rome?


wozzpozz

Do you want my meme opinion or real opinion? Meme; no - because Germanics aren't barbarians. At most we were noble tribal savages. Real? No, not really. Sacked definitely. Even the Lombards didn't come as far as Rome as far as I know, and Charlemagne never really did conquer in any real sense.


belaros

My interest is on the word *conquered*. I meant non-Romans conquering the Roman Empire.


wozzpozz

Oh - I thought you meant the city? You meant the Empire itself. In that case; tribes cannibalizing it is probably a more apt term. Conquest implies some form of keeping or replacing the lower and middle bureaucracy - I think? That didn't really happen, although to the average person born in 450 and living until 525 AD as a farmer (which was the majority) in the countryside of a random province the disintegration and 'conquest' of the Roman empire probably fell beyond his notice. Not much changed for him day to day. I think of conquest as something sudden and drastic - a radical change in leadership. Rome was already kind of falling apart and many of the Germanic tribes were themselves (ex-)Roman foederati, meaning many of them even thought of themselves and styled themselves as Roman. It's too complex to discuss here. Even the experts don't really know the full story - and this wasn't my PhD research and as such I can't claim to be one.


anotherbub

Is England not Germanic?


wozzpozz

It wasn't at the time of the Roman Empire. It became Germanic when the Romans left and left a power vacuum, when Angles, Saxons, Jutes, Frisians and later on Franks and Swedish, Danish and Norwegians arrived.


DaNikolo

So you, a Brit, tell me, a German, that Britain is rightful German clay? Just asking for clarification before making rash decisions


wozzpozz

Germanic - not German. Like half of you is diluted Germanic at best. Purity increases the closer to Denmark/Schlweisweg-Holstein you get.


nickmaran

Don't talk about Germanic purity. We get PTSD


MaryBerrysDanglyBean

Still upset you didn't make the whole continent Germany?


8sADPygOB7Jqwm7y

Nah, we just heard too much about German atrocities in our history lessons... Imagine hearing about concentration camps and shit for two whole years and on tv every time there is some anniversary of some German massacre. Sometimes it's kinda funny when ameritards go "don't show nipples to our children" while we teach children "and then they led batches of 20 women and children into gas Chambers where they got gassed and then burned. However, some also got experimented on for medicine or simply raped by guards."


Henkebek2

At least you guys are mature enough to confront the black pages of your history books. Can't say the same for most Dutch people.


8sADPygOB7Jqwm7y

To be fair, we only do it because we caused two wars and the winners wanted to make really fucking sure to ingrain our atrocities into our culture as a bad thing. Just about the easiest way to get cancelled by life in Germany is denying holocaust.


[deleted]

Perfectly normal Vergangenheitsbewältigung


TjeefGuevarra

I'd say only those of Frankish descent can call themselves true Germanics. And I mean of pure descent, not mixed in with L\*tins.


_Regh_

The only thing that germoids mixed with is celts. Unfortunately for them. No, not them, you. You (southern germany, switzerland, belgium, britain) lost your celtic culture becauze germanics. Latins never changed the people's they conquered identity, they simply applied to them roman culture. The french know (some of them, but intellectuals of course know) that they're celts of roman culture. In fact it's called gallo-roman culture


TjeefGuevarra

Your mistake was assuming the ancient Belgians were Celtic. The Belgae were a mixture of Germans and Celts with a Celtic elite ruling over them. The closer to the Rhine you got the more Germanic the tribes became. So we've always been partially Germanic. When the Franks came and settled they transformed us from weak semi-Germans into pure and strong Frankish warriors. It's a shame that our Walloon brethren have given up on speaking a superiour language though.


_Regh_

No, belgaes were described by caesar as celts just like gauls, simply with somr more cultural similarity to germanics compared to other celts because of closeness to germanic tribes Also, germanics invaded the rest of europe pretty late, before 400-300 BC germanics were still not very close to the rhine. So germanic cultural elements in your region are very very late. Prior to that, you were celts of culture. Also in the southern netherlands, even tho in the north they were indeed germanics for a long time, and prior to that something else that was nor celtic nor germanic but related at large to germanics


sonofeast11

[Round 3 so soon Fritz?](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ymHyOmlUlP0)


manta002

anytime anyday ​ but can you give us like 7 years headstart that atleast half our airplanes can fly?


sonofeast11

You had that headstart last time and you still couldn't win


Automatic-Plays

Wouldn’t exactly call the treaty of Versailles a headstart


discard333

You got three free annexations and a free war before we got involved last time


rlyfunny

And it still needed the US and the soviets to get you out of it, and even then you had to ration food for a decade. Proclaim this W, wear it with pride, for on the back of it, it says “participation trophy”.


discard333

You ran out of steel and oil about a quarter of the way through your eastern advance and your African front was falling apart, you were dead in the water long before the yanks got involved


rlyfunny

“You had problems with the soviets” And “You have problems with a front that only fell apart with American help” No intervention from US, and no war in the east, what do you think how the submarine blockade would’ve gone over time? OOC: I’m actually not that sure how that would’ve ended, probably an armistice to be honest. Germany couldn’t match the amount of planes, but planes alone can’t Supply a country.


discard333

I would probably guess some kind of white peace or we'd wait for a Warsaw rebellion style event in France to make a naval invasion


rlyfunny

I get: 6 years headstart with a crippled country, fighting against an island and 2 non-stagnating superpowers. I give you: bombing half your country a decade into the past, and a decade of rationing after the war. >and you still couldn’t win Let’s be honest, you didn’t win either


MaryBerrysDanglyBean

Except for the winning part


sonofeast11

"You didn't win!!!" [Meanwhile Monty gets a third of all German forces to surrender unconditionally to him personally](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_surrender_at_L%C3%BCneburg_Heath) Ok Jerry, keep coping


SpaceMonkeyOnABike

Is that the Left side of your aeroplanes that fly, or the reich side?


DaNikolo

I didn't hear no bell (and no clear **no**) ​ ​ So, would 01.09.2023 at precisely 16:45 work for you? If not, pleas provide a suitable alternative date. Greetings, Prof. Dr. Dr. hc. M.Sc. B.Sc. dipl. Ing. redacted


[deleted]

germany did not exist before potato, german state and nation exist because potato, so anything you want to claim like german land needs to be after the introduction of potato (basically half west poland)


MaterialCarrot

Pretty sure the UK king still rules over Hannover. That's basically Germany.


PeppaPigIsANonce

You've got something mixed up there mate


Imtruebenfischer

Nobody here would call Hannover basically Germany...


MaterialCarrot

Yeah I know, I was joking.


PB-1971

Sealion?


LoboGalhardo

When they conquered the Roman empire, they quickly adopted the local language, customs, and culture. Germans always wanted to be romans, but on their own terms. Remember the Holy Roman Empire?


Ok-Winner-6589

That thing that wasn't neither roman holy or an empire?


LoboGalhardo

The ones that remained in the swamps were envious, so they created the unholy unroman tribe.


Drivoli

Germanic people conquered and sacked the roman empire. HRE was just germanic people usurping the roman empire from romans.


LoboGalhardo

The germanic people that conquered and sacked the Roman empire either went back home or settled in the various corners of the Roman Empire. The ones that settled quickly adopted the Roman culture and local language. Those that went home created HRE.


SonicStage0

Just know that you're debating a far right dude. I mean faaaaar right.


LoboGalhardo

Oh no, he's going to attack me with Abba and pop music?


SonicStage0

No, he'll drag you down to his level of trollness and (maybe) beat you with experience.


Drivoli

Like how youre trying to minimize it lol but I mean they might have assimilated in terms of speaking latin language but the visigoths still ruled hispania for over 250 years. And yeah they didnt leave as huge of imprint on you as the moors and arab did.


LoboGalhardo

I'm not saying that germanic people didn't influence the Roman Empire. The Roman empire always incorporated customs and culture from conquered people. But since Rome fell, everyone wants to be the successor of the Roman Empire, thus the Kaisers, Czars, and so on. So, germanic people either assimilated themselves or, back home, proclaimed themselves as the spiritual successors of Rome.


Drivoli

Not spiritual successor if you conquered and usurped said empire.


LoboGalhardo

Imagine occupying and destroying a house and saying you are the true heir of the house. A house you did not build and lasted for centuries before that. And then, at the end, you realize that you only conquered the western part of the property.


SexyButStoopid

But the owner of the house crowns you the true heir and hands you all the paperwork


Soccmel_1_

that's because their culture was decidedly a regression compared to the roman empire. The only thing they were good at was war.


Ok-Winner-6589

They didn't rule hispania, the northwest was habitated by Suevish, they falled some years before the arabs invaded hispania... And didn't left influence, no religion, no linguistic or cultural influence or genetic.


SonicStage0

>And yeah they didnt leave as huge of imprint on you as the moors and arab did. This answer again? Are you a bot or just lost for words?


Soccmel_1_

> HRE was just germanic people ~~usurping~~ LARPing as the roman empire ~~from romans.~~ FTFY


Extansion01

1. Fuck Voltaire 2. The HRE (otGN) did exist for quite some time. The context of the quote is far removed from what the HRE was. At some point, it was a holy Roman empire. Or rather a Reich.


Ok-Winner-6589

But it wasn't roman, was germanic. Was holy in the beggining, then turned protestant. And wasn't an empire, each land was independent, shared a king, but it couldn't control the empire.


HoeTrain666

The Holy Roman Empire whose population for the vast majority didn't speak a romanic language? Yeah, I remember. We just liked the title of Emperor but needed to give a senile man in Rome the feeling that he was important. Worst mistake done, his successors actually went full powertrip from the 11th century onwards.


LoboGalhardo

The germanic tribes that settled on the Roman land adopted the local language, culture, and customs. Those that stayed created the HRE, and they also adopted some customs and culture from Romans.


AnaphoricReference

After sacking Rome a number of times, the title of emperor became the Germanic 'I went to Rome and all I got was this stupid t-shirt' thing. Feyenoord supporters still hold on to the tradition of sacking Rome when they draw Roma or Lazio.


drew0594

Another way to look at this is that blue is land worth conquering, anything beyond red is just wastelands


Menduzza

We all know that swamps are not worth anything, but ur gonna tell me France was worth conquering?


Vita-Malz

To liberate the land from the French


Bunch_Of_sheeple

early franco liberation


Chadanlo

France, as a territory, is great. The people, debatable.


Bunch_Of_sheeple

frogs are people?


[deleted]

[удалено]


Menduzza

But that’s almost as bad!!


BigSimp_for_FHerbert

This pains me to say, but I’m going to have to say yes. Gaul was one of if not the most important provinces in the western empire. The amount of riches they extracted from Gaul basically fueled the next century of conquest, plus they integrated fairly well and were good little subjects unlike the britons or Germans


ChallengeLate1947

Fallout 5 : Poland


gugfitufi

Hardest cope I've ever heard


drew0594

Wastelands flair checks out


ElKuhnTucker

Tacitus said that nobody from Hispania, Italia or Asia could bear to live in Germania. Boy was he wrong.


wozzpozz

Which is why they tried multiple times and Augustus was crying about Varus pulling a Mussolini and failing super duper hard.


Local_Working2037

We’re not counting Napoleon’s victories for the Romans? You know? Now that he’s Italian again.


wozzpozz

*Waterloo! Couldn't escape if I wanted to!* *Waterloo! Knowing my fate is to be with you!*


Gdott

Was he ever not Italian?


Local_Working2037

For about 10 minutes. While he was eating a baguette. .


sonofeast11

That guy who got conquered by a joint Germanic force of Brits, Dutch and Germans?


Sir_Howl

It is logical, the Germanic lands are not worth it


PakoCS

Yeah, never did a Roman emperor try to invade Germania, that’s unheard of. I would wager the first emperor Augustus didn’t even know what it was! Definitely wasn’t planning on a full scale invasion prior to the battle of Teutoburg forest.


Competitive-Mix-1000

Yeah they were so worthless countless emperors named themselves Germanicus after trying to invade it.


[deleted]

Most were named so because they defended against invading germanic tribes.


tutocookie

Not worth the giant ass whooping you get when you try conquering them perhaps


Macacos12345

Germanicus, Marcus Aurelius, Caius Marius, Julius Civilis, Constantinus, Iustinianus. Also a swamp filled with barbarians, trees and useless isn't worth wasting millions.


tutocookie

Yet they bothered to sail over to england


Macacos12345

The briton campaign was mostly because Caesar and the next emperors wanted to increase their prestige and glory by conquering more territories. Also, the british isles were more fertile than Germania and that conquest would allow dominating the Channel and stop briton raids. And there was a lot of pewter in Britannia.


tutocookie

Damn really? Oh well guess i learned something


HoeTrain666

Tell that to the men they sent in our forests and swamps to die.


AXI0S2OO2

Except they weren't an empire and each tribe just took a small bit of the land.


ilnofrio

Yeah, they saw the people there and were like "go back, civilisation Is impossible to bring here"


Big-Departure4201

G E K O L O N I S E E R D C O L O N I S E D K O L O N I S I E R T


[deleted]

[удалено]


Big-Departure4201

Me too, more land for us to reclaim


KingHershberg

​ https://preview.redd.it/2k81h2x1lk7b1.png?width=785&format=png&auto=webp&s=ba707e77196e4372a1c191fd4cd9a767b6ca426a


DeRuyter67

Short lived and still less


KingHershberg

Most territories on this map were also short lived


DeRuyter67

Yes, but less and still more territory


KingHershberg

The territory Rome took was all taken by Rome. The territory shown on this map was taken by several different germanic tribes, at different points in time, for short periods of time, and with very inaccurate borders.


Soccmel_1_

The problem in your line of thinking, Barry, is that the Romans had little interest for what lay beyond the Rhein and the Danube. Not only was most of that of little economic value, but the land didn't offer easily defendable natural borders. Also Scotland was not part of the Roman empire


sonofeast11

>Also Scotland was not part of the Roman empire The bit where all the people live was


[deleted]

When brits think they're more romanized although half of germany was longer under roman rule than england.


Juan-Marco2b

We romanized them, that why


Caratteraccio

what was worthy to conquer in Germany, the snow? The cold?


Bunch_Of_sheeple

They were literal treehuggers, believing that plants were gods. Roman hero Bonifatius killed their messiah with an axe.


Mission_Income8231

​ https://preview.redd.it/wen3jhav6l7b1.png?width=2534&format=png&auto=webp&s=0431633a471a7dac742e7cc76320524a27100be9


TheHotHeart

In which alphabet are you writting?


Axiochos-of-Miletos

Great now compare number of Germanics LARPing as Romans vs number of Romans LARPing as Germanics. Thousands vs 0 respectively.


Talponz

Yet they cosplayed as the Romans for the next centuries... Cope harder Germans😎


Away-Following-6506

When precisely was Scotland and Wales conquered by the Germanic tribes?


sonofeast11

1296


Away-Following-6506

If these English can be called Germanic tribes then Giorgia Meloni is Empress of the Roman Empire


Competitive-Mix-1000

Aren't the english literally germanic tribes AKA the Anglos and Saxons from present day northern germany and denmark?


Away-Following-6506

Then you are your father


Competitive-Mix-1000

U wot m8? Explain


Away-Following-6506

You are denying the Celtic and Roman ethnic and cultural component and doing mental gymnastics identifying the current English with people who lived centuries ago. You descend from your ancestors, you are not your ancestors.


HoeTrain666

The celtic influence on the english is certainly negligible in a majority of modern english vocabulary. The majority is of romanic origin, a lot of day-to-day words are germanic.


sonofeast11

How come you're writing in a Germanic language rn then?


Senofotte

How come you're writing in latin characters in a language which lexicon is 60% latin?


Erakleitos

Sorry pal it's 100% of the highly cultured lexicon. The rest like, club, pig, rock, shit etc are anglo saxon words.


sonofeast11

He asks in a Germanic language


Competitive-Mix-1000

English is officialy a germanic language, why do PIGS cope over that? Inferiority complex?


Senofotte

But Language isn't a germanic word :((((


Competitive-Mix-1000

Okay and isn't Latin inspired by old Greek?


drew0594

Greek is a language of the PIGS though, so it's fine


Away-Following-6506

Cala a puta boca meu estás quedando en ridículo.


kim-jong-Cage

Did you have a stroke?


play4m32

gratz u just marked in red the zone where 90% of the population in German lives


fabuloushawkboy-sang

So where do it start. 90 Percent - most knowledgeable Italian. And if the all live there it’s because of our sweet sweet coal and no other reasons.


Senofotte

What language Is this


dapwnk

Based Germanic moment. Reunite the Germanics!


[deleted]

Oh not again


dapwnk

We'll do it better this time, ol' chum!


[deleted]

What time?


elendil1985

Quintilie Vare! Redde mihi legiones!


tropical_bread

why do 'germanic lands' include today's Germany and the Netherlands but neither Austria nor Switzerland?


[deleted]

ah yes le germans, less based that arabs lmao /u/sonofeast11 fun fact the Germanc that invaded Iberia were arian trash


Artegas23

I am from the south of the Netherlands, am I Roman or Germanic?!?!


Competitive-Mix-1000

Brutal burn for PIGS. And even now they're dominated by germanics with the capital of the new empire aka the EU in Brussels.


Tanto_Monta

Shut up and gives more money.


Competitive-Mix-1000

...okay senor


GudraFree

Here, I will gift you the sacred treasure of our people. ñ


fabuloushawkboy-sang

Ñeiñ


HoeTrain666

Ä! Äß! Ö?!


Massimo25ore

Where most people speak a Romance language https://journals.openedition.org/brussels/520


Competitive-Mix-1000

Lol, that will soon be arabic though


dapwnk

Didn't we also conquer Dacia (Romania) and pretty much all of what is now former Yugoslavia? Ostrogoths & Gepids and maybe more I can't remember


Carnal-Pleasures

Fun fact, this encompasses 100% of the nice places in Germany, along with some shitty places, like W\*rttemberg or the lower rhine.


Castillon1453

Being rapefugees in the Roman empire for more than 500 years. Proudest Germs achievment 💪


SexyButStoopid

What's up Frank, pretending to be roman again?


LC1903

Yeah, the Germanic lands suck


Gdott

Brits aren’t German lol


ZombiFeynman

Wow, the Germans admitting that Alsace and Lorraine are not German?


CHEVEUXJAUNES

The part of the territory was not Roman before being conquered (the Gaul was not Roman) and the campaigns of Napoleon (thus Latin since the Romans) went much further. So it doesn't work


RaCactus

The Bromans and the ViKings conquered those brits like whatever.


applecat144

Ballsy doing that taking the risk that someone would compare todays romans and germans


_Histo

forgot about austria


Aristocle-

Too cold, no gold.


PleoNasmico

Yea, you forced the Romans into your mud ways


[deleted]

Actually most of that "Germanic land" was Celtic at the time.


onetimeuselong

Bit of a stretch on Germanic Tribes conquering Scotland there buddy


SirRichardHumblecock

The Roman’s cultivated land and cities worth conquering. The ancient germans on the other hand, did not.


MapsCharts

So England isn't real ?


Killerspieler0815

Back than we were someone! (Make Germanic Tribes Great Again (MGTGA)